5 ms·
Microsoft confirms IE10 won't run on Vista, millions of IE9 users shrug
- lmkg 16y agoIE9 not supporting XP at least had some sort of justification, regardless of whether it was a good decision. Vista was a large platform upgrade/rewrite, and they mentioned particular features IE9 was using that they didn't want to bother re-implementing for XP (graphics stack, security). But Win7 is not such a drastic upgrade over Vista (architecturally, anyways). So what's the explanation for this?
- cookiecaper 16y agoThe explanation is probably, "We want to sell licenses for the latest version of Windows". Microsoft played the lock-in game too well and they can't even get their customers to upgrade to new versions of the same software. Since Windows is a one-time purchase, if no one is buying the new versions of Windows, Microsoft is making much money off of these new versions.
- billswift 16y agoI've been using Windows and Linux side-by-side for different things since 1996. Some things have just been more trouble to set up in Linux than I wanted to bother with, with Windows available and easy to use. But Vista annoyed me enough that I am gradually switching more of my work to Linux, hopefully by the time this Vista box dies, I will just switch everything over to Linux.
- nfm 16y agoIs it just me, or can nobody else see this working in practice? Upgrading to Windows 7 to get IE 10 seems like a classic "You're doing it wrong"!
- bruceboughton 16y agoBy itself, yes. But if there are 5 other MS products where the latest version is not supported on Vista, they start to add up. It could be 3 successive IE releases, for example...
- kenjackson 16y agoWhat's the justification for Safari 5 not supporting Tiger? Safari 5 came out 62 months after Tiger. If we assume that IE10 comes out in 12 months from today then IE10 will come out 65 months after Vista.
- danparsonson 16y agoHmm that's two different browsers, two different operating systems and two different vendors - what's your point?
- kenjackson 16y agoIf you can't see my point, honestly I don't think I could explain it to you. Imagine I just said, "nothing to see here, move along". Don't spend too much time on it.
- shriphani 16y agoHacker News is the port of call for the more skilled members of the Apple Fan Club. I find it quite amusing since one of the most impressive kinect "hacks" ever was pulled off @ MIX but this is the most upvoted MS article in the last 2 days.
- danparsonson 16y agoApologies, I think my brain took a holiday yesterday.
- mkr-hn 16y agoTwo vendors, browsers, and operating systems competing in the same space. Expecting one of those competitors to support its browser past a certain number of OS releases without expecting the other to is a double standard.
- danparsonson 16y agoThank you for the straightforward answer - I think I was having a slow day yesterday!
- KeyBoardG 16y agoProbably ARM support thats coming with newer code out of Microsoft. May have been too costly and had too many breaking changes to get it on Vista. Just a guess.
- bep 16y agoMaybe because the Mainstream Support End Date for Vista is 4/10/2012
- jameskilton 16y agoAwesome. This means, if we extrapolate[1], that IE11 won't run on Windows 7! [1] http://xkcd.com/605/ http://xkcd.com/605/
- d0m 16y agoYeah, It's so annoying. I need to test on IE9 but I've only got xP..
- KeyBoardG 16y agoGet a VM with it.
- WiseWeasel 16y agoWell that's a disappointment. Since Vista and 7 share so much of the same architecture, I'd be inclined to believe this decision is completely political, which reflects poorly on Microsoft's leadership. This is hardly helping Microsoft to stay competitive with Firefox and Chrome, and it needlessly makes Vista a sub-par web development platform.
- andrewf 16y agoMakes sense given that a year from now, MS won't be supporting Vista at all (eg with security updates) if you don't have some enterprise-y extended support contract. http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/products/lifecycle#section_2 http://windows.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/products/lifecycl...
- icey 16y agoI feel like Microsoft should have branded IE10 as a completely new piece of software and not as the newest Internet Explorer. Then it would have become a feature of Windows 7 instead of just another browser. It would have also given them the chance to try some new things without feeling like they had to keep any kind of IE legacy. Yes, they would have had to support 2 different browsers for a time, but they have the resources to do that. They could have taken the opportunity to compete more aggressively with a lighter weight browser. Microsoft is full of brilliant people, if they were given a mission that said "Make an HTML5 browser, give it the fastest, most rock-solid JS interpreter you can, and oh yeah, include the DLR by default" that they could probably deliver something pretty interesting without having to deal with the IE legacy.
- billswift 16y agoConsidering the differences between some versions of IE, they effectively end up supporting more than two different browsers at a time anyway.
- icey 16y agoYeah, you're totally right. I probably should have said that they would have to maintain two separate teams working on browsers; but I imagine they do that as well given the number of people that work on browser teams.
- atacrawl 16y agoI feel like Microsoft should have branded IE10 as a completely new piece of software and not as the newest Internet Explorer. I totally disagree with this. You have to remember that a sizable portion of computer users don't really understand what a browser is. To these people, IE = internet. So for Microsoft to remove that kind of brand equity just wouldn't make sense.
- icey 16y agoWouldn't they be able to resolve that by packaging their new browser as the default in Windows 8? They could even call it the "Microsoft Bing! browser"
- Rodek 16y agoYou have to consider several things that probably went into this decision: 1. Small and declining user base for Vista means it becomes less important for Microsoft to target those users. In fact Windows 7 already has twice the market share that Vista does and it's still growing rapidly. http://gs.statcounter.com/#os-ww-monthly-201003-201103 http://gs.statcounter.com/#os-ww-monthly-201003-201103 2. If you project what some likely release window for IE10 and the next version of Windows will be (Win8) Microsoft is positioning itself to only have to support two operating systems. The cost of investment into a 3rd OS, especially one with small and declining market share (relative to it's other OSs), could just be too costly.
- mxavier 16y agoI bet the people who spent good money on a Windows Vista license are feeling really good about Microsoft right now.
- gscott 16y agoThere were few people dumb enough to buy it but plenty who were stuck with it as a default install that didn't want to then shell out $150 for Windows 7 so soon.
- dhimes 16y agoMS even wanted about that much for me to upgrade to a version of Vista that supported the 64 bit chip that came with the machine on which they had put Vista. That machine became a dual-boot with Fedora and I was on the road to Linux-land.
- blhack 16y agoWhy does microsoft still spend money building a web browser? I understood this in the 1990s because it locked people to windows, it was a feature, and hopefully it sold MSN subscriptions. But it's not the 1990s anymore. Let google spend their money on this, or let mozilla spend their money on this. Is there any reason microsoft doesn't bundle firefox with their operating system, and just EOL Internet Explorer? /admitting ignorance here
- icey 16y agoThere are still mountains of money available on the web. Since Microsoft controls the OS, they can ship a browser with defaults set to sites under their control, like msn.com and bing. My assumption is that they consider those properties as revenue (or potential revenue) sources.
- heyitsnick 16y agoHypothetically speaking, they couldn't ship windows OS with firefox preloaded with these same defaults?
- icey 16y agoI'm not sure. I know Google spends a ton of money paying to be the default search engine in Firefox. No idea what would happen if Microsoft tried to do the same thing on its own with their own defaults. I'd guess it would be kind of a PR nightmare for them though. Nobody questions those defaults when the browser is owned by Microsoft.
- idonthack 16y agoThey're still following the policy of "embrace, extend, extinguish"; the browser market just got away from them for a bit. Once they ship a browser good enough to shove out the other players with a bit of extra leverage from their desktop near-monopoly, it will become more obvious. It's already beginning to happen. For example: http://www.winrumors.com/bing-powered-u-s-searches-rise-to-over-30-market-share/ http://www.winrumors.com/bing-powered-u-s-searches-rise-to-o...
- GrandMasterBirt 16y agoLooks like MS is pushing hard for "upgrade to our latest os or DIE"... It's ok, their office will support windows 2k if it has to because its the big money maker. And people will leave IE behind soon enough.
- tobylane 16y agoIE10 not being supported by Vista is like how things weren't supported by 2000/ME but were supported by XP. Vista is like 2k, low quality and often skipped over.
- briancray 16y agoLOL. Nuff' said.
- random42 16y agoI believe this is an artifact of http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/APIWar.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/APIWar.html On the other-hand, MS is under the pressure, like never before to prove itself on the web, and few hard-choices need to be made for it o be nimble.
- yuhong 16y agoOn that article, the funny thing is that Mac OS X is changing their APIs faster nowadays.
- nabaraj 16y agoSo Microsoft wants to support only Windows 7 and IE10. I downloaded the beta and didnot see any difference with IE9.