5 ms·
Why can't engineers simply tell managers that it can't be done by the specified deadline? Why do managers even ask this question if they're gonna ignore the ans
by matheusmoreira 6y ago
Why can't engineers simply tell managers that it can't be done by the specified deadline? Why do managers even ask this question if they're gonna ignore the answer and impose an impossible deadline anyway?
It looks like they're assuming we're all lazy. They think the job isn't that hard. A fundamental lack of respect.
- drdeadringer 6y agoPerhaps some managers think they are a clever Cpt Kirk who's gotten wise to their Scotty's miracle-worker tactics, even though they're a manager with an honest Geordi La Forge. No offence to Geordi La Forge.
- watwut 6y agoBecause in majority of the case engineers after manage to hit the deadline. That is managerial experience. What management learns over time is that engineers say it is impossible but if you insist they will then do it. It is by trading quality pretty often, but that often is exactly trade off managers want. It is often by trading future productivity - engineers burning out or at least having drop after deadline.
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> It is often by trading future productivity - engineers burning out or at least having drop after deadline. Future productivity? If engineers are burning out in an attempt to meet otherwise impossible deadlines, it means they're being placed under enough stress that it's threatening their mental and possibly physical health. Is employee health really something that can be traded away?
- NortySpock 6y agoYeah, you just hire a new employee.
- matheusmoreira 6y agoThis is sarcasm, right?
- NortySpock 6y agoI wish.
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Is employee health really something that can be traded away? In theory? No. In practice? Very much yes. Health (particularly mental well-being) isn't readily and reliably quantifiable. As a manager, you may think your subordinate is happy and productive all the way up to the point they hand you their resignation letter. Meanwhile, employees have every reason to pretend everything is OK up to the very moment they secure a new job elsewhere. And to the extent they're becoming less productive due to burnout, most software jobs has a lot of slack in it - between high variance in problem solving and plenty of bullshit tasks to juggle, someone working at 10% of their normal capacity can stay unnoticed for a while. With no good feedback being available, it's hard to see you're putting too much pressure on your employees, particularly if you don't look for it (whether because you're too busy or just don't care).
- matheusmoreira 6y ago
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoManagers don't operate like this at well-run companies. Any remotely healthy team will perform estimation and scoping as a discussion with the developers involved. The author of this post sounds like he has worked at an extremely dysfunctional company, not a company that understands how to develop software. This idea that managers are universally incompetent just isn't true. The best thing you can do is refuse to support incompetent managers. Change teams or change jobs if you must. There are many, many great managers out there who won't try to pull nonsense like this.
- Avtomatk 6y agoI also noticed that the author is in a bias, this is not a problem of the "software companies", this is a problem of "some software companies" that have a very bad administration, lack of experience in the industry or who intend to apply a disguised labor exploitation
- lhorie 6y ago> Why can't engineers simply tell managers that it can't be done by the specified deadline They can. I've had a time where a project manager came by no less than 3 times asking me to re-estimate the same project, tweaked ever so slightly each time. Turned out that they had made an impossible promise to the client. Upon learning that, I just said, listen that can't be done within that budget, end of story. You have to go reduce the scope. In the end, they had to go back, loop in the account manager and have the awkward conversation with the client.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]