3 ms·
The approach suggested in the article is to use market forces, i.e. boycott products which move us closer to unwanted futures. This is challenging when the maj
by walterbell 6y ago
The approach suggested in the article is to use market forces, i.e. boycott products which move us closer to unwanted futures. This is challenging when the majority of products are headed in one direction, driven by market demand that companies can influence by advertising.
Another approach is to use regulatory power in democratic societies, e.g. to enact legislation for right to repair (https://www.ifixit.com/Right-to-Repair/Intro https://www.ifixit.com/Right-to-Repair/Intro), or specific DMCA exemptions for owners to modify device firmware (https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2020/sep/16/dmca-exemptions-2020/ https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2020/sep/16/dmca-exemptions-2...). These are necessary but insufficient steps to restore choice in functionality and freedom, which are sometimes placed in false opposition via vague threat models.
In practice, what has worked has been competition from smaller vendors. In a world of more complexity, we need more than GPD Pockets and kickstarters to lead the way with pioneering examples that can be copied by bigger companies. Without the creative force of a Steve Jobs, Apple depends on the broader market to experiment. Several iPad Pro features can be credited to MS Surface, including concessions (still poorly implemented) on a local file system. If we end up with a few monopolies, will innovation slow without competitors teaching consumers about alternatives?
There needs to be a commercial arena where engineers in smaller companies have economic incentives to develop prototypes that increase freedom without compromising security, which "appliances" can then copy. FPGAs and RISC-V have some promise for open hardware, but progress is slowed by closed software toolchains. There are no quick fixes, but pockets of general-purpose hardware success can be encouraged by legislation, engineering talent voting with their feet, and yes, commercial support by customers.
- square_usual 6y ago> This is challenging when the majority of products are headed in one direction, driven by market demand that companies can influence by advertising. Exactly. The author says it's large corporations that are driving us there, and yet seems to be naive enough to believe that the very market forces that made those large corporations large and drove technology in this direction can be changed by an extremely insignificant minority. The vast majority of people want tech that's cheap and does what they want, as evidenced by Xiaomi being the biggest smartphone company in India. The only way to turn that around is to have a power equally as big as the companies - i.e. Government.
- cassepipe 6y agoIn practice, what has worked has been competition from smaller vendors. I feel like I have to mention here System76 and the work they are doing on firmware and the development of an attractive Linux environment. https://system76.com/ https://system76.com/ I am not affiliated in any way.
- trenchgun 6y agoAlso Pine64!