4 ms·
As a former product manager with lots of experience with both engineering and management: no, that's not what deadlines are designed for. Deadlines exist becau
by crazygringo 6y ago
As a former product manager with lots of experience with both engineering and management: no, that's not what deadlines are designed for.
Deadlines exist because software doesn't exist in a vacuum, but other people depend on it being delivered. Whether so it can be sold to make money before someone goes out of business or a partnership fails, or its features arrive on time as promised for the start of the school year which can't be moved, or as the foundation for another project that has its own equally valid deadline later on.
Deadlines exist because people need to make plans and be able to rely on them, which is how our entire society and economy function.
People work overtime in every industry to meet deadlines, it's not just engineers. The only question is whether or it's good for you financially.
Whenever you take a job, it's up to you to do your due diligence in talking to other employees to find out what the working hours and flexibility are like in practice, and judge that against the salary, and decide if it makes sense for you.
Fortunately, there is huge variation in both salaries and expectations of hours per week, and the best thing you can do about places that pay little and work you long is to not take their job offer, or leave. Then supply and demand can do its thing and they'll be forced to adjust or go out of business.
- marcinzm 6y ago>Deadlines exist because software doesn't exist in a vacuum, but other people depend on it being delivered. Exactly, even without external deliverables there are likely other internal initiatives that depend on the project or tie into it. Might even be something as simple as the QA team being booked on another project in a month that does have a hard deadline. So as long as something in the org has a hard external deadline there are going to be ripples that touch all projects in the org. Also, my experience is that if you communicate early that features need to be cut to meet the deadlines most managers will be happy.
- thomas 6y agoWell put and fully agreed. I don’t think engineers are in any way a special case here. In fact it can be much worse for people whose skillset is easier to replace.
- tanseydavid 6y agoIf you ask around I think you will discover that non-engineers DO NOT relate to this topic at all the same way engineers do. That's all the evidence that I need to take the view that this phenomenon is wide-spread and pervasive in engineering and does not usually reach the same level of pathology in other professions -- a level where people are forced into 'playing a game' with regard to estimates and deadlines. In short this is really UNHEALTHY behavior and whether it occurs in all industries or just engineering seems beside the point.
- crazygringo 6y agoAsk around who? Talk to consultants, investment bankers, doctors, lawyers -- you know, other high-intellect jobs like engineers. Lawyers are playing the game of billable hours. Consultants are playing the game of working day and night to produce the report by the promised deadline, to move on to their next scheduled client the following Monday. Doctors complete grueling residencies with "artificially" insane requirements, then follow insane schedules juggling hospitals and private practice. And the investment bankers I know haven't had a full weekend off in years. I fail to see what's different about engineering, or what makes it inherently any more of a "game" than what billable hours or hospital residences or consulting deadlines are.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoAgreed. I feel for the author of this blog post, who apparently has worked underneath some terrible managers. > Deadlines exist because people need to make plans and be able to rely on them, which is how our entire society and economy function. This is the core of it. When we're heads down working through code, it's easy to forget that the end product is part of a much bigger business. In most companies, operating without deadlines or target dates is equivalent to expecting the rest of the business to revolve around you. Doesn't work. That's not to say that deadlines can or should be arbitrary. Healthy teams will sit down and discuss realistic deadlines with engineers, not hide the tasks from engineers and give them unreasonable deadlines without a hint of communication like this blog post suggests. If you find yourself working for a manager or company that resembles this blog post in any way: Get out! There are many great companies and managers out there who would be more than happy to add good talent to their teams. Mutual respect is the norm at any halfway functional company. Any company operating like this is doomed to suffer massive turnover, exodus of good employees, and slow descent into failure. Don't let bad managers like this drag you down with them, and don't let bad experiences make you permanently cynical of the industry as a whole.
- mekoka 6y ago> Software doesn't exist in a vacuum. Strip down everything to its bare essentials (i.e. just beyond the vacuum) and you have: a Programmer, a Software and (maybe) a User. The sentence above is a common trope that people believe justifies all the friction added between the Programmer and the Software, while attempting to optimize the process of putting it in the hand of the User. But I contend that deadlines are an unfortunate and provably unnecessary byproduct (see many open source projects) of that often wasteful process. > Deadlines exist because people need to make plans and be able to rely on them To make a plan you need a list of priorities and some time estimates. Some people just have a knack for turning these into artificial emergencies. The decision to build a new software feature can be taken in an organization by establishing how needed it is and vaguely describing the time it would take to build in terms of days, weeks, months or years. It's enough to know whether you want to spend some resources on it or not. Regardless of deadlines, people will work toward those time frames. > which is how our entire society and economy function. Only the parts of our society where such engagements actually matter function like this. In many other parts it's useless to follow such a model. Unfortunately some people observe it in one context and believe that it's a driver that can be blindly transposed onto another. So they start fabricating urgency where it doesn't belong. Meanwhile, it'll be ready when it's ready remains a successful model for many, even in our society and economy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Avtomatk 6y ago>People work overtime in every industry to meet deadlines, it's not just engineers. The only question is whether or it's good for you financially. The article did not speak of "overtime", it was said that the engineer was asked to complete a task that would take a month, in 3 days (regardless of whether the author was exaggerating or not). What in "every" industry is called "labor exploitation" and is not something normal.
- mbrodersen 6y agoYep agree. Vote with your feet.