4 ms·
Murray sows mistrust and conspiracy like thinking towards everything he sees as the man he is fighting against. He has uncritically trusted Kremlin sources be
by nabla9 6y ago
Murray sows mistrust and conspiracy like thinking towards everything he sees as the man he is fighting against. He has uncritically trusted Kremlin sources because they have common enemy.
For example Kremlin dismissed photos of Salisbury suspects as fake news, and Murray jumped right into it without critical thinking or distrust against Kremlin as source. NATO chemical weapons exercise taking place on Salisbury Plain seems like better explanation to him.
For these and other reasons I can't trust his reporting to be factual. We should find other sources.
- mjw1007 6y agoHere's an example of his conspiracy-like thinking from last year: https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2019/10/bad-faith-negotiation/ https://www.craigmurray.org.uk/archives/2019/10/bad-faith-ne... He claimed to have inside information from the Foreign Office, that the government was negotiating an agreement with the EU with the intention of breaking it later. I don't think anyone else reported this at the time. A little under a year later, it seems that what he reported was true.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoA little under a year later, it seems that what he reported was true. No it doesn't; it merely seems that the outcome of the conspiracy he fabricated last year is similar to the possible outcome of something that might happen in the future. Broken clocks etc.
- mjw1007 6y agoMurray often claims to be reporting something he was told by an insider at the Foreign Office. I'm not sure whether in general to believe him. In this case I'm convinced, from what we know now, that he was telling the truth: that the government was planning, at the time the backstop was negotiated, for how to break it, and that this was unusual enough for Foreign Office legal advisers to be distinctly unhappy about it. I don't think this demonstrates that every time he claims he's reporting insider information he's telling the truth. But it does weigh in the direction of treating him as a truth-teller. It's the nearest thing we can get in this sort of situation to gaining confidence by verifying a theory's prediction experimentally.
- nabla9 6y agoJust like the the boy who cried wolf, even if Murray had credible source inside FO, all his other writing undermine any real information he had.
- mhh__ 6y agoI'm not seeing it, at least just from that. Can you point out the connection between exactly what Murray writes and the "limited and specific way" debacle? Boris Johnson to skirt around law and violate treaty isn't exactly out of character.
- mjw1007 6y agoNote the article says which bit of the treaty it's talking about (the Northern Ireland protocol). If he'd written "I've heard from legal advisers that they've been asked to provide a justification for breaking part of a treaty but they don't want me to say which", I wouldn't put much weight on that turning out to be true.
- matthewmacleod 6y agoI think it's really important that we keep stressing this. Murray's blog is showing up here every day, despite his being an untrustworthy source of information, and a noted conspiracy theorist. He's also due in court next month on his own set of contempt charges. It's clear from reading his analysis that he has no interest in trying to remain even slightly detached. If he wrote that the sky were blue, you'd be well advised to double-check yourself.
- mhh__ 6y agoI sincerely hope it's for benign reasons, but HN does seem to be the only "normal" forum I read where this level of contrarian-ness wrt the Whitehouse/Whitehall line on Russia (I would say Assange too but I feel some qualified sympathy towards him). Make the argument if you want but not via Craig Murray The older threads on Litvinenko have basically the same debates going on, same with Skripal, now with Navalny. "but how can you prove Putin [noted ex-KGB Lieutenant Colonel turned naive pacifist apparently] ordered it"
- luckylion 6y agoI expect dang to jump up any second and remind you that that's most likely because you don't come into contact with people from vastly different backgrounds who hold vastly different opinions on your other forums. It's actual diversity. Skepticism, even extreme skepticism, is generally a good thing, and having some people out there that are convinced that something is not as it seems is a good thing. Even if they're wrong, they will look very closely and bring things to attention that everyone else will not look into because they subconsciously feel that it's not a good idea to poke that hornets nest if you want to keep your ideological world view in tact. With Navalny, for example, there's been quite a bit of demands to halt or cancel North Stream 2. There are obviously very powerful interests in multiple settings that would very much like to see that happen. Obviously that doesn't mean anything for the case itself, but if you flat our reject that conspiracies and intelligence false flag operations exist (or, alternatively, believe "we're the good guys, we wouldn't do that"), you won't look into it, because why would you.
- k1m 6y ago> I can't trust his reporting to be factual. We should find other sources. No major news source is covering this to the extent Craig Murray is. That in itself should be more worrying than Murray's views on other matters. His reporting on Assange has been very good. There are other sources, but I doubt they diverge much from what Murray's reporting. See for example Kevin Gosztola's reporting: https://dissenter.substack.com https://dissenter.substack.com
- acqq 6y agoHere are some other sources supporting the topics discussed at the day 11, of which I wasn't aware until reading the report: https://www.salon.com/2010/11/29/wikileaks_germany_el_masri/ https://www.salon.com/2010/11/29/wikileaks_germany_el_masri/ "A top U.S. diplomat strongly warned German counterparts against issuing arrest warrants for CIA agents who were involved in the kidnapping of a German citizen, who was brought to Afghanistan and tortured before officials concluded that they had the wrong man." From the diplomatic cable, published by Wikileaks, we can see that the US is actually threatening Germany while at the same time writing: "our intention was not to threaten Germany, but rather to urge that the German Government weigh carefully at every step of the way the implications for relations with the U.S." To paraphrase James Mickens, it seems if the USA threatens your country, "they’re going to hold a press conference and say “It wasn’t us” as they wear t-shirts that say “IT WAS DEFINITELY US.”" After seeing the posts each day trying simply to discredit the author of the reports instead of claiming that there's any inaccuracy in what he reports, everybody should consider that maybe there are some people who would rather that nobody reads about all the topics brought up there. And there are many very interesting topics indeed. I advise anybody taking the time and going through the previous days too. The author of the report claims that it is officially for him not allowed to post the links to the written statements of the witnesses of the defense. Reading his reports is insightful, and I'm not aware of anybody doing more thorough reporting now.
- jacobush 6y agoWhat I find most concerning is, where are all the "normal" reporters - and I don't mean the unicorn unbiased ones, but regular, biased but not actively pushing their fringe ideas. (I mean, it's ok to have fringe ideas. But if you are pushing them without having much to back them up with, and at the same time acting as a reporter, lets just say I wish we had more to choose from.)
- acqq 6y agoCan you name any "fringe" idea in his 11 days of reports, that he claimed himself? As in, not supported by other sources, or that weren't said directly by somebody else? I haven't noticed a single one. For example, it's obvious that the judge actively did everything they can to limit the chance that the case gets proper coverage in the press.
- somesortofsystm 6y agoYou sow distrust on one hand but then you show your fealty to the war machine on the other hand. We cannot know whether the Salisbury Plain weapons exercise is the legitimate source of the Novichok substance - because lies, deceit and 'state secrecy' are used to mask the truth. So, you'd prefer journalists not do their job and raise questions about these issues, because they cannot possibly know the truth? Your disinterest in Murray is irrelevant, anyway. He is the tip of the iceberg in terms of who is reporting on the travesty that is the Assange extradition trial. Fortunately, not everyone is as easily swayed by the military-industrial spook state as you are, though ..