2 ms·
Graham Hancock has some wacky ideas, but is always (and unusually) careful to distinguish fact from speculation. (And his wife's photos are excellent.) It is a
by ncmncm 6y ago
Graham Hancock has some wacky ideas, but is always (and unusually) careful to distinguish fact from speculation. (And his wife's photos are excellent.)
It is a circular argument that extinctions coincide with arrival of humans: that humans arrived at that time is an assumption, and one that is losing credibility. Anyway, as noted, you also need to explain why humans didn't wipe out African megafauna (no, wariness doesn't), and also why Clovis culture disappeared suddenly across the continent. One may doubt they starved immediately after wiping out the last of their prey.
You can quibble all you like about nanodiamond crystallography and carbon granules, but sharp platinum peaks at 200x above background, found at dozens of sites, need better explanation. It is curious--telling, even--that critics dwell on osmium isotope ratios and never mention platinum.
As was explained in connection with the K-T extinction event that attracted similar derision from geologists who had to retire before it got a fair hearing, anything that happened, can.
- ncmncm 6y agoIt is also telling that we find certain bolides to have an osmium isotope ratio in the range they consider a problem--and they know about those.