3 ms·
Who makes these rules? Who decides what is "anti-LGBTQ"? Will they keep adding on more letters to LGBTQ as they become available?
by globular-toast 6y ago
Who makes these rules? Who decides what is "anti-LGBTQ"? Will they keep adding on more letters to LGBTQ as they become available?
- mytailorisrich 6y agoThese days this is gauged by the level of social media outrage, this is what brings 'problems' to the attention of decision-makers, and I suspect that this rule will mostly be used as a response to that unless the domain name itself is obviously disparaging.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThe registry operator does: https://toplevel.design/ https://toplevel.design/
- spsful 6y agoFirstly, the company overseeing the tld gets to make its own rules. For example, you'd have to go through Verisign at some point if you wanted a .com domain. Second, the only things encapsulated by the term LGBTQ are sexual orientation and gender identity, two innately connected concepts. People can add as many letters to the acronym as they want but it doesn't change anything about the movement or the group as a whole.
- buzzy_hacker 6y agoOne of these questions is not like the others
- globular-toast 6y agoThe point of the "more letters" is probably not what you think, but rather what if the entity in charge decides to add a new one (say, X) but it turns out the L, the B and the T now feel alienated by the X? Or, conversely, what if they decide not to include some new group (say, P)? It just seems rather nebulous and down to the whims of some mysterious entity with unclear motives.
- krapp 6y agoWhat are you even on about? There is no "entity in charge" of the LGBT acronym, no central authority approving, adding or removing letters, or any particular concern over "alienation" from adding or removing letters. It's a cultural idiom, not an ISO standard. Regarding its "nebulous" nature and "motives," quoting from Wikipedia[0]: The initialism, as well as some of its common variants, have been adopted into the mainstream as an umbrella term for use when labeling topics pertaining to sexuality and gender identity. The initialism LGBT is intended to emphasize a diversity of sexuality and gender identity-based cultures. Note that, while the quote mentions "LGBT" specifically that description also applies to the "common variants" also described, including LGBTQ, LGBTQIA, and others mentioned elsewhere in the article. I only point that out because one of your flagged comments mentions how alienated and confused you are by "the whole gay thing," so I wanted to be as clear as possible. And if you're instead talking about the registrar, they're not a mysterious entity, and their motives are clearly spelled out on their policy page[1]. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT [1]https://toplevel.design/policy https://toplevel.design/policy
- globular-toast 6y agoErm... I'm talking about the entity in charge of the TLD.
- krapp 6y agoI still don't understand what exactly your concern is. The TLD doesn't even contain any elements of the LGBT acronym, yet you seem deeply concerned about them altering it willy nilly and this having some widespread negative effect on the gay community. This despite going through the unnecessary effort of making an entire, completely off topic top level comment announcing how confused and alienated you were by the gay community and how you wish they would just stop being so visible so you didn't have to think about gay sex all the time. I mean, I'm sure the gay community appreciates your concern and apologizes for the inconvenience, but it seems like you're trying very hard to start a tempest in teacup without even any tea to stir. Don't worry, the gays will be fine. Now relax and enjoy some Scissor Sisters: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHv0jW4p_xA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HHv0jW4p_xA
- hn_is_terrible 6y agoDon't be a dickhead.
- Avtomatk 6y agoSorry for diverting the topic of your comment, but I wish this comment to be visible... (Before thinking that I am an anti-homosexual, read my entire comment, as well as before give me a downvote, write the part where I was wrong and try to refute it with a well-founded argument) I am not against homosexuality as long as homosexuals are the minority and do not cause harm, but the normalization of homosexuality is something that simply is not going to happen unless most of the planet turns homosexual (and puts our very survival at risk). I am in favor of respect for homosexual people as well as respect for any other person... I am in favor that psychological damage should be imputed (insulting someone on the street saying "gay!" Does not count as psychological damage, because otherwise, someone yelling at me "small penis!" on the street would also fall into the category of "psychological damage")... I am against the arguments (used by most of the LGBT community) to claim that homosexuality is something "normal", are not supported by scientific studies. (the largest study conducted (that I am aware of) on 500,000 homosexual people, reveals that, although their genetics are similar, there is no relationship between "homosexual genetics" and homosexual behavior: https://science.sciencemag.org/content/365/6456/eaat7693 https://science.sciencemag.org/content/365/6456/eaat7693) Some of the LGBT community goals that I was able to research are: 1. Normalize homosexuality (to avoid the "psychological damage" mentioned above) 2. Legally defend homosexuals who receive psychological or physical harm (I already mentioned my position above) 3. Allow gay marriage (falls into the same category of "normalizing homosexuality" from point 1) I do not know more objectives, if someone can tell me (or affirm if those are all the points) I would appreciate it.