5 ms·
> Now it’s up to you if you consider that a separate permutation or not. (I don’t) This isn't really up to you; it's determined by the method you use to count
by thaumasiotes 6y ago
> Now it’s up to you if you consider that a separate permutation or not. (I don’t)
This isn't really up to you; it's determined by the method you use to count how many permutations there are.
In this case, I strongly suspect that we count 43,252,003,274,489,856,000 and then may or may not say "but 4,096 of those are equivalent for any given coloration pattern, so divide by 4,096". I would bet we don't count 10,559,571,111,936,000. Unless you have a method that yields that result naturally, you should consider the rotated centers to be separate permutations.
- function_seven 6y ago> In this case, I strongly suspect that we count 43,252,003,274,489,856,000 and then may or may not say "but 4,096 of those are equivalent for any given coloration pattern, so divide by 4,096". I don't think that's true. I went looking for the formula, and found this[1]. They include a term for the permutations of the corner cubes (8!∙3⁸), a term for the edge cubes (12!∙2¹²) and a term for the center cubes (1!∙1¹), then divide that by 12 (2∙3∙2) to eliminate impossible configurations. That term for the center cube permutations seems to agree with my view on it. There's no such thing as "rotation" for a plain colored center cube. It's the same no matter how you look at it. I think a cube with designs on the center faces will have more permutations than the 43e18 we're discussing here. [1] http://b.chrishunt.co/how-many-positions-on-a-rubiks-cube http://b.chrishunt.co/how-many-positions-on-a-rubiks-cube
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> They include a term for the permutations of the corner cubes (8!∙3⁸), a term for the edge cubes (12!∙2¹²) and a term for the center cubes (1!∙1¹), then divide that by 12 (2∙3∙2) to eliminate impossible configurations. But that matches exactly what I said was being done, modulo the particular number and an error in the formula you provide. (It should be 1·1⁶, not 1!·1¹.) You have 4 orientations for each center cube, and then you divide 4⁶ by 4,096 to get 1. I agree that the way your link presents it, with a glaring error in the term for the centers, suggests that they didn't put any thought towards the centers beyond "they don't and can't change in any way".