3 ms·
Trivial searches yield trivial results. That [1] really only examines ratios of osmium to platinum-group elements is telling. At only one place in the paper do
by ncmncm 6y ago
Trivial searches yield trivial results.
That [1] really only examines ratios of osmium to platinum-group elements is telling. At only one place in the paper do they admit that the osmium/osmium isotope ratios found in their samples, from the one cave, do, in fact, match a known bolide. They very carefully avoid addressing the extreme Pt abundances found in the YDB layer at dozens of sites. This is akin to others complaining that iridium abundance at the strata is not especially elevated, without addressing platinum, which lacks other explanation.
"Lack of clear consensus" cited in the paper is revealed to mean that certain individuals, like them, have disagreed, without addressing faulty details. Such individuals have made claims that spherules identified as carbon are spores, without having examined any of them, or that they are not present at all, but which turn out to refer to layers that do not coincide with the YDB.
The European volcanic eruption mentioned is known to have occurred some centuries before the YDB.
You can't refute results from dozens of sites with equivocal results from a single site.