6 ms·
I’m in my mid fifties and I have never had a company pension, defined benefit or contribution. I saw my first house decline in value by 25%. We had interest rat
by tonyedgecombe 6y ago
I’m in my mid fifties and I have never had a company pension, defined benefit or contribution. I saw my first house decline in value by 25%. We had interest rates peaking at 15%. I didn’t have student loans but only because I didn’t go to university, just like 90% of my peer group. Unemployment was much higher than it is now and schools were teaching subjects for obsolete careers.
It wasn’t as rosey as it is often portrayed.
- xenonite 6y agoOkay, but we’re you in the 90+ percentile like the OP? What happened to those that were in that range 30 years ago?
- dweekly 6y agoRE: "unemployment was much higher than it is now" - I'm not sure what country you're in, but here is a graph of the US unemployment rate since 1950: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/UNRATE (unemployment was higher this year than any other period on the chart)
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoUK, as per the user who I replied to.
- mikestew 6y agoRegardless, the U. S. had super-high interest rates at that time, too. 12% sticks in my head, but it was also the time of the Variable Interest Rate loan, where I watched co-workers really have to tighten those budgets and almost lose the house because interest rates went from "ungodly high" to "ridiculously high".
- lsllc 6y agoUnemployment in the US has been at its lowest (3.5%) AND then highest (14.7%) levels in 50 years, both in 2020! https://www.statista.com/statistics/273909/seasonally-adjusted-monthly-unemployment-rate-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/273909/seasonally-adjust...
- jbay808 6y agoHow old were you when you bought that first house?
- Gunax 6y agoEveryone will argue with their own statistics, but I think your general sentiment is correct. Everyone seems to think the oldies had it easy in the good ol' days and the youngens are a bunch of lazy good-for-nothins. There are probably certain a ways it has gotten easier and others in which it is worse... But I think this is more about generational sentiment than actual facts.
- 0xB31B1B 6y agothats not really true though, we have the numbers. In real terms, education, healthcare, and housing costs have grown at a much higher rate than inflation. It is more expensive to go to college, pay rent, and stay healthy now than it was 30/40/50 years ago.
- 0x6862 6y agoHousing seems to be the primary issue, but you’ll find very little support for actually fixing the issue - more and taller buildings in densely populated areas. I don’t think people have a problem with spending more on education, they just want a reasonable return on investment for it. Turns out pumping money into monopolistic schools doesn’t get you a better result
- novok 6y agoThe olds don't want it because it decreases the value of their boomer bank account (houses) and being old, don't like change in general.
- klmadfejno 6y agoThe boomer generation was more or less promised that housing was the key to social mobility. And it was for a large number of people. It's hard for that to remain true now, and there's a ton of negative externalities. It's not like these people were experts on real estate policy before, they just don't have perspective on how it differs for the young. "Not liking change" is disingenuous, even if, broadly speaking, older people don't actually like change
- Havoc 6y agoI think you're missing how pervasive & broad the issues are these days. You mentioned you had a house. I'm fast approach the top 1-2% by income and think I can maybe swing a 1 bed apartment. It'll be borderline. Not house...apartment. ...no idea what the other 98% of my peers are doing but they sure as hell aren't buying houses. Meanwhile all the landlords I've rented from thus far where a generation older and had entire portfolios of properties. Pretty sure I'll come out on top of this because I'm doing well, but can certainly understand the disillusionment of the younger generation
- c-rhodes 6y agoThen you must be living in a really expensive city.
- medium_burrito 6y agoIt's a combination of good jobs being in expensive cities, purchasing power dropping and epic (god I hate word) asset inflation. That said remote work makes middle american and rest of the world post wuflu much more possible. I wonder what will happen to big expensive cities after all the young people leave for the midwest and south?
- Havoc 6y agoYup. London. In the land of limp pay cheques (compared to US). Financial sector means being in a financial hub though so not much choice. I'll probably end up moving further out and accepting a long commute eventually.
- novok 6y agoWhy not move to SF or NYC if your in tech or finance?
- 535188B17C93743 6y agoYou say it like it's super simple...
- csomar 6y ago> I saw my first house decline in value by 25%. This rarely matters unless you are looking to sell or borrow against. > We had interest rates peaking at 15%. But inflation was higher at the time. Also rates are 0% now at the Fed level, but if you are a consumer you are going to pay a bit depending on your credit score. > I didn’t have student loans but only because I didn’t go to university, just like 90% of my peer group. The governments (it's really a global phenomena) pushed the general public into universities. It's hard to blame the students when you take that decision at a very early age 17-19 and most of these youth doesn't have any life experience. > Unemployment was much higher than it is now I highly suspect the current unemployment rate is meaningful. To be counted as jobless, you need to register with the local employment office. It's possible today's youth no longer rely on that and use modern alternatives instead. > schools were teaching subjects for obsolete careers They still are. > It wasn’t as rosey as it is often portrayed. It was not. The only difference really is land and housing which was significantly more affordable and did matter less where you lived. Now you need to live next to a "jobs-hub" that have insanely high rent and purchase prices.
- klmadfejno 6y agoIf you buy a house worth 4x your salary (in the ballpark of average), a 25% decline in home value means you need to spend an entire year of labor just to break even, ignoring the obvious associated living costs. The decline doesn't matter if it's temporary, but they're not always temporary. That sounds incredibly demoralizing.
- xenonite 6y agoOn the other hand, renting an apartment translates to a 100% decline in value (and 0% ownership).
- klmadfejno 6y agoRenting is not a leveraged loan worth multiple times your annual income. Home ownership may generally be better than renting. But home ownership and value decline is much much worse.
- xenonite 6y agoI think it’s good that you were able to own a house even though it lost in value. This ownership still sounds better to me than only being able to rent an apartment. Renting always means that the payments lead to 0% ownership in the end, hence a 100% decline in value.