3 ms·
The predictions in the article are too generic. I don't think they have an accurate model to predict the exact probability of each side effect. Extending this
by gus_massa 6y ago
The predictions in the article are too generic. I don't think they have an accurate model to predict the exact probability of each side effect.
Extending this model to predict if a drug will cure a disease is very difficult. Side effects are very generic like "vomiting" and a wide set of drugs cause "vomiting" for a wide set of reasons.
If a drug is useful against a disease sometimes is very specific, for example if the drug makes enzyme X of one virus or bacteria use the drug instead of another substance Y, but it does not confuse the human version of X. Or if it blocks the enzyme X of one virus or bacteria, but it doesn't block the human version of X.
Some drugs are very generic, like some antibiotics, and sometimes you can use broad classifications like Gram positive or negative bacteria. But in many drugs the effect is more specific.
Note that the article was not published in "Nature" but in "Nature Communications". Nature has created a bunch of journals https://www.nature.com/siteindex#journals-N https://www.nature.com/siteindex#journals-N that have a less strict level than the original "Nature" journal and I have seen a few dubious articles published in these journals. I don't remember something specific about "Nature Communications", but a general personal warning about "Nature X".
- JPLeRouzic 6y agoThanks for this very detailed answer!
- gus_massa 6y agoYou may be interested in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_structure%E2%80%93activity_relationship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_structure%E2%80%9... It's a family of methods to try to predict the properties of molecules using computer, in particular from similar molecules. There are a thousand of variants that are useful in some cases. It can be used for an initial filtering or to get some ideas, but it can not replace [1] a clinical trial. [1] For now, and probably for a long time. Nobody know what will happen in a few decades/centuries.