3 ms·
I can't speak for anybody else, but I am bothered by the idea that people read A People's History largely uncritically, and then, their studies complete, go on
by karaterobot 6y ago
I can't speak for anybody else, but I am bothered by the idea that people read A People's History largely uncritically, and then, their studies complete, go on to act as though they were de facto experts on U.S. history.
Studying history (even as a non-historian) is impossible unless you are constantly revising your views, and that's not possible if you only know one source.
I'm sure there are plenty of people who read Howard Zinn critically, as part of a "balanced diet" of other sources. However, I think that among the type of people who have only read one general history of the U.S. since high school, but are still happy to preach to you from it, A People's History of the United States is probably the most popular selection.
- UncleMeat 6y agoIt isn't necessarily about balance. One can carry a leftist view of history and still find that there is way more to modern scholarship than Zinn provided.
- andrewprock 6y agoIn my experience, you'll find more uncritical experts in the realm of WWII aficionados. The number of WWII buffs who are unable to grasp history dwarf the relative minority who use Zinn as their singular lens of understanding. See also: people who watched a Ken Burns documentary
- InitialLastName 6y agoWhat else would you recommend as part of this balanced diet of sources on US history? For starters, presumably, the founding documents, but after that (and Zinn) I haven't come across a lot of accessible general histories in general discussion. One could perhaps compensate with the AAA biographies of famous presidents and the like (David McCullough, Doris Kearns Goodwin, Robert Caro etc) but that doesn't really get you an alternate narrative arc.