4 ms·
Yes, it did work: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22466733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22466733 Cambridge Analytica were the tip of the iceberg
by fsflover 6y ago
Yes, it did work:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22466733 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22466733
Cambridge Analytica were the tip of the iceberg (graphcommons.com)
- specialist 6y agoThanks, I somehow missed this, will read shortly. Meanwhile, one aspect of the 2016 presidential coverage that drives me nuts is the omission that HRC's voter file was stolen and likely used by GOP, Trump, Russia. Meaning they knew exactly who to target. A campaign's voter file is it's Crown Jewels, it's secret sauce. It is the campaign. HRC knew they had a problem in MN, WI, PA. They just couldn't figure out what was going on in time. Plus a zillion other things going on. Again, will read your link soonest. It might help me fill in a few more of the puzzle pieces.
- xienze 6y ago> HRC knew they had a problem in MN, WI, PA. They just couldn't figure out what was going on in time. Yeah, the problem is that they took those states (and it’s MI not MN) for granted as safe blue states (which they had been for decades) and bought into the “Hillary is so far ahead in the polls she doesn’t even think about Trump anymore”[0] hype that they didn’t see the need to campaign there. 0: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/10/23/hillary-clinton-so-far-ahead-in-polls-that-doesnt-even-think-abo/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/10/23/hillary-clinton-...
- specialist 6y agoThat's among the least of my criticisms. But it's easy to criticize. One unintuitive thing I wish was more easily explained: Any given move to gain votes will lose other votes. It's a wicked hard optimization problem.
- macspoofing 6y agoThis doesn't show it worked. It shows that CA is connected to other similar companies either through a direct relationship or a tortured, barely tenuous connection (the slide on how some employees went to work for other companies in the same space is silly). Regardless, at no point does it attempt to even show that anything that CA did made one lick of a difference or that anything they did was even unprecedented in the space. For example, I don't believe for a second that Democratic campaigns haven't been using similar social media aggregation techniques in present and past elections. I even remember glowing articles written about how the Obama campaign was able to harness social media for purposes of political targeting and messaging. So what are we talking about here? And the entire thing is even more ridiculous in the larger context of how incompetent and disorganized the Trump 2016 campaign was.
- specialist 6y agoOkay. I quickly scanned the linked graphcommons presentation (?). Instead of responding to that directly, I'll share the thesis I've been chewing for a while. I worked on election integrity stuff for about a decade. Opposing the touchscreens, tabulators, and other blackboxes. Advocating for better administration. That kind of stuff. Like with all learning, my understanding of the problem dramatically changed over time. The biggest threat to election integrity is change. With great reluctance I came to the view that any future changes had to be slow-rolled, even the phase out of the touchscreens. Think of it as how first responders stabilize the patient before transporting that patient. The second biggest threat is noise. It's the asymmetry of bullshit principle. It's just so fucking hard to figure out what's going on. We spend all our time chasing wild gooses. So much slips past our attentions. Only then can I think of the actually machinery of democracy. Stuff like form of elections, procedures, transparency, etc. This frame and my own campaign work (stumping, GOTV, etc) informs how I regard CA and others. The biggest threat CA poses is Steve Bannon's "flood the zone" with bullshit strategy. With so much activity below the radar, it's impossible to talk rationally about this stuff. Because there's always more to the story. Which is the trap, the exact purpose of Bannon's strategy. The skeptics say CA, social media, etc. didn't effect voter behavior, specifically costing HRC the election. That's entirely besides the point. Other factors absolutely moved voters. We could stack rank them. Comey's betrayal is probably the biggest. My two personal faves are HRC's reliance on negative partisanship (too many attack ads), and HRC's desperate need to tangle with corporate media (instead of just creating HillaryTV and speaking directly to voters like Trump did with Twitter). But there are many fights in the margins that most commentators completely ignore or outright dismiss. What we election integrity people called "death by a thousand cuts." It's never just one thing that makes the difference. That's too obvious and will eventually be corrected. Rather it's the cumulative damage of 1,000s of small attacks. Asymmetric war fare. By keeping the contest "close", it becomes possible for the jitter (noise) to make the difference, depending on timing of the snapshot (when you measure). And now we get to what CA and others did. Buried in all the noise, they used HRC's stolen voter file to precisely target and overwhelm "undecided" and low motivation voters. Maybe 500,000 voters in total. Tiny percentage of the electorate. And Trump got lucky. It was just barely enough. Smaller in impact than say Jill Stein's spoiler. But on top of every thing else, it made the difference. ("Undecided" in quotes, because that's another topic onto itself.)