3 ms·
I'm one of those WA + Signal users. There's only a few barriers (besides momentum) now that prevent me from turning friends to Signal (some of them are dumb, fe
by godelski 6y ago
I'm one of those WA + Signal users. There's only a few barriers (besides momentum) now that prevent me from turning friends to Signal (some of them are dumb, few are big). But by far the number one feature is groups. We're at a time where people are concerned about privacy, this should be utilized.
Other than that, Signal needs to become feature rich. There are many features people want that are just pushed aside. Unfortunately Signal is making the shift from only crypto/privacygeeks to mainstream. In crossing that crevasse Signal needs to consider a different set of opinions that previously it could safely ignore. I would leave Signal if it left the "privacy above all else" mentality, but the forums suggest a high group think about what is "a good feature" and what is "a dumb feature" (and how people are going to use it). If it is a highly requested feature, just add it to the list of things to add. You can't ignore it anymore.
(And can we just add a link to the third party sticker website? People seem to care about that and sticker discovery is needlessly difficult. I get asked this frequently and am constantly sending the sticker link. I'm sorry, but the default ones suck and I cannot understand any good reason it works this way)
- Vinnl 6y ago> (And can we just add a link to the third party sticker website? People seem to care about that and sticker discovery is needlessly difficult. I get asked this frequently and am constantly sending the sticker link. I'm sorry, but the default ones suck and I cannot understand any good reason it works this way) Presumably the reason is that your own sticker sets should be private by default, which makes it more work to allow optional public sharing of them (which supposedly was not worth delaying the feature for). For example, I have a sticker set of weird pictures of a friend of mine that I like to use, but only with mutual acquaintances. Btw, I would argue that stickers are the prime example of Signal trying to become feature rich. But of course, there's only so much you can do at the same time. (Though new features appeared to be released more often recently, presumably as a result of their funding infusion a while back.)
- godelski 6y ago> I would argue that stickers are the prime example of Signal trying to become feature rich. I agree with that and think it is a good example. I know they got a lot of flack for it, even seeing Rachel get downvoted quite a bit for saying this is what Signal needs. As to the sticker discovery, I am more referring to a link in app that leads you somewhere like here[0]. It is nice that if a friend sends a sticker to you that you can download the entire set. It is nice that you can make your own (which is presumably what you are referring to). But if we can download these stickers without some warning (presumably no danger) then this would fix the endless comments I hear of "Signal doesn't have good stickers like Facebook does." Just seems like extremely low hanging fruit to me. [0] https://signalstickers.com/ https://signalstickers.com/
- matheusmoreira 6y ago> the forums suggest a high group think about what is "a good feature" and what is "a dumb feature" Examples of features in both groups?
- godelski 6y agoI'm not trying to say what is right or wrong. To be clear here. I've seen many people ask for a bidirectional delete like in WA. The response always comes back to the lines of "just don't make typos." When I've seen arguments akin to a company nuking a company phone the responses are "well that's dumb because someone can run a custom Signal and save all the data anyways (like that has anything to do with the threat model at hand or changes that this is a probabilistic method of security, but at least doesn't guarantee that the holder of a phone can read confidential messages). I should note that a "compromise" was created where Signal is introducing the feature but there is a time limit. It is not clear to me why this time limit is there other than because some people think it will "trick" people into thinking such things like screenshots exist (I guarantee you every 13 year old boy with TikToc knows how to screenshot or record). Basically the argument is that this feature will "trick" people into thinking that the message no longer can possibly exist anywhere (I don't think many would actually believe this, but yes there are dumb people. Security is never dumb proof). Another example is the sticker thing. Just make them discoverable.
- andreareina 6y agoI mean, it does seem to me like Signal is deliberately courting the mainstream audience, and has been from the start. That's why it uses phone numbers as identity keys, that's why stickers and such, etc.
- godelski 6y agoThe phone numbers were an easy way to do identification and create a social graph. They are working on a more privacy focused one, but that is technically much more difficult. I wouldn't call the phone numbers a "courting the mainstream audience." I would stickers, but then that's just a single example that was already mentioned.
- andreareina 6y agoEasy identification and social graph are important for mainstream adoption though. It so happens that it's not solely the mainstream audience that benefits, but I wouldn't say that disqualifies it.