3 ms·
How does the math work out here?? The total income of the top 1% is $2 trillion: https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-data-2018-update h
by rayiner 6y ago
How does the math work out here??
The total income of the top 1% is $2 trillion: https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-data-2018-update https://taxfoundation.org/summary-latest-federal-income-tax-...
Meanwhile, there are 130 million full time workers: https://www.statista.com/statistics/192356/number-of-full-time-employees-in-the-usa-since-1990/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/192356/number-of-full-ti...
The chart in the middle shows that top 1% incomes would drop by half in the counter-factual scenario. If you redistribute that to 130 million full-time workers, that adds $7,650 per worker across the board. So how can you get $30,000 more at the 25th percentile and $40,000 more at the median?
The basic problem seems to be that the study assumes that taxable income should scale with per capita gdp growth. But it ignores that there are a bunch of other things in GDP besides personal income, and the proportions of each component can change over time: http://lmi.mt.gov/Portals/193/xBlog/uploads/2016/10/26/GDPvsIncome_800px.png http://lmi.mt.gov/Portals/193/xBlog/uploads/2016/10/26/GDPvs...
There are a lot of things included in GDP that are not taxable personal income: social security contributions, net government transfers, etc. The RAND study looks at just taxable personal income. So if nothing else changes other than the fact that the government prints a bunch of money to pay for welfare benefits, or if the income from rents skyrockets, or if benefits grow faster than wages, or if corporate profits sit undistributed (all of which are true) the share of total GDP going to median income earners will go down. (Note they do include investment income and distributed corporate profits.)
The study’s problem isn’t methodology, per say. It’s overlooking that there are other things in GDP besides taxable income to the bottom 99% versus the top 1%. The article draws the conclusion that reductions in the percentage of the economy going to the median earner means that they instead went to the top 1%. Obviously that’s false because the money could go somewhere else. Under the RAND model, both shares could even go down, because a larger share of the economy is comprised of GDP components that aren’t taxable personal income.
- whack 6y ago> There are a lot of things included in GDP that are not taxable personal income: social security contributions, net government transfers, etc This is not true. The GDP numbers specifically exclude social security and other money transfers, specifically to avoid the problems you've stated. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/082415/are-social-security-payments-included-us-gdp-calculation.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/082415/are-social-s... "No, Social Security payments are not included in the U.S. definition of the gross domestic product (GDP). Social Security payments are transfer payments, which are not included" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_payment https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transfer_payment "For the purpose of calculating gross domestic product (GDP), government spending does not include transfer payments, which are the reallocation of money from one party to another rather than expenditure on newly produced goods and services" The main difference between GDP and Gross National Income, is that GDP doesn't include income from foreign sources, and going to foreign destinations. But this doesn't make a significant difference in USA. "For instance, the U.S. GNI for 2018 was about 20.7 trillion, according to the World Bank. The GDP in that same year was $20.5 trillion, according to the U.S. Bureau of Economic Affairs"