3 ms·
I get it but I don’t understand it. Can you imagine: on the one hand post industrial countries are inhabited by a bunch or multi centenarians, on the other han
by mc32 6y ago
I get it but I don’t understand it.
Can you imagine: on the one hand post industrial countries are inhabited by a bunch or multi centenarians, on the other hand poor countries are overpopulated by youngsters.
In the post industrial countries their minuscule pool of young people have no chance to dislodge entrenched old people who have the power.
There is less rejuvenation and less change in these multi centenarian societies and they become calcified, ossified. Old buggers hanging on for what? Will their minds be plastic? Sure, I don’t always agree with my young self or today’s young on all things, but I believe they should have the opportunity to shape their society in their time without obstructionist old timers.
- kinghtown 6y agoGood news is that those youngsters will have plenty of time to plot and wait with their extreme lifespans. People change. Life is change. Why would a longer life span be even more extremely boring and unchanging. I’m not convinced. It’s a big galaxy. Bad news: we probably won’t be getting extreme lifespan anyways. It’s very political.
- mc32 6y agoYoungsters are not typically known for patience with adults (witness progs vs liberals). I think it would be very socially destabilizing.
- teorema 6y agoIt's kind of a false dilemma? Old persons who don't change versus young ones who do? Could be ageist, not to mention neglecting the real issue of experience. I agree with the "room for new people" conundrum but you could approach that as a population control issue from a couple of different directions. Or you could approach lifespan extension simultaneously with research on its consequences, like how to structure society (economics, politics, etc) so as to optimize well-being.
- mc32 6y agoWith longer time spans compared to regular folks who don’t have the multicentennarian means, these people would accumulate more wealth and more power and would distort power imbalance even further (think the disparaging “boomer” remark but make it “multi cent”.
- godelski 6y agoWell the good news is that historically we've been more progressive than it takes for people to die. It is still a slow process, but it is clear that cultural change isn't happening because old people die and young people with new ideas replace them.
- Barrin92 6y agoI don't think that's so clear because historically we've never been in a situation where the average age of the population moves towards 40-50, or already is there in some countries. The median age in the US in 1900 was 23. If the oldest members of the population constitute a majority, and you're living in a democracy, cultural change is pretty hard to achieve. Here in Germany, where we have one of the oldest populations on the planet, politics consists essentially of one issue, social services and pensions.
- godelski 6y agoAt least here in America it seems like culture has shifted very quickly. The last 5 years, 10 years, 20 years, 50 years. I can't speak much for German culture, but I can say with high certainty that German culture is extremely different than 30 years ago. Yes, there's similarities, but things have changed quite a bit.
- fuzzfactor 6y agoOne of the reasons power structures can be so commonly screwed up is that they are usually inherited in some way or another from a time before anybody living was even born. Young and old, so that's like a century right there, and some things can get out-of-date a lot faster than that. That's what makes it such a long-term problem. The equivalent in a corporate culture is a structure inherited from a time before any current employees were there. Either way you can end up with some misguided systems which are not relevant enough for a modern situation, and it can be very painful to correct. >Can you imagine: on the one hand post industrial countries are inhabited by a bunch or multi centenarians, on the other hand poor countries are overpopulated by youngsters. Since World War 2 this has been the trend, not people living that much longer, but average & median ages diverging widely. American, German, British, Japanese, Russian, Italian WW2 participants are finally almost completely gone. Their descendants of these participants as a group skew older than the general populations which are trending less youthful than developing countries overall. Remember these entire countries (their population at the time) participated, not just the warfighters, that's one reason they call it a World War. So these older-populated countries still have a significant cohort whose fathers & grandfathers were the participants in WW2, and the legacy of the devastation was not forgotten by as many generations since then compared to developing countries. Some of whom had much smaller percentages of WW2 participants to begin with, and now it's largely their great-grandfathers & great-great-grandfathers. Seems to me those are the ones most likely to start WW3. In recent decades some have known more intense fighting than there actually was in their location during WW2 anyway. >In the post industrial countries their minuscule pool of young people have no chance to dislodge entrenched old people who have the power. It could be worse, you could have a teenage monarch, then you'd have to wait a really long time before you could expect a royal change. >they should have the opportunity to shape their society in their time without obstructionist old timers. This is so important to youthful accomplishment, the sooner people can have a society more suitable for its time, the better off everyone would be. Especially young people with a long future ahead of them, it's amazing what you can accomplish in a few short decades if you start early. Fortunately not all old timers are obstructionist, but it does tend to be a technique for seeking & holding on to undue legacy power, and they're the ones with the most time for consolidation.