8 ms·
So, as a UNIX hacker, here's what I don't get about the iOS community. There is way too much excitement over the simplest things ever. Let's break down some o
by jrockway 16y ago
So, as a UNIX hacker, here's what I don't get about the iOS community. There is way too much excitement over the simplest things ever. Let's break down some of the copy for this app:
Prompt is a clean, crisp, and cheerful SSH client
What does that mean? What does a clean ssh client do; not commit any protocol violations? What is crisp? When you bite into it, it's like a ripe apple? What does cheerful mean? Is the ssh client really happy that it can make a TCP connection to the intarwebs, especially for me?
What does this sentence mean to someone that wants to ssh from their phone?
it helps you when you need it, and stays out of your way when you don’t
So when I want to be sshing, I can run it, and when I don't want to be sshing, I don't have to run it? Splendid. It works like every other computer program ever made.
Perfect for system administrators, web developers, movie-style hackers (“Let me just TCP/IP into the UNIX port!”), or any person who needs to connect remotely and type some magic.
So I googled for "ssh client", found your page, and you're telling me who uses ssh clients. How would you get to this page without knowing what ssh is, and how would you know what ssh is without needing to use it?
Anyway, a lot of happy-sounding words for ... a program that decrypts text from the Internet and writes it to the screen.
- ojilles 16y agoRight, it's called marketing. And it tries to describe what the authors were aiming for. F.ex. //it helps you when you need it, and stays out of your way when you don’t// I read as "We don't use UI chrome that's distracting, only showing those things that you need contextually".
- Maascamp 16y agoIt seems just like ConnectBot for Android, except it costs $5.
- cschmidt 16y agoI think your comment highlights a difference between the Android and iOS communities. Android users just want free software, while iOS users don't mind paying for quality. Guess which platform ends up with the slickest software, with the most spit and polish. Developers find paying customers on iOS, so that's where the develop.
- gregory80 16y ago> Android users just want free software, while iOS users don't mind paying for quality. that seems like a gross generalization. Having had and used both android and iOS I never saw that behavior in myself or others. I have to agree with OP, i don't understand the excitement over this SSH client, interface included. A shell prompt is one of the oldest interfaces. iOS can support 3D graphics rendering and gaming and panic is selling a $5 SSH prompt. Seems bizarre.
- cschmidt 16y agoSure, maybe I'm over generalizing. However, I keep reading stories about how it is hard to make money in Android, like this one.... Doom Creator Says Android Not Profitable http://www.mobiledia.com/news/87020.html http://www.mobiledia.com/news/87020.html
- dcope 16y agoThe excitement is not just over "an SSH client". Knowing that Panic engineered and designed it is a huge selling point. They've been known for years to make some of the best software for OS X. This is their first venture into iOS and they don't disappoint. I will (and actually did) gladly pay $5 for software that is designed well and works very well.
- ugh 16y agoThere is next to no software I can think of where a $5 price point would be bizarre. How can a $5 SSH client even begin to be bizarre?
- Udo 16y agoBeing able to ssh into a server while on the road with nothing more than an iPad is a feature that has value to some people (like me, for example). For an app that is really useful, the difference between $5 and free is negligible. I just paid more for my coffee than I did for Prompt, and I didn't think about that twice either.
- jarek 16y ago
- jmathai 16y agoI love ConnectBot. Is there a way to hit CTRL + arrows?
- WiseWeasel 16y agoYes, the Prompt keyboard features both a ctrl toggle and arrow keys. Screen shots here: http://www.panic.com/blog/2011/04/introducing-prompt-ssh-for-ios/ http://www.panic.com/blog/2011/04/introducing-prompt-ssh-for... and here: http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/prompt/id421507115?mt=8 http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/prompt/id421507115?mt=8
- Cushman 16y agoThey're talking about the interface, dude. Making a pretty, usable terminal for iOS is non-trivial, that's what they're selling.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- mpiche 16y ago"So I googled for "ssh client", found your page, and you're telling me who uses ssh clients. How would you get to this page without knowing what ssh is, and how would you know what ssh is without needing to use it?" There are many ways to arrive on that page that do not involve googling for "ssh client". It's a blog for a software company, but there are other topics on that blog that don't have anything to do with software (like food, retro games, and design). Anyone can read it, not just the geeks who know what SSH is. Point being: Why obscure what the app does to people who are less familiar with terminals or SSH? I don't see any fault in trying to educate others about the app by giving non-technical readers concrete answers of who would most likely use it.
- ugh 16y agoMaking a good SSH client for touchscreen devices is hard. Touchscreen devices have limited screen real estate and non-standard (read: limited) keyboards. As to the language: Clean and crisp say both pretty much the same thing in that sentence, crisp is only along for the alliteration (as is cheerful). My Latin teacher would be delighted. It's marketing, but it also makes sense. Not all apps are created equal, even if they all do the same simple thing, especially on touchscreen devices. It's more about selling you the keyboard (a suitable keyboard for SSH clients doesn't come standard with touchscreen devices) than about selling you the client. Oh, and why do they include a description of the target group? Maybe because some people read the Panic blog without knowing what the hell SSH is? Those Panic guys are are pretty well known.
- pluies 16y ago> As to the language: Clean and crisp say both pretty much the same thing in that sentence, crisp is only along for the alliteration (as is cheerful). My Latin teacher would be delighted. Technically, an alliteration is based on the sound. So while "clean", "crisp" and "client" are an alliteration (beginning with the [k] sound), cheerful (beginning with [tʃ]) isn't part of it.
- ugh 16y agoMy Latin teacher would not be disappointed by my failure because she knows that I have never been all that interested or good at that stuff ;)
- rflrob 16y ago> It's more about selling you the keyboard (a suitable keyboard for SSH clients doesn't come standard with touchscreen devices) than about selling you the client. If that's the case, why not mention it a bit more in the post? I agree that a good keyboard layout is important, but the closest they come is saying "customizable special keys". I like iSSH's ability to do a semi-transparent overlay keyboard to maximize screen real estate. Can prompt do this as well?
- 16y ago
- jcsalterego 16y agoI would wager part of the excitement is that Panic is an excellent and long-standing company in the Apple community, and they've proven time and time again they can release quality, beautiful software. As the type of Mac user that has one foot in the console and one foot in the pretty GUI that is OS X, it's pretty great when someone can bridge that gap -- be it a kickass Terminal like iTerm2, or what I can only expect is an excellent app from Panic, Prompt. Skip the marketing (still good copy to read), find some way to use the app and judge Panic that way.
- bxr 16y ago>Anyway, a lot of happy-sounding words for [...] I agree. I use ssh somewhere around 10 hours per weekday, have used a bunch of different clients, and really have no idea what sets this application apart from any other ssh client other than a bunch of vague adjectives. If they can't manage to set the product apart, at all, why am I going to give it a look? I know some of the other comments here excuse that by saying its marketing, or that these words are to describe the interface. Thats good and all, but if you're trying to sell me an ssh client, its OK (hell, almost mandatory) to assume you're talking to a slightly technical audience. Show us the nitty gritty that will make me _want_ to pick this application over any other. As much as I clicked around, I couldn't find anything.
- rimantas 16y agoassume you're talking to a slightly technical audience Some, even in technical audience have a taste for good UI.
- bxr 16y agoOk, and thanks for assuming from my post that I don't care about interface, but then show me _that_. All I see other than an generic iOS interface is a keyboard with a few convenience keys. Is that it?
- leon_ 16y agoYep, that's all. But hey, it's iOS where you can - given enough hype and marketing - make everything sell well. I wouldn't dream of installing a SSH client on my iPad - simply because the keyboard has no physical feedback. I can't type on that thing. I guess there will be many people who will buy this app and still will be disappointed afterwards.
- GHFigs 16y agoIf they can't manage to set the product apart, at all, why am I going to give it a look? Because it's Panic, a company that has earned your attention by consistently delighting you. If that doesn't describe you, they probably aren't really trying to sell you an SSH client.
- statictype 16y agoWhat you're pointing out is a quality of the Mac community, which has a certain amount of overlap with the iOS community. In this particular case, the company - Panic - is a highly regarded indie Mac developer so the copy reads like how it would for Mac apps. Many Mac users geek out on user interfaces that are sparse and simple and uncluttered - this is the audience to which this SSH client is pandering so it's no surprise that they're marketing it that way. In reality, most typical iOS users (not the same as Mac users!) want something functional that gets the job done and don't really give a hoot about having the app 'get out of the way' or be 'crisp' (and the AppStore top seller lists would seem to indicate this), which, as you have mentioned seem to have little meaning for a Unix command line crypto/networking/admin tool.
- pnathan 16y agoBe that as it may, but, uh...... When I PuTTY into a Linux box or, on a linux box, type "ssh me@sweetbox", I don't see any clutter. It's pretty sparse and simple - just a brief prompt and a blinking cursor. I don't even know how it could become more than that... I think it speaks volumes about the progress of iOS apps (and iOS in general) towards being a usable computer that a SSH client is exciting.
- exogen 16y agoRight, because with PuTTY on your Linux box, you don't need a virtual keyboard on the screen. Most of the complexity is off-screen. Touch devices don't have that luxury. Now imagine PuTTY with a virtual keyboard built in and you start to see some clutter.
- jws 16y agoIt isn't the ssh protocol(mostly), it is the user interface. Mapping a physical keyboard and display onto a touchscreen/display involves tradeoffs. • The keyboard I am using right now is >50% larger than my entire iPad display. It won't fit even if I sacrifice the entire display to keyboard. • Will you overlay the keyboard on the character matrix? How do you know where to put it that you won't cover the part I'm trying to see? I generally want to see the bottom, that is pretty much worst case. • I need a control and escape key for command line editing, and I need a dozen symbols plus the digits to type normal unix commands. The keyboard is getting either pretty big, or multiplexed. When you use ssh on a unix machine, you are taking advantage of infrastructure that isn't there on the iPad, like the ability to scp your keys and favorite configuration file into a .ssh directory. • How bizarre is the sequence to get my encrypted private keys into my iPad? • How complicated are you going to make the preferences? Just the default ssh client config on Debian is showing 34 options and I've got ones that aren't in the list in my personal config file. What makes this unique to iOS? # aptitude search '?provides(x-terminal-emulator)' | wc -l 32 … really? I need to sort through 32 terminal emulators to use ssh on my Debian machine? Is that before or after I choose between the 44 window managers? And they all think they are pretty special. At least I only have 5 display managers to choose from. Nobody apologizes in their marketing copy for speciating.
- krakensden 16y ago> really? I need to sort through 32 terminal emulators to use ssh on my Debian machine? Really? Unless you installed debian-minimal, and installed the gui piecemeal from there, your system came with a terminal emulator (gnome-terminal or kterm) in a nice menu, which will work perfectly as soon as you type 'ssh myserver.tld'. Besides, it's not like Prompt is the only terminal emulator/ssh client available on the app store. A quick google reveals there is also iSSH, TouchTerm, Terminal 426, and pTerm.
- jws 16y agoReally? – yes. Normally I go with the defaults, but on my netbook for linux work on the road I didn't want to lose a lot of screen real estate to menu bars and window ornaments. Honestly I was only using X because the dark blue on black text in some emacs coloration was illegible, but fixing the console to get dark blue far enough off of black to be legible eluded me. I nearly got there with 'slim' and 'awesome' and one of the terminal emulators, but then when I needed to pop up gimp for the odd image fix it was unusable. (tiled window manager meets the legion of floating windows with strange ideas about window manager hinting.) I hate to say it, but it wore me down. I relegated the netbook to machine room console duty, bought a lighter main laptop, and just use VirtualBox to run my portable linux machine. My laptop load is 50% lighter, and the virtual linux box is faster than the netbook anyway. A much better solution. (and dark blue on black is legible on this machine).
- guygurari 16y agoWhat does a clean ssh client do; not commit any protocol violations? Anyway, a lot of happy-sounding words for ... a program that decrypts text from the Internet and writes it to the screen. You're focusing on features. They're talking about design. How do you type ctrl-c? How do you type the arrow keys? Any client must support these features. The differentiator is the design -- how easy they are to use, how nice they look, etc.
- spitfire 16y agoEverything in the ios/webapp field has to be the fun! and easy! way to do whatever. "colontast.ic is the fun and easy and social new way to do colonoscopies!" Picture that page with sky blue background, happy cartoon characters and rounded buttons (3 easy steps!). It wears me right out. Like those cheap painted "sale!' signs at car dealerships.
- jodrellblank 16y agoI know you're trying for comedy, but I prefer the fun and easy way to X than the confusing and miserable way - which is how many programs are by default.
- danilocampos 16y ago> There is way too much excitement over the simplest things ever. Simple things done well are among the most delightful discoveries I can make in my human existence. Have you ever had a perfect omelet? I mean, perfect? Fluffy, nice balance of tasty fillings, not overdone? I have. Maybe twice. Each time, it was wonderful. Wonderful for the fact that with just five ingredients, it created subtle, delicious flavors and enjoyable textures. Wonderful for the discipline and focus necessary not to overcomplicate it with unneeded flourish. It's so simple, compared to some of the more elaborate meals I've eaten. And that's what made it so special. Another parallel is tools. Have you ever hefted a really nice kitchen knife? Maybe one of those numbers where the blade and the shank are forged from a single piece of metal? Everything just swoops and melts together, and the blade feels like a comfortable extension of your arm. Just the right weight, perfect leverage, a tool that was agonized over by a craftsman desperate to make the best. Simple, relative to a Swiss Army knife? Absolutely. And that's where its power comes from. iOS has some things about it that reward simplicity and focus. It's really easy to make an overwrought, complex app on any platform, and iOS is no exception. With a lot of care and attention to detail, though, you can make something that's simple, not distracting, made from the barest components necessary and extremely good at solving a very specific problem with minimum fuss. When that happens, it's so nice to see. *nix rewards people who build their own stuff, which is fine, but the tradeoff in this is craftsmanship. It's easy enough to get system tools to the level of "good enough for you" without ever reaching good enough for everyone. That, I suspect, is the cultural difference you've detected here.
- THRAWASAD 16y agoHave you ever read an idiotic comment? It starts with some stupid explanation about a perfect omelet, while conveniently forgetting that an Omelet is just some crap that we eat to get nutrition, so that we can get more important things done.
- cparedes 16y agoWait, what? ssh is simple. I suspect that the typical person needing to SSH into a box is already someone who knows how to operate in UNIX. Otherwise, you're using the wrong protocol.
- r618 16y agoyou remind me recent 'Oprah trolled' meme :)
- SpaceAcer 16y agoThat's some good trolling there. Here's an idea: take your ignorance and go read a book, stop posting comments on the internet.
- rhygar 16y agoInsufferable much?
- jodrellblank 16y agoThat's not you speaking as a UNIX hacker, that's you speaking as a someone who takes a permanently miserable attitude on almost everything. How dare they describe such a holy item as an SSH client without a list of which protocol weaknesses it has taken into account! SSH isn't cheery, this is serious business! UNIX IS NOT A TOY! Harumph! Etc.