5 ms·
The speed limit of the universe isn't just some hypothesis waiting to be disproven. It can't be broken. It's impossible.
by baddox 16y ago
The speed limit of the universe isn't just some hypothesis waiting to be disproven. It can't be broken. It's impossible.
- mmavnn 16y agoNever underestimate the capacity of humans to be wrong. Science is made from people being willing to admit they're wrong: the evidence for speed limits is compelling, but not absolute. It would just mean our current model is screwed if we're wrong...
- baddox 16y agoAssuming that the speed of light can be broken leads to hopelessly contradictory and paradoxical (truly paradoxical, not just counterintuitive) conclusions. It's not just some guess that scientists have made about how fast information can travel.
- arethuza 16y agoScientific theories aren't reality - they are a model of reality and to be considered scientific a theory has to be refutable - if you can't conceive of experimental results that would disprove your theory then it's not really a scientific theory. So every scientific theory is in a very real sense "waiting to be disproven".
- baddox 16y agoWe can know things. We know that no algorithm can determine whether or not arbitrary Turing machines will halt, because assuming the contrary leads to a contradiction. Similarly, no consistent axiomatic system powerful enough to express propositions of elementary arithmetic can be complete. Neither the undecidability of the halting problem nor Gödel's first incompleteness theorem are "waiting to be disproven." Similarly, the speed limit of the universe, if assumed to be breakable, leads to all sorts of contradictions and true paradoxes. Note that I'm not saying that the entirety of some theory, be it special or general relativity, quantum theory, etc. are known truths.
- lobster_johnson 16y agoAlgorithms, being a sub-branch of mathematics, are logical constructs, which means they can be proved or disproved on a logical basis. Physics is a scientific model of reality which is based on experimental observations (mathematics is used as a descriptive language, but the underlying reality itself is not (as far as we know) based on logic), therefore any physical theory is not provable, only verifiable through experiment to some statistical probability of correctness. The current physics theory is backed by a huge amount of observations, so admittedly we can be pretty sure about much of the theory. But to say that we "know" is not correct.