5 ms·
Algorithms are changing what we read online
- jseliger 6y agoI saw this essay in Arts and Letters Daily (https://www.aldaily.com/ https://www.aldaily.com/) and added it to my blog's next links post, with a variation of this comment: I've never heard of this guy and yet his work sounds like just the sort of thing I'd like to read: I'm not interested in most of the standard political and pop culture stuff that's endlessly written and re-written. Unfortunately, he doesn't seem to have a link list of his recent works anywhere, at least that I can find. His website (https://russellsmith.ca/ https://russellsmith.ca/) appears to be pretty generic, and its RSS feed seems to have last been updated in 2015. How are we supposed to find his work and follow him, if we are interested in his work (and I am, after reading this)?
- motohagiography 6y agoCan recommend highly, particularly his books, "Confidence" and "How Insensitive." I read his column in the Globe for years. When you compare what he writes to the content that gets pushed to us like in that Social Dilemma documentary in another thread (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24468533 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24468533), smart people are writing, they're just getting drowned out. Content algorithms are like rating food on how efficiently it can deliver sugar and caffeine with no other criteria for "good."
- samizdis 6y agoYou can get quite a bit of his stuff here: https://muckrack.com/russell-smith/articles https://muckrack.com/russell-smith/articles
- rtx 6y agoAs a consumer, I enjoy and pay for human curated content. Maybe publishers just need to ride out the analytic craze.
- mellosouls 6y agoThis article rings true to me. In particular I've noticed a steady stream of woke articles being pushed my way despite me having little interest in that sort of thing. These things are supposed to be fed by our preferences, but while I'm happy to read across the board brow-wise, most of my reading is of the deeper articles and yet genuinely intellectual essays are rarely offered up. It's frustrating as a reader, and interesting to hear about it from the view of the writer.
- AlexandrB 6y agoI know what you mean. After all the tracking data collected and ML models trained the primary metric for suggesting content still seems to be "stuff other people are reading/watching/playing/listening"
- jacobr1 6y agoAs someone that used to work on recommendations systems ... the problem is that the signal is just so robust. Stuff other people like really is one of the stronger ways to predict what you will like. Most additional data sources that allow us to customize further and identify what sub-groups you might belong to and thus prioritize highlighting things of relevance to your subgroups tend to empirically show lower performance for the overall population. The only thing I've seen work is focus on the "most popular" things for the most important demographics (such as those with money to buy things) which might overfit for that demo, and underperform overall, but still performs the best on some higher metric like revenue. I commented a while back on someone asking "Why recommend me a ladder if I just bought a ladder, couldn't the system understand that people usually only buy one ladder?" But the fact is, the commenter was wrong about his priors. Actually someone who buys a ladder is indeed more likely to buy another one ... even if most people that buy ladders only buy a single ladder. The fact that you bought a ladder, puts you in the cohort of people that buys ladders, which means you are more likely to buy another one than someone who isn't on the record buying a ladder.
- techbio 6y agoI'm sure the poster you're replying to knows this and wishes it weren't so.
- octodog 6y agoI quite enjoyed this article and found the author's perspective on the inherent internationalism of art resonate with me. However, I'm not sure that the issue he is discussing is mostly caused by algorithms. It seems to me that the internationalisation of newspapers and media organisations is the main culprit. As the author says, if you can read art reviews in the NYT, why bother with 'small time' critics? Personally, I share the author's view that having a local perspective is still valuable but it seems clear that a lot of people don't.
- carabiner 6y agoThe algorithms are motivated by ad impressions. Solution: seek out newspapers that are funded by subscriptions, not ads, the ones with stiffest paywalls. These would be Financial Times and WSJ. Chomsky called the FT "the only newspaper that tells the truth" because the readership and authors are aligned in their goal to make money from the news.
- zepearl 6y agoI personally never read articles of FT nor WSJ - I don't even try to "click" on those links/references as I know that I won't be able to read them => I'll never have any chance to "understand" if I would like to subscribe to those newspapers :(
- swiley 6y agoWSJ has ads doesn’t it?
- searchableguy 6y agoThere are some free ones. Try their wirecard reporting. I find it pretty interesting. Wirecard and me: Dan McCrum on exposing a criminal enterprise: https://www.ft.com/content/745e34a1-0ca7-432c-b062-950c20e41f03 https://www.ft.com/content/745e34a1-0ca7-432c-b062-950c20e41...
- zepearl 6y agoThank you - but the ones that a freely available aren't marked in the headlines (e.g. "free"), or am I overlooking something?
- samizdis 6y agoQuite a few FT articles are free to read, and many others paywalled on the site are often syndicated to other, non-paywalled sites. A DDG search on the headline will often return such results. (I try, when submitting an FT article, to find a syndicated version as well and to post a link to it in comments immediately after submitting.) Alternatively, and depending on your views about copyright etc, you can submit the article's url to archive.is - which will either return anything already "archived", or try to fetch it for you.
- clircle 6y agoNope. been using Google Reader and NewsBlur for 15 years to avoid this foolery.
- swiley 6y agoReading curated feeds WILL expose you to mass manipulation engines. The power they steal from you and others can then be rented out in bulk for a premium. That’s why most companies don’t let you turn them off (or make it difficult to opt out.)
- MichaelMoser123 6y agoMost of the newspapers in Germany have half of their articles as 'premium content', and these cost some money. I wonder if they focus on the same metrics with this model. (I mean if the newspaper has a revenue model that is not primarily based on ads then its metrics might be of a different kind)
- mjburgess 6y agoIn the case where an article causes you to subscribe, the topic area can be sustained by a smaller audience. Eg., this is how netflix maintains a large library of niche films. It is enough just that they profit on them, not that they are popular. The issue in OP appears to be that his articles were always included with the printed newspaper, and some people were curious enough to read it. However those people would never think to seek out that content. So it's a question of "how do you serve the intellectual curiosity" in an era where mere popularity is the main recommendation system? I don't think it's as big of a problem as he seems to think, only, that newspapers now have no answer to it. Many institutions for the intellectually curious (newspapers, universities, etc.) don't serve that function anymore.
- MichaelMoser123 6y agoFor discovery there are specialized reddits and there is still https://www.aldaily.com/ https://www.aldaily.com/ also twitter is good for that
- dorchadas 6y agoAny good recommendations on some of those specialized reddits?
- dangus 6y agoUltimately I think what this author is describing is actually more of a tale of one employer‘s crummy management style. Interesting niche content like the author writes is exploding. In contrast, it sounds to me like this particular outlet is missing out on the opportunity to provide niche and offbeat content by bean counting. In other words, I’d hesitate to assume that all digital media outlets are blindly chasing “engagement” without making any other considerations. I would think that big legacy media companies are easily led off a cliff by “doing what everyone else is doing.” We are in the infancy of digital media, as much as it seems like it’s been around for a long time at this point. Many outlets, especially traditional ones, are ultimately still doing “the wrong things” that digital media firms in 2050 will look back on as being primitive and crude. One last point: while the “flip through the pages of the paper and discover odd topics on art and culture” is dead, that doesn’t mean the interest and readership is dead. What’s dead is the idea that institutions like The Times or The Globe have any relevance in acting as aggregators of that content.
- WalterBright 6y agoOne thing a news recommender app could do is randomly insert a reference to an article that is not based on popularity. Sort of "giving it a chance" like a radio DJ used to do to introduce new music from an unknown artist.