5 ms·
The Salisbury poisoning was bizarre. The Russians had arrested Sergei, then spy-swapped him in 2010. So the Russians have to have figured out a reason, after a
by roenxi 6y ago
The Salisbury poisoning was bizarre. The Russians had arrested Sergei, then spy-swapped him in 2010.
So the Russians have to have figured out a reason, after a decade, that suddenly this man had to die in a grizzly and obvious assassination. Despite the fact they already had him under arrest and decided he wasn't all that important to them. It is very hard to imagine what that reason would be. And on the converse, anglosphere intelligence services have a history of lying.
It is reasonable to question the Salisbury poisoning. It is hard to see what was in it for Russia. There wasn't an outcome here that is good for them, so it is unclear why they would have done it.
- mhh__ 6y agoTo prove that they can get anyone, anywhere? Is that really that hard to get? They aren't exactly quiet about what might happen to someone who doesn't play ball. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/vladimir-putin-traitors-kick-bucket-sergei-skripal-latest-video-30-pieces-silver-a8243206.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/vladimir-put... https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2019/09/10/traitors-must-be-punished-vladimir-putins-stark-warnings-russians-who-defect-west/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2019/09/10/traitors-mus... Skripal was swapped for 10 illegals (the illegals, from 2010). Bringing them back was a propaganda win, they sort of got away with it, and the west got Skripal back in return.
- roenxi 6y ago> To prove that they can get anyone, anywhere? Is that really that hard to get? If they can get anyone, any time ... why pick someone irrelevant? Why not get someone where it is in their interests for them to die? That is a really bad motive. All they are doing is tipping their operational methods and compromising the identity of their assassins. Plus it costs money and is risky. Either the Russians are really stupid or there is some aspect of the story that isn't public. What that aspect is, who knows. But it is probably there.
- mhh__ 6y agoSkripal was one of the west's crown jewels (that we know about at least), obvious target. This is about sending a message to potential future-skripals. And the brazenness of it fits with what I have said - We can get away with this anywhere, you are not safe. Spies have been killing people for millenia, and the KGB (now FSB) and GRU are particularly good at it. John Barron's book on the KGB from the 70s literally had a list of a few hundred known KGB officers at the back before the index, they all know each other to at least some degree (They'll suss you out the moment you are deployed to a foreign embassy). > What that aspect is, who knows. But it is probably there. Like what? Maybe they poisoned themselves with Novichok for a laugh, but it's unlikely. Remember that a lot of Russian money passes through the British ruling party and London so it's not really in their interest to ratfuck
- pydry 6y agoIt also makes it nearly impossible to do a spy swap in the future. Putin gets to do that once. I don't think individual FSB agents whom skripal blew the cover of give a fuck about this but I'm certain Putin does.
- arethuza 6y ago"die in a grizzly and obvious assassination" I think the point is very much to send a message to current serving Russian intelligence officers to think very carefully before betraying their country.
- mhh__ 6y agoThis is apparently hard to grasp for some (HN is the only site on the internet I frequent where the Russian security services of all people seem to be given the benefit of the doubt)
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoI think it’s because US / UK security services are just as ruthless and bloody, they just cover it up better. I doubt anyone here disputes the extreme moral failure of Russian state security. It’s just that we should be much more skeptical of countries that are just as bloody and flippant in their lack of concern for human life or decency, like US & UK.
- mhh__ 6y agoWho has the UK assassinated in the last 20 years? The western intelligence services are awful too but no one does it quite like the russians
- the-dude 6y agoDoes the UK participate in any drone programs?
- mhh__ 6y agoYes, but that's a different kind of operation (they're run by the military). The correct answer to my question is (if you go 40 rather than 20 years) that the bodies are very much buried in Northern Ireland (although the FRU was part of the British Army)