3 ms·
Typically when making a copyrighted creative work your objective is to get paid for that work. Just preventing people that wouldn't pay for it anyway from enjoy
by Nextgrid 6y ago
Typically when making a copyrighted creative work your objective is to get paid for that work. Just preventing people that wouldn't pay for it anyway from enjoying that work is a lose-lose situation for both parties involved.
While this isn't evidence that DRM is useless, it also isn't evidence that it is useful. That evidence would come from sales numbers if they are significantly higher than another comparable work that wasn't DRM'ed as it would prove that the DRM is actually convincing people to pay for something they normally wouldn't.
Piracy is not just a "freeloader" problem. I've been to a few poorer countries where piracy is absolutely normal not because they don't want to pay per-se, but because they just don't have the means to do so or are prevented from doing so by technical or commercial reasons like lack of adequate payment infrastructure or region-locking; in which case you are still better off letting them enjoy the creative work for free and hope to gain the benefits in some other way (like them buying your future software when they can finally afford it, or producing good press and raising awareness around other people who can actually afford it). There's also the issue of people for who DRM actually causes problems and prevents them from enjoying work that they did actually pay for, though I personally don't see how the inconvenience of DRM is worse than the risk of running code from an untrusted, anonymous source that might be malicious).
- belorn 6y agoWe can compare sales number of RDR2 with witcher 3, a game that came out 3 years before RDR2 and without DRM. Given a growing market, and the assumption that both games are equally attractive for buyers, RDR2 should at minimum have a small increased number compared to witcher 3. Witcher 3 sold about 30 millions copies over the first 2 years. RDR2 sold 32 millions over the first 2 years.
- ineedasername 6y agoEh, hard to say: Witcher 3 was a breakout hit with a (relatively) niche audience for prior games. It's prior games were also available DRM free. RDR2 was both highly anticipated and had a massive marketing budget. I think your idea is sound, but I just don't know if these are really comparable game launches. Counter-factuals are also very hard to prove. how do we know that Witcher 3 wouldn't have generated more revenue if it wasn't easy to share your copy?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoThis comparison is invalid. They are two different games with overlapping but not identical fan bases. There are significant demographic, marketing, and competitive differences between the two releases. You really can't draw any conclusions about drm, positive or negative, from the relative sales figures.
- thu2111 6y agoGame publishers have that data, very precise data iirc. It was a long time ago but I recall one of the smaller publishers did a long blog post on this topic. They showed sales graphs for one of their games. The graph showed a big spike in the first few days followed by a slow decline. It also showed huge chunks missing (drop followed by an identical sized increase a few weeks later). Those chunks were when cracks came out and the increase was when the cracks were broken by multi-player patching. It's simple enough maths to calculate the area of the graph that was missing - that's your lost sales. Apps use DRM because most pirates will in fact buy the game if they can't crack it. They are big into gaming, they want to play the newest games NOW when they are fresh and their friends are talking about it, and they want to play online with others. So as long as cost of DRM < cost of lost sales, games will use it. As DRM has been a feature of gaming for as long as there have been video games, it always baffles me how many people on forums like HN seem to believe only irrational developers would use it.