5 ms·
The PR battle has nothing to do with the lack of investment. That all comes down to well-supported reactors not even being buildable. Even EDF in France, which
by epistasis 6y ago
The PR battle has nothing to do with the lack of investment. That all comes down to well-supported reactors not even being buildable.
Even EDF in France, which has massive support, can't build nuclear these days, and France is often cited as nuclear's greatest success stories.
It's time to stop blaming boogie men for nuclear's failures, because that does nothing to help it succeed. Anti-nuke "greens" blame does allow for building a culture war, which is why I think it survives in the public imagination. However, in utility boardrooms, and at the NRC, none of that has stopped the world's attempts at building the next generation nuclear fleet. What has stopped that is the cost of construction.
It doesn't matter whether there is outsider opposition to the tech if it can't even be built economically.
- jandrese 6y agoI guess the next question is: Why is the construction and operation so expensive? Did the cost of steel and concrete skyrocket? Are new reactors excessively complex? Is there insufficient competition in the industry to keep costs under control? Excessive regulatory compliance costs compared to other forms of power generation? Is it the cost of paying a team lawyers for decades to keep fighting all of the lawsuits?
- Lavery 6y agoI read a study a while ago arguing that reactor cost was as expensive as it is because nuclear plants are so large, complex, and infrequently built that each project is essentially bespoke.
- jandrese 6y agoWas that study by chance suggesting a large number of small mass produced reactors? It's a workable idea unless you think the problem is that every reactor, no matter how large, has to deal with red tape and lawsuits from NIMBYs.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoI believe the cost of construction labor has outperformed inflation & materials have tracked inflation. But the cost of energy has underperformed inflation. If the trend continues for much longer, energy sources which require less labor will become more competitive (solar). If you're a greenie - this is a good thing. Because oil has almost nothing going for it beside how good a source of energy it is for jet/rocket fuel.
- crubier 6y agoI am 99% sur that solar requires more manpower than nuclear, for an equivalent controllable power output.
- renewiltord 6y agoYeah, but it's more granular and you can deregulate it and still be safe, so you can leave it to the market to handle pretty easily.
- philipkglass 6y agoThe Desert Sunlight solar farm generated 1,344,841 MWh in 2018 [1] while employing 15 people full time [2]. That is an annualized output of 10.2 megawatts per full time employee. The Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant generated 18,213,519 MWh in 2018 with 1400 full time employees [3]. That is an annualized output of of 1.5 megawatts per FTE. During operation, the solar farm generates more than 6 times as much energy per FTE. Of course you need storage too for solar to supply power after sundown. I looked at some recent utility scale battery project news, like the Moss Landing project currently under construction, but I couldn't find information about these projects adding any number of permanent jobs after construction. They may be too low maintenance. Finally, you need to amortize the project construction labor over the life of the project to get an all-in labor intensity analysis. Diablo Canyon was unfortunately built long enough ago that contemporary reporting was pre-digital. From recent nuclear projects in the United States, it looks like nuclear projects don't have lower lifetime labor intensity (inclusive of construction) than solar + storage either. The low labor intensity of large scale renewables is an under-appreciated point. Most of the labor is front-loaded into the construction phase, and doesn't amount to a lot per lifetime MWh. When you see breathless reports about how solar power is employing a boatload of people, they're talking about short term construction work. If solar power were at steady-state, as mature as coal or nuclear power, it wouldn't provide many jobs. The only reason its job numbers are so much higher than coal/nuclear is because coal/nuclear are stagnant/declining while solar is still in the rapid growth/construction phase. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desert_Sunlight_Solar_Farm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desert_Sunlight_Solar_Farm [2] https://www.energy.gov/lpo/desert-sunlight https://www.energy.gov/lpo/desert-sunlight [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diablo_Canyon_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diablo_Canyon_Power_Plant
- belorn 6y agoFossil fueled power plants are cheap, quick to build, and has plenty of private companies that compete for the contracts. The cost per MWh has almost been cut in half for natural gas in the last 10 years, while nuclear is struggling to reduce costs (if at all). The cheapest possible energy gird currently available is to use wind as much as the weather allows it since it has currently the lowest cost per produced MWh, and natural gas for everything else. Solar is also starting to reach similar cost per MWh as natural gas when weather allows it. We might see a renewal in nuclear if natural gas (and other fossil fuels) were taxed to the point of being economical unattractive. Without that I don't expect something that cost twice as much to compete in a market with a fungible commodity.
- wrsh07 6y agoI think this overlooks the ways that opposition can increase costs of building nuclear and the extreme safety burden imposed on nuclear plants but not other energy plants & sources > The strict safety regulations imposed on the nuclear industry are another reason why capital costs are so high. [1] This is actually covered a bit in a recent 80,000 hours episode: https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/mark-lynas-climate-change-nuclear-energy/ https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/mark-lynas-climate-c... [1] https://thebulletin.org/2019/06/why-nuclear-power-plants-cost-so-much-and-what-can-be-done-about-it/ https://thebulletin.org/2019/06/why-nuclear-power-plants-cos...
- gameswithgo 6y agoIf safety costs were not high, then suddenly the boogie men might be correct about the dangers?
- whatshisface 6y agoThe right balance would be to let nuclear meet the same safety standards as other power sources, instead of far higher ones.
- throw0101a 6y agoThe fatality rates of other source of electricity are much higher, and they seem to be accepted: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents * https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy https://ourworldindata.org/safest-sources-of-energy So why is there an insistence on potentially over-engineering nuclear? Why the insistence on lower rates of nuclear compared to other type of generation? If we don't want to reduce nuclear safety—which is completely reasonable—then to be consistent, other forms of generation should be made safer—which may drive their costs up. Pick a rate that is acceptable, and have design goals around that. Either by making things less onerous for nuclear or more onerous for others. There are all sorts of gas generators coming online (because of fracking), and while they may be better than coal, but that's hardly a useful way to eliminate emissions. Pushker Kharecha and James Hansen: > Our findings also have important implications for large-scale "fuel switching" to natural gas from coal or from nuclear. Although natural gas burning emits less fatal pollutants and GHGs than coal burning, it is far deadlier than nuclear power, causing about 40 times more deaths per unit electric energy produced (ref. 2). * https://www.giss.nasa.gov/research/briefs/kharecha_02/ https://www.giss.nasa.gov/research/briefs/kharecha_02/
- cmehdy 6y agoThe cost is upfront for nuclear and that's what doesn't align with society's immediate goals. France is no exception to that (and in fact if you know more about the state of research in France for example you can see that long-term investments aren't valued highly enough either). That's why despite the knowledge being there (and exported, just check out what french companies do in China) the main obstacle is political and societal: people are still scared, and politicians oscillate constantly on the matter of nuclear energy (Fessenheim, EPR etc) and therefore cannot actually develop a consistent position over the development phase. France actually has a ton of benefits from using nuclear (check out maps pollution-related deaths, check out hybrid car CO2 emissions per km, etc) but it takes a long-term vision to make big commitments that can pay off handsomely, and most of the world is fairly myopic (and my country is no exception). I could point you towards [1] the perception of nuclear risk (nuclear waste first, nuclear reactors second) in France being much higher than the perception of floods/fire/medical risks/terrorism, and much higher than the real numbers[2]. There is a HUGE disconnect between what people THINK nuclear power plants and nuclear waste are in terms of risk and what actually is problematic, and this oscillation has been very strong in public opinion (after all, it was Hollande 4 years ago who committed to closing a perfectly fine Fessenheim following public opinion more than anything else). So no, it's not about being buildable or not. Nuclear power plants are buildable. They're just not giving the private sector a good return on investment in today's market, and therefore it's on governments to get moving but for them to enact change their voters need to be consistently wanting it too. It's not even just a nuclear problem: just look at how public transportation can often be a constant fight between parties which delays advancements by decades (see: Toronto). [1] (in French) perceived moderate and high risks for various items in social awareness: https://i.imgur.com/iPpS6rM.jpg https://i.imgur.com/iPpS6rM.jpg [2] (in French) actual amounts of deaths related to many of the items of the previous image: https://i.imgur.com/fOwKjka.jpg https://i.imgur.com/fOwKjka.jpg
- 7952 6y agoThere is a false dichotomy being presented here. A piece of infrastructure can be both technically difficult and politically challenging. I think that applies to traditional nuclear power stations. Nuclear engineering is difficult, and that makes it more difficult to build nuclear power plants! And past success and knowledge is not a licence to success in the future.
- bananabreakfast 6y agoThey can absolutely be built economically, but they are hobbled by excessive regulation due to public fear. This argument is akin to when congress accuses the US Postal Service of losing money and being uneconomic, when in reality congress itself mandated that it must be run that way.
- epistasis 6y agoI'm not sure that I've ever seen somebody in the field suggest a reform that would reduce that cost, except for the small modular style construction. That is to say, nobody involved with the process has a suggestion on what regulations are unnecessarily increasing costs. So I don't think the USPS is comparable, as there are very clear and easy fixes that would solve their problems (ie increase stamp prices). When you look at what happened with Westinghouse and the AP-1000 in Georgia and South Carolina, it seems that parts of the problem is that the designs weren't even buildable as they were laid out, and when it came time to build the construction side just went ahead with whatever they could hobble together. So it's been suggested that if the NRC checked the plans not only for safety, but also basic construct ability, then maybe these massive projects would succeed. But because the engineers did not do their job, and construction teams did jobs they shouldn't have, and the business arrangements were such that all this went sideways instead of problems being identified and fixed, there was massive failure. Personally, I think more regulation has a better chance of fixing the industry rather than less regulation. The executives are clearly incompetent and have no clue or long term planning ability.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>I'm not sure that I've ever seen somebody in the field suggest a reform that would reduce that cost, You don't wind up in the nuclear field by being dumb and smart people don't say things that can easily be construed by the opposition as advocating for reduced safety.
- epistasis 6y agoThat doesn't sound like a smart strategy to me, because it leads to the conclusion that every regulation is necessary for safety and noting can be cut. Meanwhile at the same time lots of people are saying "too much regulation drives up costs," which means that the implication is still that nuclear advocates are asking for less safety fit cost savings.
- konjin 6y agoThe West has not been able to build any sort of infrastructure for a generation [1]. It's not that we can't build nuclear power plants on time and budget, it's that we can't build anything larger than a sports stadium period and we can only get over that by drowning it in money and hoping for the best. Green energy is great in this regard because solar panels are just roofing and wind turbines are just really skinny 5 story buildings. Hell you're on a website that exists only because no one is willing to do the type of R&D that build the tools we use in the first place (unix, arpanet, computers) so we instead outsourced it to people in garages and hope for something that works, or at least looks like it works and makes a ton of money before it crashes and burns (hi twitter!). https://www.spglobal.com/en/research-insights/featured/infrastructure-investment-as-an-elixir-for-ailing-u-s-productivity-growth https://www.spglobal.com/en/research-insights/featured/infra...
- renewiltord 6y agoThe way I see it is you can measure how economical these things are in a country where they don't listen to the people. So I look to China and see if they think it's worth it. And Chinese nuclear power is spiking. They're building loads of reactors and loads of renewables. It looks like their renewables growth is more than the nuke growth, but they're doing the nuke thing too, which makes it seem like the economics aren't the thing.
- yorwba 6y ago> So I look to China and see if they think it's worth it. And Chinese nuclear power is spiking. Spiking? They approved two reactors this year and most years since Fukushima they didn't approve any. https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3100097/chinas-cabinet-approves-two-new-nuclear-power-plants-push https://www.scmp.com/economy/china-economy/article/3100097/c... ...after the 2011 Fukushima nuclear plant disaster in Japan, China halted its approval of new reactors for four years. These resumed in 2015, largely driven by Beijing’s pledge to cut carbon emissions. Then, from 2016 to 2018, the country again stopped granting permission for the construction of new nuclear power plants. After three new plants were approved in June 2019, government approvals again ground to a halt until this week.
- renewiltord 6y agoYou don't need that many approvals a year. They're doing just fine. Check out the construction pipeline. They have 10.6 GW under construction right now. That's a 25% increase when it's built. Tianwan-5 was just hooked up to the grid last month.
- epistasis 6y agoFor comparison, China added ~30GW of solar in 2019. To make the GW of solar more comparable, one must adjust for capacity factors, which round to 1 for nuclear but is ~0.25 for new solar. So China added the equivalent of 7 nuclear reactors worth of solar TWh last year. They are also great at adding HVDC, which the US desperately needs.
- 6y ago
- bryanlarsen 6y agoSheer incompetence has much more to do with our inability to build nuclear than the anti-nuke greens or onerous regulations do. Read about the comedy of errors that was Westinghouse's plans to build reactors in the US and their descent into bankruptcy. “The cause of this latest problem seems to have nothing to do with nuclear power and everything to do with incompetent business practices, particularly Toshiba’s construction contractor,” Conca wrote. https://www.triplepundit.com/story/2017/westinghouse-bankruptcy-end-nuclear-power/18391 https://www.triplepundit.com/story/2017/westinghouse-bankrup...