4 ms·
About 4-5 years ago, my MacBook Pro's trackpad would randomly stop working and I would have to restart my laptop a few times to get it working again. Sometimes
by nvrspyx 6y ago
About 4-5 years ago, my MacBook Pro's trackpad would randomly stop working and I would have to restart my laptop a few times to get it working again. Sometimes it would work for a few hours, sometimes a few minutes. I also dual-booted Linux at the time and the funny thing is the trackpad never had an issue under Linux. After quite a bit of researching, it led me to believe that the ribbon cable connecting the trackpad to the motherboard was faulty due to macOS never trying to reconnect to the trackpad if it loses a connection for even just a moment.
I brought it to the Apple store and explained that I had tried everything possible to resolve the issue without opening up the laptop myself, such as resetting NVRAM, completely reinstalling macOS completely, etc. I explained that I think that the ribbon cable is simply faulty and that it probably just needed a replacement. The Genius said that they're going to bring it in the back to do every single one of the things I mentioned that I already did.
I come back 4 hours later to pickup my laptop and they tell me that the issue is the motherboard and that replacing said board would cost $800. I asked how they determined it was the motherboard and not simply a faulty ribbon cable to the trackpad, but they wouldn't answer the question directly. After requesting their superior and restating my question a few more times, they told me that they don't have access to replacement ribbon cables and that my only option was a motherboard replacement, which itself would take about a week because they needed to order the board. That was enough for me to take my laptop and leave, even though they still didn't answer the actual question of how they determined what the actual issue was or even confirm my hunch that the issue was with the ribbon cable.
I bought a $5 replacement cable from Amazon, took about 10 minutes to swap it out using an iFixIt tutorial, and I'm still using that laptop as my main machine years later. In other words, they spent 4 hours to quote me an $800 fix that would take about a week to be done for something that was actually only a $5 fix that would take no more than 30 minutes. I've been hesitating to buy a new laptop for years because of that experience as well as the downhill quality of MacBooks as of late, such as the keyboard (although fixed now), touch bar, initial Catalina bugginess, etc.
- cooljacob204 6y agoYup, that was a common issue. This is exactly what happen to a friend of mine. Tried to sell him a new motherboard, he decided to just buy a ribbon cable and replace it himself. Another friend had his motherboard replaced because he had the common issue with the old keyboard where keys would randomly stop working. Of course it didn't fix it, only wasted a month of his time. Luckily his was still covered under warranty and they managed to get it right and replace the keyboard the second time around.
- userbinator 6y agoI believe Louis Rossmann had a video of something similar, where a loose/unseated display cable was quoted by Apple as a motherboard replacement.
- ntsplnkv2 6y ago> I explained that I think that the ribbon cable is simply faulty and that it probably just needed a replacement. The Genius said that they're going to bring it in the back to do every single one of the things I mentioned that I already did. People who are technical like you, or myself, and attempt to fix things, and often know more than techs, it's frustrating. But consider how many people come in that don't do those things, or don't do them but said they did, etc. Honestly, often times when a coworker of mine is checking an issue I'm having, the issue is a minor one that I somehow missed.
- wnissen 6y agoI had almost the same thing happen. Turned on my Mac Mini one day and it just could not see the SSD. Not even in Recovery mode. Took it in and the “Genius” tested it and said that the drive wasn’t working. They offered to replace my 1TB SSD for some large amount of money. I asked if they would sell me a replacement cable so I could see if it was the drive or the cable. Nope. Had to get it third-party, which cost next to nothing. And of course the only reason these cables fail is because they’re wafer thin and designed for laptops. When’s the last time you heard of a full-size hard drive cable failing? Never. If Apple would release a “real” desktop computer that was toaster sized instead of mini, this wouldn’t be an issue.