4 ms·
The system is supposed to prevent people from dying, 346 people died, the system is broken, it is a fact. Of course we work backward from there. Even if the co
by GuB-42 6y ago
The system is supposed to prevent people from dying, 346 people died, the system is broken, it is a fact. Of course we work backward from there.
Even if the conclusion is that it is "acceptable business practice", it doesn't make the system less broken. Just as making a bug "won't fix" doesn't make the bug disappear.
But this is all political bickering, I don't think republicans are proud when American planes crash and kill their passengers, some of them US citizens. But because the report is written by democrats, and I suspect it is a little about safety and a lot about attacking the republican government, somehow, republicans feel the need to fight back instead of trying to find solutions.
I hope there are real engineers trying to actually solve the problem behind the scenes.
- heyflyguy 6y agoI agree with you and the report itself has some inflammatory and accusatory information that while seemingly a conviction of Boeing is also a validation that the FAA has created a system the rewards these behaviors. As a parallel I submit to you the FAA Medical process - a system by which it is better for a pilot to conceal or not report until terrible a condition that could invalidate their medical and remove them from flight duties. While both of these are bad for the consumer, I ask - who is at fault? The big company, the pilot, or the people making the rules that encourage such behaviors.
- brennebeck 6y agoShouldn’t all three bear some fault? The big company for not proactively supporting their staff to report (e.g. benefits), the pilot for doing something ethically wrong, and the regulatory body for encouraging the broken system?
- kortilla 6y agoBenefits don’t help a pilot not wanting to lose the ability to fly.
- ncmncm 6y agoThere is more than enough blame to go around, in these as in all cases.
- trabant00 6y ago> The system is supposed to prevent people from dying, 346 people died, the system is broken, it is a fact. Please present one system that you designed and implemented and it worked without faults. Imperfect (as all things are) does not equal broken! From a system design point of view I've lived to see multiple "broken" systems being replaced by a worse system with the best of intentions. Also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_analysis To be clear: I am not saying FAA is faultless, I am no expert on aviation security, I simply have no opinion. I'm just saying some people are quick to take out the pitchforks.
- braythwayt 6y agoI make software that is broken ALL THE TIME. And what do I do then? Find the faults and then fix them. Just because software is not perfect does not mean that I sit like a dog in a house fire saying, "this is fine." Killing 300+ people is broken. And our obligation is to admit that it is broken, and fix that thing. When we find another thing, we admit that the system is broken there as well, and go fix that. Trying to diminish the seriousness of 300 deaths with mealy-mouth terms like "imperfect" is pure spin. If a plane, staffed by pilots allegedly trained on how to fly it, crashes from pilot error... TWICE, the system is broken. terribly broken. See also: Security, physical or digital. Terrorists flew planes into the World Trade Center. The system was broken. We fixed some of it. We put on some secuity theatre too. But we didn't say, "It's impossible to fix everything, so the system is fine." We didn't shrug it off as "imperfect." We always begin by being truthful with ourselves about the fact that we have discovered that the system is broken. And if the consequences of its broken-ness are unacceptable, we fix it. "Imperfect" is a word that should only be used for acceptable faults. Like, "The seating in economy is imperfect." It's too close together, but we don't have planes falling from the sky because they're cramming passengers together. --- And now a footnote: Please avoid ad hominem arguments like "please name one system you've..." If the speaker's argument has a logical fallacy, point it out. If the speaker's argument is sound, it doesn't matter whether they write faultless software, or even whether they write software at all. It's the argument we are discussing, not the person making it.
- 6y ago
- AniseAbyss 6y agoGreat now even air crash investigations are about Washington party politics. That will only erode international trust in the FAA further.
- sofixa 6y agoDon't worry, nobody actually trust the FAA anymore. It will take decades to undo the damage.
- shakezula 6y agoThat’s the story of just about every one of our alphabet agencies coming out of this last 4 years, unfortunately.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jacquesm 6y agoTrust can't really go further down than '0' which is roughly where you are right now. The FAA will not be able to walk away from this one without a decade(s) long effort ahead of them to recover the trust they once had.
- nautilus12 6y agoNot defending their actions, but just throwing your hands up and saying the system is broken (and implying the system should be replaced wholesale)isn't productive either. Why not start first by fixing the specific pain points in this system that lead to this scenario rather than replace it and see where that gets you. I feel like democrats have a very deconstructionist perspective these days towards nearly everything. When I do my job I don't start by saying the internet is broken and needs to be replaced. I think sometimes we need to balance our idealism with a couple doses of pragmatism.
- hoorayimhelping 6y ago>The system is supposed to prevent people from dying, 346 people died, the system is broken, it is a fact. Of course we work backward from there. Isn't this just outcome bias though? You're arguing that because there are 346 deaths, the system is necessarily broken. That may not be the case. From what I've seen, it probably is, but it's not a foregone conclusion, and we shouldn't look for evidence supporting that conclusion. 346 deaths might actually be a very small number compared to what could have happened had the system actually been broken. The point is, it's a logical fallacy to say that because there were 346 deaths, the system is broken, and we need to work back from there. This could have been a rare combinatorial explosion of bad luck. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outcome_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outcome_bias
- ncmncm 6y agoThe FAA insisting the plane was airworthy even after two crashes from the same cause eliminates outcome bias. And no system is so broken and corrupt that you won't find plenty of people willing to insist that it is all just fine as it is.
- ta1234567890 6y ago> I hope there are real engineers trying to actually solve the problem behind the scenes. This is mostly a management and political issue, not an engineering one. And being cynical, I'm pretty hopeless about politicians or managers taking responsibility for their actions here.