3 ms·
Except that one of the primary criticisms is that the primary sources are edited heavily and misleadingly. I have particularly little sympathy for that, because
by rayiner 6y ago
Except that one of the primary criticisms is that the primary sources are edited heavily and misleadingly. I have particularly little sympathy for that, because one of the things you learn as a lawyer is that using a misleading quote or omission destroys your credibility in an adversarial system like legal proceedings. Your opponent will invariably provide the missing context in response and make you look like a liar. If a history book takes liberties (for example, in one passage, using an ellipses to connect sentences in two completely different documents written two days apart) that I wouldn’t in legal practice, that’s a huge red flag.
- jahaja 6y agoWell, since you so lackadaisically dismiss a rather impressive book with a single paragraph, and remembering that you're one of HN's resident status-quo apologist that really like to google up heavily cherry-picked links to your arguments - it would surely be appropriate to do so now as well?