7 ms·
I've just tried out the spatial audio on my iPad with AirPods Pro, with one of the (many) free first episodes on Apple TV+... ...and it's stunning. Seriously.
by crazygringo 6y ago
I've just tried out the spatial audio on my iPad with AirPods Pro, with one of the (many) free first episodes on Apple TV+...
...and it's stunning. Seriously. It's actually three separate features in one. First, all the audio is outside of you rather than stuck between your ears. Second, it's surround sound so that dialog actually comes from your iPad, while music comes from all around. And third, it tracks, so if you look left the dialog all comes from your right AirPod -- and it's positively disconcerting it's so real. I thought for a second all the sound was actually coming out of my iPad and, oh crap, I have to turn it down not to bother the neighbors! Before realizing... oh my god it's actually that realistic.
So not only does it blow me away technologically, but also that I got it as a free upgrade almost a year after buying the headphones! People love to criticize Apple, but man do they do some wonderful things for their customers.
Now I'm just so disappointed the feature is iOS-only, and not for Macs. I watch all my TV on a projector hooked up to my Mac, and man... if I had spatial audio while viewing that... I can't even imagine. It would beat any movie theater I've ever been to. (And sadly, iPad HDMI output is low-quality, as it heavily compresses the output.)
My understanding is they don't support Macs because they don't have accelerometers/gyroscopes so the AirPods wouldn't know what they were relative to spatially. But man, I'd be happy just for a button I could click that says "my head is looking directly at the screen now". Wouldn't that be enough? But there's no mention of it being in Big Sur, so oh well...
- christoph 6y agoI came here to say the same thing. Just watched a few Star Wars and Pixar scenes on Disney+ and I was shocked how well it worked. I thought it might be gimmicky, but it's a total game changer for watching movies at night with Airpods. Also very happy my iPhone can finally display PIP as well.
- ghostpepper 6y agoAs an owner of the regular airpods, I never really saw the reason to upgrade, but this sounds pretty compelling. How many shows support this?
- crazygringo 6y agoAll the ones I tried on Apple TV+. I think pretty much all scripted TV these days is produced in at least 5.1 surround, which is what it needs (also supports 7.1). But it has to be supported by the content and the app you use. LifeHacker put out a guide a few hours ago about which streaming services support it on their iOS app [1], the upshot being: Supported: Apple TV+, Disney+, HBO Max Not yet supported: Netflix, Prime Video, Showtime Anytime, PBS, TNT [1] https://lifehacker.com/which-apple-devices-and-video-services-support-spatial-1845077927 https://lifehacker.com/which-apple-devices-and-video-service...
- christoph 6y agoOnly Apple TV+, Disney+ & HBO Max support it at the moment, no Netflix or Prime yet.
- gumby 6y ago> My understanding is they don't support Macs because they don't have accelerometers/gyroscopes so the AirPods wouldn't know what they were relative to spatially. What about when using the AppleTV? (This question isn't really for crazygringo who wouldn't be using the Mac to watch video if they owned an appleTV.)
- realityking 6y agoAppleTV doesn’t support it either.
- debug-desperado 6y agoDo you know how it compares to Dolby Atmos for headphones, DTS Headphone:X, and Windows Sonic? Those solutions all work with conventional stereo headphones. Edit: after more reading I believe the main difference is the sensors in the Airpods Pro track head movement. For instance the virtual center (dialog speaker) would always appear to be coming from the display device, even if you move or tilt your head.
- crazygringo 6y agoSon of a gun, I went and researched and turns out my Mac can produce a "similar" spatialization effect in VLC from 5.1 audio at least, under Window > Audio Effects > Filter > Headphone virtualization. Not that I've ever heard anyone mention its existence before. But I'm definitely using that from now on. Thanks for setting me on that track! As for comparing the two... the iOS one is absolutely better, but the VLC one is still a really nice improvement. But it's definitely not just the head tracking. The VLC one somehow feels like it spreads the audio out "horizontally", so background sound comes from outside the head, but people speaking still sound "between my ears". Whereas with iOS, the people speaking genuinely sound like they're in front of me -- it puts the center audio forwards -- and nothing sounds "between my ears". I would guess Apple can produce something superior because they know the exact shape and positioning of their own headphones, as opposed to a generic stereo headphone plugin? Not to mention, of course, the lack of head tracking in VLC. I just researched Dolby Atmos for Headphones to compare, and it looks intriguing but appears to be Windows only.
- debug-desperado 6y agoClassic "virtual surround" works like you've noticed in VLC. I believe the new spatial audio formats (including Apple's) all use a standard HRTF (head-related transfer function) that approximates an average person's ear canal shape. This lets you be placed in a virtual space surrounded by audio sources/objects. Sony's Mark Cerny had a fascinating talk on PS5's spatial audio implementation. Sony might even support importing a custom-measured HRTF for even greater sound placement accuracy. No idea where you'd get it measured though!
- 6y ago
- jdxcode 6y agoI own a pair and they don’t stay in my ears even if I’m sat perfectly still for more than 15 minutes at a time. I really hope they fix this somehow.
- zaroth 6y agoI have the same problem as you. Our ears must be similarly defective. You can buy silicon flaps that slip over the top and will keep them comfortably in your ear. The problem is that they don’t fit in the case with the flaps on. I haven’t tried AirPod Pros but I assume they are better in this regard.
- arsome 6y agoApple: where it's not a problem with their hardware, it's a problem with your ears.
- zaroth 6y agoTo be clear, it’s the same for me with any in-ear buds that don’t have the silicone flap thing that I first found on the Bose QuietComfort headphones. That earbud style just fundamentally doesn’t work for some anatomical reason in a percentage of the population.
- 1_player 6y agoGood to know, I wanted to buy some AirPods but I'm another one that can only fit BOSE IEMs. I guess I'll pass. Does anybody else with "wrong" ears used to get awful outside ear pain with the old all plastic iPhone earbuds? I physically cringe in pain just looking at them.
- sinatra 6y agoFor what it’s worth, I had the same problem with all previous Apple earphones. But, I don’t have that problem with airpod pros.
- gwd 6y ago
- sswaner 6y agoWow. With my bad ears, I wasn't sure it was working as you described until my right AirPod battery died and the spatial audio went away. Stunning is right.
- cafed00d 6y ago> People love to criticize Apple, but man do they do some wonderful things for their customers. I agree. Some solutions from Apple are uniquely wonderful. Imagine if they opened up this feature for 3p companies like Netflix. And let’s suppose Netflix commissions original content that is tailor made to take advantage of this type of audio. Of course, Netflix would benefit from increased subscribers and one could argue Apple would benefit from the availability of the content too — more people likely to buy airpods. However, I’m personally convinced that Apple’s 30% commission charge to Netflix is completely justified. After all, they’re taking advantage of an end to end solution built by Apple. But of course, Netflix could bypass the IAP policy and not past the benefits into Apple. But I’m just using Netflix as an example. Any 3p app such as game or music app or movie app would benefit from this feature. I only bring up the 30% point because it’s been make headlines recently and the hn community also has been vocal on the topic. (Disclaimer: I don’t know enough about the spatial audio feature to say if it works with apps like Netflix or not. I’m presuming it doesn’t for illustrating my argument.)
- mkskm 6y agoNetflix stopped allowing subscriptions via IAP in December 2018.
- _venkatasg 6y agoNetflix can and hopefully will add support. HBO Max and Disney+ support spatial audio right now.
- shaan7 6y ago> People love to criticize Apple, but man do they do some wonderful things for their customers. People rarely criticize Apple for the products themselves. Apple gets criticism because of the "weird" (for lack of a better word) restrictions on the products. I've stopped using a Mac for quite a while now - but I recall examples - when the first Macbooks came without a optical drive you could buy an external one. But it will only work with _that particular Macbook model_ (after googling around I found that you could send a magic SCSI string to make it work). There is no iPhone with a SD card slot - my dad _LOVED_ iOS and his iPhone 6S but he had to switch to an Android phone so that he can use a 500GB SD card to store all his photos (he wants _ALL_ his photos available locally on the phone, so cloud sync is not an option). I could go on. Apple makes some amazing products, but then adds quirks that makes the amaze short lived.
- samatman 6y agoI hear you. The headphone jack on the phone, I can actually see it. Not a lot of real estate inside a phone, and they wanted people to try AirPods (which I love, and might not have tried if it weren't for the missing jack). But... no headphone jack on a 13" tablet? I edit movies on there sometimes and I grumble every time I dust off the dongle to plug in a mic for voiceovers. But, no, people criticize Apple for everything they can think of. It's one of those companies where there's a set of people who, for whatever weird reason, have decided it's the enemy. They're against Apple and everything it stands for. It's strange, I think the only company I feel that way about is Facebook. Maybe because phones are the most intimate things we own, they become part of our identities?
- madeofpalk 6y ago> Not a lot of real estate inside a phone iPhone got thicker and bigger when they removed the headphone jack.
- bigfudge 6y agodoesn't that reinforce the point? Space was needed for something else...
- rorykoehler 6y agoThere is an A Tribe Called Quest album with a skit that almost always made me turn around to see who is talking behind me when listened to on headphones. AFAIK they used stereo microphones on a mannequin to achieve this effect. I don't know what my point is but I guess it's a bit surprising that it took so long for this to enter the mainstream as we've certainly had the ability to do his with minimal extra processing for quite some time now.
- jmiserez 6y agoIt's called binaural sound, and can be played back on any headphones.
- AnonC 6y ago> So not only does it blow me away technologically, but also that I got it as a free upgrade almost a year after buying the headphones! Being pedantic here: it is not actually free for you. The costs of improvements delivered through software updates are built into the original price you paid for it through deferred revenues and "subscription accounting". [1] In other words, Apple is not subsidizing new feature delivery from other sources of revenue or from debts. This came from the collective AirPod Pro users' pockets. Accounting (and the related legality) aside, it is great to see hardware products get enhancements and a longer useful life through such means (whenever it happens). [1]: https://appleinsider.com/articles/13/11/01/apple-now-sitting-on-10b-in-deferred-revenue-more-than-samsung-or-google-earned-last-quarter-aapl https://appleinsider.com/articles/13/11/01/apple-now-sitting...
- voska 6y agoI was of the understanding that the accelerometers are actually inside the AirPods - so that shouldn't prevent them from working with Macs. Maybe it comes with Big Sur?