2 ms·
I think there is a better explanation here, one that does not require such nefarious motives. If you're producing a physical product, then there is usually a m
by lisper 6y ago
I think there is a better explanation here, one that does not require such nefarious motives. If you're producing a physical product, then there is usually a more or less linear relationship between the amount of product you produce and the time and effort you put into producing it. If you can make a widget in an hour, then it probably will take you more or less two hours to make two widgets. The constant of proportionality can change with practice and according to skill, but there probably isn't an order of magnitude of difference between an extraordinarily skilled factory worker and a moderately skilled one.
With engineering things are radically different. In engineering, and particularly in software engineering, everything is easy once you know how, otherwise it is borderline impossible. Most of the effort involved in engineering work is not in the actual work, but in the figuring-out-how. As a result, there can be multi-order-of-magnitude differences between the effort required by someone who already knows how to do something and someone who still needs to figure it out for the first time. This difference is most pronounced at the bleeding edge of theoretical research, where it can literally take decades to figure out something for the first time, after which the same problem (or variations on the theme) can be solved in minutes or seconds.
So the problem becomes: do you pay someone for their efforts or do you pay them for the results? Historically we've paid people for their effort because that was correlated with results, but that is no longer the case. But people tend to bristle at paying for results, particularly if they see that very little (apparent) effort was involved in producing it. There's the old chestnut about the plumber who charged $100 for banging on a pipe. When challenged, the plumber produced an itemized invoice: $5 for banging on the pipe and $95 for knowing where to bang.
Engineering problems are often solved by taking a shower. But Harvard MBAs don't like to pay people to take showers. We really need a radical re-thinking of the whole compensation model for this kind of work.