2 ms·
Security has a big dirty secret: it's hard. If what you're doing is easy, it ain't security. Simple as that. TOFU works if you actually do it properly. That me
by globular-toast 6y ago
Security has a big dirty secret: it's hard. If what you're doing is easy, it ain't security. Simple as that.
TOFU works if you actually do it properly. That means verifying the fingerprint of the key you just received out of band once time. Now you can trust that key. How many people do this? Even IT professionals just routinely say yes for new ssh keys without checking. That's not TOFU, that's just trusting that you are not under attack which is not security.
TOFU is actually just a degenerative form of web of trust anyway where you just automatically say "I do not trust" to the above so that each new trusted key needs to be established individually. But it does make it easier. Easier to not be doing security at all.
- shp0ngle 6y agoWhen I observed people actually using Enigmail, they just do "search for that person keys" in enigmail, which did search at MIT or whatever, and picked the first (and only) result. (Again, that was before PEP/TOFU. In my former company, we had PGP as a company mandate. Everyone hated that, and it never ever worked properly for group e-mails, no matter how hard we tried to hack it. Not sure what is the experience now.)