4 ms·
Having doubt is the default position in science. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. It’s an interesting finding, but it’s prudent to remain s
by orev 6y ago
Having doubt is the default position in science. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
It’s an interesting finding, but it’s prudent to remain skeptical.
- aquova 6y agoI agree in principle, but the statement "there is doubt about the quality of the radio detection" implies that there have been concrete issues pointed out about the basis of these findings, which I haven't heard anywhere else.
- willis936 6y agoIn fairness, it is too early to have a thorough review. The press conference and paper are less than an hour old. Be wary of anyone making bold claims right now, author or armchair scientist.