4 ms·
A calorie's a calorie's a calorie. The food being cheap doesn't suddenly make it more fattening. You can be skinny on a diet of birthday cake if you wanted to.
by Spivak 6y ago
A calorie's a calorie's a calorie. The food being cheap doesn't suddenly make it more fattening. You can be skinny on a diet of birthday cake if you wanted to.
* Not being sure that the next meal is coming means you have to pack on some lbs to reach the point where you can go a few days without a square meal.
* The not actually getting the next meal makes you ravenously hungry when it comes even if on average you're overeating. It's why people with EDs aren't automatically skinny -- if you restrict and then binge you can/will gain weight.
- hirundo 6y agoThere is a large difference in satiety between, say, 1000 calories of steak versus potato chips. This has a large effect on what you eat later, despite what you might want.
- Spivak 6y ago1000% true! And your body isn’t stupid, it knows when you deny it things and makes you crave them.
- EForEndeavour 6y agoIf you agree that the above comment is 1000% true, do you also stand by your earlier claim that "a calorie's a calorie's a calorie"?
- Weebs 6y agoThis actually isn't fully true, we don't digest all kinds calories equally. Generally speaking, yes, the most important factor in body weight is the total amount of calories consumed. Whether they are proteins, fats, complex carbs, or simple carbs, and when you consume them during the day, effects how much of that energy actually gets stored in the body. https://www.strongerbyscience.com https://www.strongerbyscience.com has an article somewhere on this, and it's not well tested yet, but we're starting to see some scientific evidence to back this up.
- Spivak 6y agoThe question isn’t whether the effect exists. It would be incredibly surprising to discover that our bodies absorb literally every single food exactly the same. The question is whether the effect is large enough to actually matter. And maybe it does, maybe there is a magic diet that allows you to eat well above your TDEE without gaining weight but nobody has found it yet.
- klmadfejno 6y ago> A calorie's a calorie's a calorie. This is a very bad meme. There's many factors that influence how much weight you may gain besides calories consumed. At the more obvious end of the spectrum, if you eat corn, and poop out undigested corn, that's definitely not a calorie nor a calorie nor a calorie.
- Spivak 6y agoOn the margins you’re absolutely right. But for basically everyone it literally doesn’t matter. Nobody’s diet is precise enough to play these games. Every diet that’s effective is CACO. Use whatever structure you need to actually accomplish it. If it means no carbs, vegetarianism, Atkins, WeightWatchers then good on you. Calorie tracking is a bitch and if you have a rule of thumb that works for you then enjoy it.
- EForEndeavour 6y agoYou've been vigorously defending your position all over this thread without relying on specific scientific evidence. Can you provide further reading to convince us that the mantra "a calorie is a calorie" is useful to guide the modification of diet for weight loss and health? For what it's worth, here are two peer-reviewed articles that contradict that idea. The thermodynamic truism that "a calorie is a calorie" is true because it's a tautology, but misses the point almost entirely. EDIT: "a calorie is a calorie" is about as useful and relevant as saying "the key is to earn more than you spend" in the context of trying to save money, or raise yourself out of poverty. Technically absolutely true, but woefully unhelpful. --- 1. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5639963/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5639963/ "Diets high in protein and/or low in carbohydrate produced an ≈2.5-kg greater weight loss after 12 wk of treatment. Neither macronutrient-specific differences in the availability of dietary energy nor changes in energy expenditure could explain these differences in weight loss." --- 2. https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/79/5/899S/4690223 https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/79/5/899S/4690223 "Over a million calories are consumed a year yet weight changes to only a small extent; there must be mechanisms that balance energy intake and expenditure. As obesity reflects only a small malfunctioning of these mechanisms, there is a need to understand the control of energy balance and how to prevent the regaining of weight after it has been lost. By itself, decreasing calorie intake will have a limited short-term influence."
- smilliken 6y agoThere's a thermodynamic upper bound on the energy you can extract from a dietary calorie. In that sense, the physical sense, a calorie is a calorie. In the dietary sense, calories are NOT equal. It's easy to change a person's body mass by changing their diet while keeping calories the same. Mixing simple carbohydrates with fat is an effective way to get our metabolism to generate body fat. Simple carbohydrates in general, really, since our body is forced to process them into fat quickly or else our blood pH reaches harmful levels. Repeating "a calorie is a calorie" is harmful for people considering their diet, and a truism if you're speaking to a physicist. In either case, not helpful.
- Spivak 6y agoSee, I feel this is the exact opposite. Telling people that it’s possible to lose weight without running a caloric deficit one way or another is the most harmful piece of advice to give to anyone who’s on a diet. I do not deny that it is probably possible to min max your diet and exploit some of our bodies weirdness. But on a macro scale none of that shit matters. If you run a caloric deficit it literally does not matter in the slightest what your body does to the food: it can store in fat, it can burn it immediately no matter what your body is still going to have to burn all of its reserves to operate.