12 ms·
How to form a California LLC without a lawyer
- flowerlad 6y agoCheaper to register in Delaware. Only $300 per year in LLC tax vs $800.
- stillmotion 6y agoYou still have to pay a minimum of $800 a year to the franchise tax board for operating a non-Californian business.
- pianoben 6y agoWord. California always gets its cut. If you're in California, or have customers there, going to other states only increases your potential obligations.
- feross 6y agoExactly. Which is why I just recommend forming a California LLC directly if you live in California (like I do).
- CalChris 6y agoYeah. I understand the advantages of a Delaware C corporation if you need a C corporation. But I don't see the advantages of a Delaware LLC if you will be operating in California.
- CameronNemo 6y agoIf you own the LLC but don't take a salary, do you still have to pay the fee?
- danielrpa 6y agoYes.
- ISL 6y agoNYS was the same way. It was irrelevant whether the company made money or not.
- LordAtlas 6y agoAs a non-US citizen, California taxes and fees seem ridiculous.
- manigandham 6y agoThey are. There's little-to-no benefit derived from these arbitrary fees, especially amongst all the other high taxes in the state.
- koolba 6y agoIf you live in CA and you’re going to cheat the taxman by not registering locally as a foreign corporation, then you might as well register as an Ohio LLC. $99 initial registration and zero annual fee to maintain it.
- smabie 6y agoDelaware courts are very business friendly, so it usually makes sense to register there, even if it's more expensive than other states.
- anon9001 6y agoSure, Ohio is nice because it has no fees and no reporting requirements for $99. But why stop there when you can go to Arizona and get the same deal for $50. But seriously, if you want to cheat California, just leave and move to a more business-friendly state and do your business legally. It's 100% not worth it to operate illegally in California, especially for the registration of an entity that's intended to protect you legally. Oh, also fun, don't forget to explicitly close out your CA business when you finally give up and move out. If you don't, they'll hunt you down for your $800/yr several years later with penalties and interest.
- mellavora 6y agoecho that. Failing to register as a foreign corp operating in CA is going to be seen as tax fraud by the authorities. They don't like that. CA is an expensive place in many ways. Basing your business operations there is only one of them.
- mproud 6y agoIn Minnesota, you pay a one time fee of $135, and renew yearly for free.
- protomyth 6y agoYep, and the renewal takes about 5 minutes online. North Dakota charges $100 then $25 for each annual report. Odd, ND is more expensive.
- dfjacobs 6y agoColorado is $50 to create a LLC, then $10 a year to file your annual report. If you miss the annual report filing date, the fee is $50 to get back in good standing.
- flowerlad 6y agoIt is best to have at least two persons in the LLC. If there is only one owner, then you have less protection as the "veil" can be "pierced". https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/piercing-the-limited-liability-veil-single-member-llc.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/piercing-the-limited...
- feross 6y agoFrom the article: > if you form your small business as an SMLLC, and observe a few basic rules (such as keeping business finances separate from personal finances), you should be personally protected from most kinds of business liability Single-member LLCs which are run properly still get liability protection.
- flowerlad 6y agoSee: https://denhalaw.com/can-you-protect-yourself-with-a-single-member-llc/ https://denhalaw.com/can-you-protect-yourself-with-a-single-... Courts in a variety of states have “pierced the veil” of a single-member LLC from the outside and have held that it is not a separate entity and thus may not be used to protect the assets of the LLC from the creditors of the member. You get liability protection, yes, but not as much as you would if you had one more member. The veil can be pierced for various reasons, so to reduce risk you want to minimize those reasons as much as possible.
- fountainofage 6y agoI think this is interesting in that I don't know many people who view LLC's protections this way. The classic example is that if your rental property is in an LLC, then your tenants can't win a suit and get to your own personal house. These examples of piercing the veil are from the other direction - a personal suit getting access to the LLC assets... Which sort of makes sense - the alternative would be the court ordering the seizure of my assets - which would be my ownership stake in the LLC. So in their example, I'd still expect to lose my ownership stake in my LLC by asset seizure even if I was in a multi-owner LLC... Or had stock in an S-corp.
- flowerlad 6y agoYou may also need a registered agent for "Service of process". Costs $100 per year. Without it you risk default judgement in case of a lawsuit. https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/what-is-an-agent-for-service-of-process https://www.legalzoom.com/articles/what-is-an-agent-for-serv...
- feross 6y agoYou can just use your personal mailing address and check it for mail.
- Cactus2018 6y agoYou can act as your own Registered Agent for a corporation or LLC as long as you have a physical street address in the state where your corporation or LLC is formed. The actual corporation or LLC being formed, however, cannot name itself as its own Registered Agent.
- closeparen 6y agoThis puts your name, address, and association with your company name into public record. Not recommended if there is >0 probability of attention from internet crazies.
- inoffensivename 6y agoYou also need to file a California Form 568 tax return with the Franchise Tax Board and pay the $800 annual tax whether or not you have any income, or you get a big fine that increases every month you don't file... Ask me how I know :)
- xur17 6y ago> pay the $800 annual fee whether or not you have any income Really? In the 2 states I've lived in, there is no annual fee for LLC's. I'm curious what the reasoning behind having a fee that large is.
- nkozyra 6y agoI'm surprised. I've had two in Florida and both had annual report fees ~ $150. But if you don't pay your LLC just goes defunct. Making it a mandatory fee you can't escape kind of flies in the face of the whole point of an llc
- abi 6y agoBasically, because CA can get away with it.
- bmiller2 6y agoIf California can tax it, oh they will tax it.
- m463 6y agotax what you want less of.
- ende 6y agoUnless it’s land that wealthy people owned before 1967 and don’t want to pay taxes on.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoPlease call them by their chosen name “The Peoples Republic of California”
- unstatusthequo 6y agoAs a lawyer, but not your lawyer, please consider a Delaware LLC. California is not where you want to litigate and it’s yearly fees are absurd. Delaware is the gold standard.
- jusob 6y agoYou still have to pay the $800 to California if you reside there.
- manigandham 6y agoOr if you operate there.
- 2bitlobster 6y agoWhy would you want to as opposed to Delaware?
- Stratoscope 6y agoIf you're in California, they will get their $800 regardless. It doesn't matter where you create the LLC, California has a minimum $800 tax on it.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> they will get their $800 regardless California law is convoluted and Californian courts slow. That makes doing almost everything with a California LLC more expensive than with a Delaware LLC. The only reason to form a California entity is if you’re doing business with the state.
- Stratoscope 6y agoIf you live and work in California, you are doing business with the state. You aren't going to avoid that, no matter how hard you try.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> If you live and work in California, you are doing business with the state In a revenue sense, e.g. if you are contracting with the state. Paying California taxes is about equally easy for a California resident, New York resident or Delaware entity. Or if you’re operating a small business unlikely to ever need to use the courts or raise outside capital, and the extra ~$300 for a Delaware entity isn’t worth the benefits.
- shrimpx 6y agoI wonder about this. Suppose you incorporate a LLC in Delaware that buys some stocks, and some houses in Arizona and rents them out. But you live in California. Is your LLC “doing business with California”?
- Archit3ch 6y agoCan you do this if you're not a US citizen? I assume you'd need a US-based partner in the LLC.
- cobbzilla 6y agoCompanies that are entirely foreign-owned are perfectly legal. You do not need a US-based partner. But if you're not a US-citizen and want to create a company in the US, I would highly recommend NOT forming it in California, for cost/paperwork reasons. There are many other US states that are much more business-friendly to choose from.
- ramraj07 6y agoWhat if you have to bill clients incorporated in CA?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cobbzilla 6y ago(IANAL disclaimer) Merely having customers in California does not create a "locus of business" in CA that would require you to pay the $800 annual fee. On the other hand, if you have an office and/or employees in CA, it probably would.
- athms 6y ago>IANAL Stop giving legal advice. Billing clients in California can create a nexus but it depends on the amount of sales. A company is considered doing business and subject to California tax laws if state sales or property exceed the following amounts: * CA sales of $601,967 or 25% of total sales. * CA real and tangible personal property worth $60,197 or 25% of total property. Also, if a company engages in any transaction for the purpose of financial gain within California, the Franchise Tax Board considers that doing business within the state. An example would be meeting potential clients during a professional conference and negotiating a sale. This can be done by either a member of the LLC, an employee, or an agent such as an independent contractor.
- Stratoscope 6y agoI have a California LLC and wish I didn't. It has been nothing but an albatross around my neck. I am almost certain I will shut it down at the end of this year. Look, if you're reading articles like this one, don't do it. Just don't do it. Get competent legal and accounting advice first. I formed my LLC four years ago when an interesting contracting project came my way. I'd worked as a 1099/Schedule C contractor in the past, but this client wanted me to have an LLC. OK, no big deal. Then it turned out they also required the LLC to be taxed as an S Corp. No big deal there either, it's a simple IRS form to make that election. Now guess what? You have to start filing 1120S corporate taxes plus the California equivalent. All the LLC/S Corp income flows right through onto your personal tax return, but you also get to get to file 940 and 941 payroll tax forms and the state equivalents. And whether your LLC is taxed as an S Corp or not, you have to pay the $800/year California minimum tax on it. Yes, even though the LLC/S Corp really has no net income of its own (as it all flows into your personal tax return), you will owe that $800/year. Even if you create your LLC in another state. Do not try to do this yourself. You will get it wrong and will pay many thousands of dollars in penalties as I have. I finally realized I would be much better off just working for another company and letting them deal with all these headaches. They have an entire team to deal with it! If I had a time machine, I would have stuck with regular employment instead of thinking of myself as an independent business. Forget about the fabled "corporate veil". If the IRS and FTB decide they want their money, they are going to get it. If you do think this still sounds like a good idea, you must use a payroll service to pay yourself. After my initial fiasco of trying to do it myself, I started using Gusto [1] and they are pretty great. For filing the LLC itself, I used SunDoc Filings [2] and they are really good too. They helped me on very short notice when I made a mistake on my LLC filing that would have caused it to be rejected. But really, think twice, or a dozen times, before you open this can of worms. Sorry for all the italics. :-) But this is something where I have some painful experience, and if I can help steer people away from it I hope it will be helpful. [1] https://gusto.com/ https://gusto.com/ [2] https://www.sundocumentfilings.com/ https://www.sundocumentfilings.com/
- c17r 6y agoI've never run into a case where the client cared how I reported my taxes. How would they even know? Did they give you a reason for this?
- arthurcolle 6y agoWhat's the best bank to use for a newly formed LLC? I'm torn on whether or not to use Axos
- toomuchtodo 6y agohttps://mercury.com https://mercury.com No relation, just a happy user. Founder lurks on here, answered some questions in a thread, that’s how I found them.
- arthurcolle 6y agoCould you shoot me an email? I'd like to discuss your experience further if you are interested!
- selectodude 6y agoI started a business account with PNC in 45 minutes.
- dawnerd 6y agoI’ve been using Azlo and had no problems. They’re pretty bare bones however.
- redis_mlc 6y agoHaving done my own legal work for over 20 years, I still haven't found a compelling reason to create an LLC for small-time businesses. People often ask me, "how do I start a software startup in the US?" and I answer, "You usually don't have to do anything." Since in the US you have the option to create startups with no government approval, you should take advantage of that. If you get funding, normally you have to redo the LLC the way the lead investor insists anyway, so just skip all the paperwork and fees and don't bother. If you're paranoid, work on a detailed ToS instead. Regarding banks, most people are happy with BofA or Chase for the customer support. If you want to deposit checks in your business name, you will need to create a separate business account using the DBA form in California. I've heard gripes about SV Bank, so reserve that one for VCs. Note that banks don't enforce dual signature withdrawals, so if you can't trust your partner, don't put their name on the account. Regarding residential zoning laws, don't park a bunch of cars in the street in front of your house.
- gojomo 6y agoThe article claims as a second benefit of an LLC: > 2. Tax benefits. You can deduct qualified business expenses from the total income of the business. Here’s a simple example: If you spent $1,000 on servers and your website made $10,000, then you’ll only pay taxes on the $9,000 in profit. You don't need an LLC to deduct such expenses. Even sole proprietors can deduct business expenses against business profits.
- therockspush 6y agothe value of the llc or s-corp is the corporate veil. whether or not thats worth the $800 annual charge in CA, on top of other inconveniences, is the question.
- unishark 6y agoIndeed anyone self-employed, full-time or part-time. A LLC just (hopefully) gains you liability protection and perhaps a bit more legitimacy, in return for a big fee in California.
- themodelplumber 6y ago*For single-member LLCs. In other cases it may take your CPA all of five minutes to show you the financial math as to why it's a wise move.
- vmception 6y agosole proprietorships and other unincorporated ventures are getting a lot more respect and seamlessness lately! the stimulus programs specifically included them and the SBA asked no questions you do still want the liability protections, more disciplined separation of assets and accounting by having an incorporated name, and deterrent to people looking to sue, alongside additional levels of anonymity if you choose which can further deter potential creditors they can also make elections to parallel regulatory or tax regimes, which you don't want to alter on your personal body. such as election 475 for active traders, converting capital gains and losses into ordinary income allowing for unlimited tax deductions on losses, instead of the default status for capital. or setting up "blocker" corporations in other jurisdictions to help other people avoid onerous default tax regimes.
- jonsno56 6y agoCrap. I actually missed 1-2 years of paying the $800 franchise tax because like a lot of other people on this thread, it’s just used for hobbies, makes no money, and lies fallow 99% of the time. I’ve never gotten a fine in the mail for this though. Does anyone know if there’s some sort of online portal or phone number that is the best place for me to pay all the taxes and fines and make sure that in their records I am even?
- unishark 6y agoPerhaps you want the website for the secretary of state. You can also look up any business and see all the public forms plus the address they're using (for those notices you're not getting). https://businesssearch.sos.ca.gov/ https://businesssearch.sos.ca.gov/
- ghancock 6y agoIt might be that the LLC is liable for the taxes and not you personally. Do you really want to pay $1600 for something you aren’t really using or do you want to abandon it and walk away?
- dboreham 6y agoTax collecting people probably already thought about that problem..
- revel 6y agoNot a lawyer but been through the incorporation process a few times: get a startup lawyer and commit to spending $2-5k just on legal fees in your first year. Each patent you want is $20k so you should probably not waste your time or money with one unless you're damn sure you need it and it's essential to your business. If you screw up the paperwork it will prevent you from raising money or work with others and kill your business. Honestly, I know it sucks to have to pay money that seems unrelated to your startup, but you'll pay it back many times over and have to set things up properly anyway
- jjeaff 6y agoYa, we hired a top tier SV firm. They just used their own fill in the blank forms like you would get from legal zoom. And I even had to make corrections and send it back multiple times because they got the share numbers wrong and forgot to replace multiple mentions of the last company they used the form on.
- jaja99 6y agoCan someone tell me how to form LLC in WA state and not publish our home/business address? We will be working from home, but we don’t want our home address to end up in public search records. Any help or recommendation?
- poulsbohemian 6y agoGet a mailbox at a UPS store or similar mail drop service. Easy peasy. This gets around the "No PO Box" requirements that many government forms have because the mail drop service will have a storefront address. So you end up being 124 Mainstreet Box 47.
- poulsbohemian 6y agoI know (because I saw it recently) that if lawyer assists you with forming a C corp in WA, their address can be used and they become an agent for your business, IE: they potentially get all your renewal paperwork, etc. I'm assuming if you had a lawyer form your LLC that they could do the same. That said - I've had a WA LLC for decades, my partner has formed LLCs in WA, etc... it's trivial to do yourself and fairly harmless to include your home address. In the month since she formed her most recent, I think we've had two pieces of junk mail. I did a search with the DOR a few minutes ago - yes, the address shows up for my business but not for hers, so who knows whether your address would even be published?
- gamblor956 6y agoS corps are generally preferable to LLCs if you are eligible to form one, but it also depends on your goals, i.e. if you intend to raise money, you need an LLC or C Corp. I formed an S corp for my personal protects for tax reasons. I also used legalzoom, because it's good enough for most small businesses. (And even big ones; Panda Express is an S corp.)
- shrimpx 6y agoJust curious, what are some of the tax benefits you gain with an s corp?
- siberianbear 6y agoI also don't understand the parent's comment. An LLC can make a tax election with the IRS to be taxed as an S-Corp.
- jccooper 6y agoChapter S election (which an LLC can do, by the way, it's not a particular type of entity) does pass through taxing, and has a thing where the "profit distribution" of the corp, after paying shareholders "a reasonable salary", can be distributed without self-employment taxes, just regular income taxes. So you can save some 15% on some portion of your income--if you have an income larger than whatever you may be able to justify to the IRS as a reasonable salary. Other options may make sense based on how much money is kept in the company, if you have passive investors, how much money you're making, how much work the shareholders do, etc.
- rayshan 6y agoWhat SaaS product is everyone using for forming companies nowadays? Stripe Atlas? Clerky? Gust?
- shrimpx 6y agoAtlas
- pmayrgundter 6y agoZenbusiness is my friend's, based in Austin
- giorgioz 6y agoThe best resource I found when I was forming a US LLC was https://www.llcuniversity.com https://www.llcuniversity.com
- kogus 6y agoIn some states, all you need is a federal EIN, which you can get free on the IRS site in about five minutes. https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/employer-id-numbers https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe... I live in SC, and you don't even have to inform the state that you formed an LLC. If you do want to, its about $100 and takes another online form. The idea that you would need a lawyer is absurd.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoPutting hurdles up (like $500 LLC fees) in front of the various things that "legit businesses do" is a form of regulatory capture. Basically the goal is to force businesses to choose between heavily buying into the status quo or giving government power of arbitrary enforcement over them. The licensed plumbers don't want all the journeymen who haven't spent years getting a license but can install a toilet just as well undercutting them and stealing their gravy business. By imposing regulatory hurdles at every step of the way you keep those "I'm not quite big enough to go 100% above the table" businesses under the table you keep them on the down low and you keep them from affecting regulatory change. By the time those journeymen plumbers have licenses of their own and can be 100% above the table they feel entitled to the gravy and don't want to change anything. (I only picked plumbing because it's a good example in my state, there's plenty of others).
- la6471 6y agoThe absolute horrible thing about forming a Llc in California is the $800 FTB tax, that you have to pay irrespective of wether you have any income or not. This is really discouraging for any individual who is trying to start a business and is unsure of the outcome in the initial years.
- charliepark 6y agoAlso, it’s on the calendar year, not a rolling 12-month calendar. And it isn’t prorated. File your paperwork in early December? That’s $800 now and $800 in a few months. Wait until January if you’re close to the end of the year and can afford to hold off.
- juandazapata 6y agoThat’s ~$67/mo to stay in business. I don’t see how this can be considered a horrible thing.
- ashconnor 6y agoIn the UK I paid a £13 a year to file accounts online to keep my dormant company running.
- mdorazio 6y agoWhen you're a very small business losing money the first few years of operating and California sticks you with an $800 bill on top of local taxes that are also levied regardless of income (business personal property), it's a giant slap in the face that makes you want to move your business to pretty much any other state.
- athms 6y agoThen move. But remember, if you do business in California, you must still pay the franchise fee if you have a company that is NOT a sole proprietor or general partnership. Incorporating in another state will not save you, you must register with Secretary of State as a foreign entity.
- giancarlostoro 6y agoI had no idea LLC's were so expensive elsewhere, here in Florida it's roughly $150 last I remember and you can do it online, I think most people I've met just do it all online.
- elchin 6y agoCost: $800, repeat every year
- aerodog 6y agoSo true. And so shitty.
- bsdadmin 6y agoMake sure you do your LLC banking at a different bank than your personal checking account.
- AS126 6y agoVery useful. That's why I like this community.
- happyjack 6y agoIn my state it's $100 to file, and a $50 fee each year (if assets are < $250,000). If you're a single member LLC, you don't even have to have articles of incorporation. You can even file a sketchy shell company and pay a registered agent to use their address. Also, no state taxes either. It's about a 10 minute process.