4 ms·
That's the parent's point! The certification itself is completely meaningless. If a company has their SOC2 it basically tells you almost nothing about their sec
by Spivak 6y ago
That's the parent's point! The certification itself is completely meaningless. If a company has their SOC2 it basically tells you almost nothing about their security culture.
I've never been at a company that has taken SOC audits seriously -- plenty of companies that take security seriously but SOC compliance is an exercise in paperwork not security.
- acdha 6y agoIf that their point, it wasn't well expressed. It doesn't seem right to call something “a grift” because you chose to treat it like a formality when you could have used it as a good faith engagement to actually try to make it better. That's why I made the Agile comparison — organizations can have positive or pointless adoption without that saying more than “you get out of it what you put into it”.
- staticassertion 6y agoI call it a grift because it really feels like it. It's this weird "you have to do this or else" thing that provides 0 additional value (SOC2 is not prescriptive, it is just a forcing function, you could have... just done it). A bunch of unqualified people coming in to rank the unrankable in a vague, gameable, expensive way is my definition of a grift. Then, on top of that, you have a sort of ring of high status organizations that will audit you and charge a fortune, but they've convinced all of these other orgs that their audits are Definitely Better (companies audited by them get breached all the time too), and now you've got this whole racket on top of the grift. Agile isn't forced on anyone. People won't skip over your product because you're "not really doing agile" or whatever. You don't get forced into yearly audits where you pay some outsider with an "agile certification" and 0 technical knowledge to take up multiple engineers for months to write reports. This post explains more: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24505894 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24505894