6 ms·
Yes, nvidia (the proprietary GPU driver) was way better than fglrx (the proprietary amd driver) and even nouveau (the open source reverse engineered driver for
by Macha 6y ago
Yes, nvidia (the proprietary GPU driver) was way better than fglrx (the proprietary amd driver) and even nouveau (the open source reverse engineered driver for Nvidia) worked better than radeon for me in those days. It was intel for smooth sailing or nvidia for acceptable performance.
I think their unpopularity these days come from three factors:
1. For the gamer crowd, RTX 2000 was a price hike and even the higher end cards were not that impressive for performance. It looks like they were resting on their lead against AMD.
2. People love to root for the underdog and AMD was behind for the longest time.
3. For the developer crowd, the closed source Nvidia drivers were not great for Linux compatibility, and the Mac crowd couldn't care because they couldn't have Nvidia after their fight with Apple.
I think for a sample of the general public who have opinions on Nvidia, it's 1,2 and 3 in that order while for HN users, it's 3, 2 and 1 in that order.
- KptMarchewa 6y agoNouveau is extremely slow, and was slow on several of my machines for at least 5 years. I'm not sure how it's any better.
- rhn_mk1 6y agoNouveau is only slow because about 5 years ago Nvidia started signing the card firmware, excluding Nouveau from using some features like setting appropriate clock speeds. They release some pared down firmware that Nouveau is allowed to use, but not after years from release have passed. Before that mess (around the 900 series), nouveau was fast.
- smichel17 6y agoCan confirm; I had a laptop (Dell XPS 14) with a GT630m and Nouveau worked well enough that I never felt the need to install the proprietary drivers over 4 years of use.
- Macha 6y agoI'm replying to the parent comment about AMD pre-open-source drivers. So we're already 5 years ago. I had my Linux install in a VM for a number of years because fglrx was an aggravating experience (unstable, often broke on kernel updates) to use and radeon had abysmal performance on my 290x. To the point that my laptops 540m (on nouveau) would outperform the 290x under linux. I still have that 290x in one of my systems, and since amdgpu supported it it has been a very pleasant experience. But even that took a while as they started with 3xx and supported the 4xx cards before going back for the 2xx cards.
- fossuser 6y agoI still don't really understand the context around the Apple fight and it's a huge bummer, since Apple hardware with Nvidia GPUs would be the best combination. When I used Linux the closed source Nvidia drivers were better than anything else and easily available, the complaints around them seemed mostly to be ideological? The price complaints seemed mostly about 'value' since the performance was still better than the competition in absolute terms.
- formerly_proven 6y ago> The price complaints seemed mostly about 'value' since the performance was still better than the competition in absolute terms. Just because company A makes the fastest card does not imply that company A makes the faster card at every price point.
- fossuser 6y agoTrue, but in Nvidia's case I think they did? Well - they charged more at each price point because they were faster. At some prices I think it wasn't enough to justify the extra cost from a price to performance ratio, but that doesn't seem like a reason to think they're bad. It's possible I'm a little out of date on this, I only keep up to date on the hardware when it's relevant for me to do a new build.
- Certhas 6y ago> Well - they charged more at each price point... Are you joking? How is it the same price point when they are charging more?
- Macha 6y agoIf vendor A's cards are $180, $280 and $380 and vendor B's cards are $150, $250 and $350, it's common practice to group them into three price points of $150-199, $250-299 and $350-399 so that each card gets compared to its nearest in price.
- formerly_proven 6y ago> 2. People love to root for the underdog and AMD was behind for the longest time. AMD has had pretty much always a solid mid-tier offering in the last five years, but people would still rather buy an nVidia card (like, say, a 1050) instead of the better AMD (at the price point) because of the "1080 Ti" halo effect. nVidias software stack is pretty bad. Sure, the driver core works pretty well. The nVidia control panel looks like it was last updated in 2004, which is actually true (go find some screenshots of it from 15 years ago running on XP, it looks the same). Now, that doesn't mean it has to be bad (don't fix what isn't broken), but the NCP is actually clunky to use. Not to imply AMD's variant is necessarily better, but at least they're working on it. The nVidia "value-adds" like shadow play and so on are all extremely buggy. And while their core driver may be good, you still get somewhat frequent driver resets and hangs with certain interactive GPU compute applications.
- paulmd 6y agopeople say that but much of the time AMD has excluded themselves from consideration for other reasons. 5000 series, 7000/200 series, and 480/Vega series all saw major cryptomining booms that raised prices far beyond those of the equivalent NVIDIA cards, so for much of the time they were simply not priced competitively. Like, for almost a year you would have to pay $1000+ for a Vega that barely matched a 1080 while you could get a 1080 Ti for $800 or so. Also, there's been constant driver problems literally since the ATI days, just recently drivers basically crippled Navi for the entire duration of the product generation, drivers crippled Vega previously, Fiji was a driver mess, Hawaii and Tahiti were not problem free either (the famous "company A vs B vs C" article [0] notes that "company B's drivers are bad and are on a downtrend" and that was during the heyday of GCN, in 2014, those were the "stable drivers" that everyone rhapsodizes about in comparison to the mess that is Navi/Vega). Terascale was a fucking mess too. AMD products often have weaker feature sets. It took them years to catch up with G-Sync (offering low-quality products with poor quality control for years until NVIDIA cleaned things up with GSync Compatible certification). NVENC is far better than AMD's equivalent (Navi's H264 encoder is still broken entirely as far as I know, it provides less than realtime encoding speed and extremely poor quality), so if you want to stream with AMD you have to use your CPU and crush your framerate, or purchase a much more expensive CPU. AMD has no answer for DLSS, and is just implementing their first generation RTX support with the next generation. This is what I refer to as the "NVIDIA mind control field" theory. That consumers are just so wowed by the NVIDIA brand that they can't help themselves. The reality is AMD simply has not been that compelling an offering for that much of the time. There has been a lot of poor execution over the years from the Radeon team and prices have often not been as good as people remember them to be. And a few good products don't change that either. Like, it took something like 8 years of AMD slacking off (Raja mentioned in a presentation that around 2012 thatAMD management thought "discrete GPUs were going away" [1] and pulled the plug on R&D - certainly a very attractive idea given their budgetary problems at the time) for NVIDIA to reach their current level of dominance. AMD has never led the market for 8 years at a time. Maybe a year tops, usually NVIDIA has responded pretty quickly with price cuts and new products. NVIDIA has never let off the pedal the way AMD did (and yes money was the reason but that doesn't matter to consumers, they're buying products not giving to charity). [0] http://richg42.blogspot.com/2014/05/the-truth-on-opengl-driver-quality.html http://richg42.blogspot.com/2014/05/the-truth-on-opengl-driv... [1] https://youtu.be/590h3XIUfHg?t=1956 https://youtu.be/590h3XIUfHg?t=1956