3 ms·
Anandtech should have an article with primary source instead of this estimate. ( Assuming they are allow to publish it ) 1. It is no use discussing yield % wit
by ksec 6y ago
Anandtech should have an article with primary source instead of this estimate. ( Assuming they are allow to publish it )
1. It is no use discussing yield % without putting the die size. It is defect density per cm2 that is the most important factor. ( Your yield percentage change due to design and die size )
2. 5nm defect density is better than 7nm comparing them in the same stage of development. i.e Very Good.
3. TSMC is actually open and transparent with their progress and metrics. Both in Investor Meetings and Technical Forum. ( And with their business partners.... something most other Foundry aren't doing as well )
4. Most of these calculations in the comment are in BOM cost, which completely ignores the Design Cost ( Billion ) and Research Cost, in terms of Apple that is Architecture Cost, and IP Cost such IMG, FPGA ( Lattice ) etc that are paid per unit. ( Edit: And testing, packaging cost, but it is relatively small )
5. Hopefully with these figures in mind, you will see how Qualcomm is fighting hard to compete, considering they will have to sell it with at least 50% margin. ( And why Nvidia dont necessarily want to be in the Mobile SoC market, as suggested in the ARM- Nivdia discussions previously )
6. And then you should realise, how the ARM royalty portion is not an important cost factor. ( As per all ARM or RISC-V discussion on HN )
7. You should also notice the trend of Wafer Pricing. Hopefully that will finally shape your view on Moore's law.
- starfallg 6y ago>ARM royalty portion is not an important cost factor That's exactly the reason why Nvidia's pending acquisition of ARM is so suspect. There's not much money to be made in ARM's business model hence it really only makes sense if they plan on exploiting the synergy of ARM + Nvidia tech in a way that only ownership of the company allows them to.
- baybal2 6y agoNo, an option to hike royalties is very much on the table given ARM's very liberal fees by industry standards. High volume, high margin fat lambs like Qualcomm merrily eating grass around, or obscenely high margin high-end network chips would've ended on a dinner plate much, much earlier if ARM had an American business culture.
- starfallg 6y agoSoftbank can do that themselves if that was the plan.
- Tostino 6y agoSoftBank needs cash now, not later. Their horrible bets all got called this year.
- starfallg 6y agoSoftbank is getting just $2bn right now. And the next payment at closing is only $10bn, the rest is in stock. The whole Softbank needs cash now to fill the WeWork hole doesn't add up. They could have made more cash with an IPO, in similar timescales.