3 ms·
I'm confused by the example at the end: > On Monday, after 37 years in prison, Robert DuBoise was formally exonerated in Florida for a rape and murder from 198
by tzs 6y ago
I'm confused by the example at the end:
> On Monday, after 37 years in prison, Robert DuBoise was formally exonerated in Florida for a rape and murder from 1983 that DNA evidence now proves he did not commit. He was convicted partly due to testimony from unreliable jailhouse informants and controversial, discredited bite mark analysis. His case is a perfect example of how much our justice system is plagued by bad behavior.
But reading the story they link to for more detail, I didn't see any obvious description of misconduct or bad behavior.
Yes, bite mark analysis is considered mostly bogus now, but that is a fairly recent development. In 1983 it was widely accepted.
And yes, jailhouse informants can be unreliable. They can also be reliable. Just like any other kind of informant. Or any other person who testifies. That's why the defense gets to cross examine them, and it is left up to the jury to decide if a given one is reliable or unreliable.
BTW, don't infer from the apparent weakness of the article's example that the underlying report the article is based on, from the National Registry of Exonerations, is weak. The example from the article is not from the report.
The report does contain a few examples, so I find it odd that the article did not use one of them.