3 ms·
Answers were self-reported from online surveys: > Marshall, Piatkowski, and Johnson asked bicyclists as well as drivers and pedestrians to analyze the factors
by PragmaticPulp 6y ago
Answers were self-reported from online surveys:
> Marshall, Piatkowski, and Johnson asked bicyclists as well as drivers and pedestrians to analyze the factors associated with such behaviors. They used snowball sampling—meaning that respondents recruited other participants—for an online survey that presented hypothetical cycling scenarios along with multiple-choice questions about what the respondent would choose to do in each scenario. Survey takers, numbering nearly 18,000, were able to explain their rationales.
As both a cyclist and a driver, I aim for maximum predictability whenever I'm on the road. None of my movements should ever surprise drivers or other cyclists (who are paying attention).
Candidly, about 3/4 of my cyclist friends are intent on following the rules of the road. The other 1/4 are convinced that rules only exist for cars. I've seen too many close calls from people making illegal moves under the mistaken belief that it was safer to run a stop sign, or make a quick lane change without signaling, or otherwise behave as if they could out-maneuver the cars around them.
As a driver, my only close calls with cyclists have been when they skipped stop signs or assumed that the cars would yield to them at 4-way stops. A cyclist even T-boned my wife's car while she was driving the speed limit down a residential street because the cyclist assumed they could maneuver around her.
Cycling is dangerous. Don't make it more dangerous by adding unpredictability to the mix.
- MiroF 6y ago> Cycling is dangerous. Don't make it more dangerous by adding unpredictability to the mix. I agree, but at the same time I think the laws should be changed so that stop signs become yield signs for cyclists (so called Stop as Yield laws). Then it would be predictable and the laws would be designed in a way that makes sense for cycling. This is effectively what I already do and most cyclists I know do as well. I would be lying if I said that I never skipped stop signs. The general difference between reckless/unsafe cyclists and others is less the skipping stop signs versus the when to skip. For instance, I would never skip if there was already a car at another stop sign.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MereInterest 6y ago> Cycling is dangerous. Don't make it more dangerous by adding unpredictability to the mix. This framing makes a lot of assumptions about city/road design that are not universal. I'd say that cycling is inherently an incredibly safe activity. Driving is a dangerous activity to those inside the car, and even more so to those outside the car.
- narwally 6y agoYep, I actually feel much safer when I'm flying down singletrack on my mountain bike than I do when I'm commuting to work. On the mountain bike I know exactly what and where the dangers are, and I have a lot of control over how much risk I take. On my commuter, no matter how I ride, some subset of drivers get pissed of at my existence, and there's another set that aren't paying enough attention to notice my existence at all. There are ways I can ride that help mitigate some of the risks, but ultimately my safety is largely in the hands of the drivers around me. As of a few years ago I actually quit riding on the road altogether. It seemed like for every mountain bike acquaintance I had that broke their collar bone, there was a road bike acquaintance that ended up dead or paralyzed. The risks no longer seemed worth it, especially given the fact that commuting by bike had begun to feel stressful instead of a nice way of getting some exercise before and after work.
- InitialLastName 6y ago> Cycling is dangerous. Don't make it more dangerous by adding unpredictability to the mix. Cycling isn't the dangerous activity here. Cyclists by themselves have an incredible safety record, especially once you adjust for the health benefits of exercise. Driving is the activity that puts lives at risk, but with modern car "safety" improvements those lives tend not to be those of the driver or the passengers.