8 ms·
It could be argued Apple created an illegal rules which require a violation to raise them in the justice system
by paulryanrogers 6y ago
It could be argued Apple created an illegal rules which require a violation to raise them in the justice system
- ubermonkey 6y agoI mean, it could also be argued that the moon is made of green cheese, with roughly equal fidelity to real life.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoSo the possibility of Apple's rules being illegal is equivalent to the moon being made of cheese? I used the phrase "can be argued" because I think the idea has enough merit to warrant being tested in court. These companies certainly have enough money and market influence to justify exploring it.
- ubermonkey 6y agoI have yet to see any serious, respectable theory under which Apple's App Store rules would be illegal AT ALL. People keep yammering about "monopoly," but they have no such thing. Closed platforms with rules for participation are utterly normal and utterly legal. (What's really amazing is the arguments I see -- presumably from either very young or very ill-informed people -- that this is "just like" Microsoft in the 90s.)
- ascagnel_ 6y agoA judge should be the one to decide if the rules are valid or not. But, for now, this action is entirely on Epic. Epic broke the rules, Apple (and the court, for that matter) said that they would continue to sign and publish Epic's Fortnite updates if they brought Fortnite back in line with their contract, and Epic not only refused to do so, they submitted more Fortnite updates that broke the rules, before eventually entirely removing Apple's IAP from the iOS version of Fortnite (just before Epic's developer account was banned). One other thing to consider: even if the IAP rules are invalid, Apple still can decide who it wants to do business with (unless the court rules iOS an essential facility, which basically invalidates the entire closed ecosystem business model, which would really up-end the tech world).
- paulryanrogers 6y agoI don't think you can go before a judge without having the rules enforced against you.
- ascagnel_ 6y agoI think Epic initially violating the rules and getting Fortnite taken down initially would have been enough of an action to justify the suit. Epic willfully not coming back into compliance with their contract is entirely on them, and lends more credence to actions Apple take against them.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoA judge can't decide that until someone actually breaks them and then takes that to court. Someone needs to have "standing" to challenge the rule.
- colejohnson66 6y agoDid you miss the part where Apple and the judge said that Epic could remove the “offending” code and they’d be let back on without the case being dismissed?
- nodamage 6y agoThis is incorrect. Epic already has standing from the fact that Apple has collected $300 million in Fortnite IAP fees. They could have sued to recover those fees without also getting Fortnite removed from the App Store.