3 ms·
IMHO it's the wrong problem to fix. My view is that the best way to speed up the transition to clean energy is to vastly increase demand for electricity. This c
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
IMHO it's the wrong problem to fix. My view is that the best way to speed up the transition to clean energy is to vastly increase demand for electricity. This causes people to invest in new energy production. Which at this point pretty much means more wind and solar gets added. The more we have of it the less important remaining coal and gas plants are. Many countries are nearly done shutting down their coal plants. Gas plants are still being built but the economics for that are also not looking great at this point. Once we have a robust clean energy grid, these will probably be mothballed as well.
Data centers are already mostly running on clean energy and in so far they are not, all big cloud providers have committed to being carbon neutral. So, if you have some solar on your roof, you basically could be browsing the web without expending any carbon. So, open some more tabs and stop worrying.
In any case, the web is a tiny portion of our overall energy consumption so it's not really worth prioritizing this for optimization. Best case, it won't make a lot of difference. Worst case you are sacrificing design and UX for something that ultimately doesn't matter in terms of tangible results.
Of course, there's nothing wrong with making laptop batteries last longer, making laptops run cooler, and delivering a web site that is fast and responsive.
- ajkjk 6y agoThis is a mild example of a type of argument that I like to call "destructionist": to save something, destroy it as fast as possible so we have to deal with the consequences sooner. I've seen it applied to climate change: save the earth by ruining it! It's fallacious, though. If you can save it later, you can save it sooner, and if it's worth saving at all, sooner is better. It's not an argument for a _solution_, it's an argument for _finding the will to implement the solution_ -- and it's the "minimally moral" argument for that. "Rather than do anything that takes moral strength, just make the problem worse and let other people deal with it!" The only worse stance is to no longer want a solution at all! Of course it does seem like the real problem isn't figuring out what to do, but convincing people to care enough to do it. But our collective human intellect ought be able to do better than this.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoIt's an economic argument; you are making a moralistic argument. Economics have achieved more in the last five years than decades of moral outrage over climate change. I'm simply stating that increased demand for energy is currently being met (almost exclusively) through clean energy. Speeding that process up through more demand (which we have anyway) also speeds up the process of shutting down dirty capacity. This is why coal is rapidly disappearing from most countries still operating coal plants. Unthinkable ten years ago, and yet nearly completed in some countries right now. Even the US is on a clear path to probably be completely coal free very soon. The problem is not the demand but the dirty and expensive supply. I'm simply arguing to fix the supply problem by flooding the market with clean alternatives. The fastest way to do that is simply increase demand.
- mrpopo 6y ago> My view is that the best way to speed up the transition to clean energy is to vastly increase demand for electricity. No. Historically, and globally, when electricity demand increases, electricity sources stack up. We may create more clean energy that way, and that will increase the percentage of renewables in the energy mix, but the atmosphere doesn't care about percentages. It cares about how many tonnes of carbon are released by the existing electricity sources that need to be shut down. The last thing we need is another source for more electricity demand. Electrifying transportation alone will increase demand more than enough for your dream market investment magic.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoHistorically we replace expensive sources of something with cheap sources of something. As demand increases we source the best/cheapest version to meet that new demand. The energy market is no different. The vast majority of new capacity on the grid is coming from wind and solar. As the supply of clean energy increases, suppliers actually decommission and shut down more expensive existing capacity. That's why coal plants are going out of business in lots of places and why some new gas plants are not utilized at 100% and instead kept around only to address peak demand. This is enabled by a growing demand for and a supply of clean electricity at a lower price than what they can produce with legacy plants. Countries with growing economies tend to have a growing electricity market and a shrinking proportion of dirty energy. So, KWH goes up, CO2 goes down. The number of GWH from coal in Germany has actually gone down in recent years. While gas grew a little to offset that, much more growth came from re-newables. So, the CO2 production has been going down year on year. The amount of gas consumed per year in Germany is still substantial of course but not really growing at this point. Accelerated growth in the energy market increases the pace at which energy providers invest in new capacity. This in turn speeds up the process of de-commissioning economically non viable plants. Electrifying transport indeed adds a couple of tens of percent but it will take quite long to get there. If you drive 10000 miles in a year, that adds about 2.5GWH to your yearly energy bill (assuming 200 miles/50kwh of battery in your car). That's ~25% of the energy usage of an average house hold (in the US). But it will take quite some time before all households have EVs. 25% growth over 2 decades is not that much. Also a lot of that demand will be met by people putting solar on their own roofs, which technically shrinks the grid demand and overall energy market.