3 ms·
But of course it defies basic economics to suggest you can make a society—as opposed to specific oligarchs—richer through non-free, non-market labor. That’s whe
by anigbrowl 6y ago
But of course it defies basic economics to suggest you can make a society—as opposed to specific oligarchs—richer through non-free, non-market labor. That’s where it helps to have an author write the essays who isn’t an economist!
You can't take a free society and make it more prosperous by the institution of slavery, but if you have a thinly-populated continent and eager export markets to play with you can certainly generate great profits, howbeit unevenly distributed and with the slave class excluded completely from per-capita considerations because they are themselves considered property.
This whole post seems like a rather forced and tendentious diversion from the topic.
- rayiner 6y ago> You can't take a free society and make it more prosperous by the institution of slavery, but if you have a thinly-populated continent and eager export markets to play with you can certainly generate great profits, howbeit unevenly distributed and with the slave class excluded completely from per-capita considerations because they are themselves considered property. This is true! But it probably doesn’t support the assertion that “out of slavery — and the anti-black racism it required — grew nearly everything that has truly made America exceptional: it’s economic might, its industrial power...” The 1619 project makes a ton of very good points. But it also makes a bunch of over-the-top assertions. But it can’t back those up. Ignoring those is a motte-and-bailey defense of the work. > This whole post seems like a rather forced and tendentious diversion from the topic. It’s on my mind because I have kids and the 1619 project will be this generation’s People’s History.