3 ms·
With passwords "broken," US rolls out Internet identity plan
- iuguy 16y agoReading the comments there's some very strange people out there. The long and short of it is that this is a state-driven, private sector managed federated identity scheme. Traditional authentication mechanisms such as OpenID are not tied to you. That is to say, one minute you could be Bob Bobness, then the next Dave Daveness and there's no way you'd know. With this there'd be a level of verification to say actually you are Bob Bobness. As long as it's voluntary I don't see a problem with it and I think there could be many practical applications in banking and for government web sites for example. For the rest of us, I think we're happy with OpenID and our fictitious alter egos being linked to other fictitious alter egos :)
- gte910h 16y agoThe issues with monolithic schemes like this are like using your SSN for identifiers: Once the authentication is out there, it is a royal pain to get a new one if the old one is compromised.
- AndrewDucker 16y agoWith multiple different providers, I'm happy with it. I can be "Andrew Ducker - Certified by the UK government", but also "Samael, certified by Slashdot.org", depending on where I'm logging into, and what I'm up to.
- drdaeman 16y ago> providers Excuse me, but I'm against this very term being applied to identities. I possess my own identity and while I'm fine with others acknowledging and certifying this fact, I'm totally against others being "providers" of my identity.
- ChuckMcM 16y agoWhen Google was struggling with various people being locked out of email and not being able to get back in (without an alternate channel its really hard to verify you are who you are without a bad actor in the loop) I proposed a project for creating an identity token. I was playing with the Yubikey [1] as a possible approach. I certainly think something like that has the basic concepts, physical possession of the device which can be queried to provide strong identity verification. It was amusing (in a greek tragedy sort of way) to watch the conversation get de-railed by reductio ad absurdum arguments about perfect security. When in fact it would benefit over 80% and perhaps as many as 95% of the Internet users to have something like this. Still have the business plan. Its a bit capital intensive since it functions best when everyone has it, but the basics were build the base system in a "open" documented kind of way (so that folks could verify for themselves it wasn't snake oil), create a licenseable fob capability that is compatible with a variety of communication mechanisms (this was pretty straight forward). Have a 'key' implementation cost less than $5/key in quantity going to less then $1/key (Difficult but doable I believe) and three key partnerships. The 'competitors' are soft systems which are implemented on handheld devices or other token schemes. Russell Coker wrote up a good summary set [2]. The 'secret' sauce of this effort, or perhaps the key learning that makes it different from other systems, is how it deals with key theft and alternate identities. Great systems problem! [1] http://www.yubico.com/yubikey http://www.yubico.com/yubikey [2] http://etbe.coker.com.au/2010/03/15/security-tokens/ http://etbe.coker.com.au/2010/03/15/security-tokens/