3 ms·
This is quite impressive, but it is also somewhat meaningless. I suppose I'd draw an analogy to a cake shop boasting that it had achieved net-no industrial acci
by roenxi 6y ago
This is quite impressive, but it is also somewhat meaningless. I suppose I'd draw an analogy to a cake shop boasting that it had achieved net-no industrial accidents over its existence - a great record, but also not really a particular stretch to achieve.
Carbon emissions aren't about servers. They are about, in order of priority:
* How do we feed people cheaply without fossil fuels (both as fertiliser & for crop transport)?
* How do we extract minerals cheaply (especially aluminium) without fossil fuels?
* How do we maintain the cheap logistics network that gets us stuff without fossil fuels?
The first two are non-negotiable, the 3rd is quite important. If those 3 problems were solved then fossil fuels would just go away quietly. Google isn't involved in any of those things; it is part of the 'these carbon emissions are incidental' category of emissions that we can reasonably get rid of.
But, again, good on them for setting clear goals and achieving them.
- taf2 6y agoNot sure it’s correct way to view the problem but in my mind if google could 1. Ensure all employees traveling to work had zero emissions 2. The production of energy to power their offices and servers produced zero emissions 3. The sourcing of materials to build and maintain the energy production produced zero emissions 4. The food required to feed the people working for them produced zero emissions I think 3 and 4 are going to be the hardest for the world to figure out 1 and 2 we have good solutions either solar/ hydro or mass transit or electric cars. But the supporting infrastructure that’s harder maybe?
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoAt Google at least there's some reasonable support for EV charging at work. The Mountain View office support for this is better than my own (Waterloo) where we have only 4 chargers for the entire office -- located indoors underground right in the office building making them competitive spaces that people use even though they don't need it. But the infrastructure in California is actually quite impressive, and they were early to the game on that. But better than making driving less CO2 intensive is to have people not drive at all.
- YetAnotherNick 6y agoYes, I agree that the title should be "Google data centers achieves zero carbon footprint", but still it is not zero effort to achieve it. I would imagine data centers to use non trivial power to run.
- MattGaiser 6y agohttps://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06610-y https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-06610-y
- hobofan 6y agoWondering if that also applies to Alphabet as a whole or only Google. I find it especially interesting due to everyone screaming "but muh CO2 footprint", every time big ML projects are announced by them (e.g. AlphaGo) that use enormous resources for training.
- onion2k 6y agoa cake shop boasting that it had achieved net-no industrial accidents over its existence I'm curious about how you offset an accident to get back down to net no accidents. Can you explain?
- stiray 6y agoVery well said. I wonder (actually I really dont - it is clear that it doesnt) if 0 emission include also creation of silicon resin, PCBs, wiring, electricity,... I am not saying it is nothing, but it is "a tad" spitting into the sea. The major footprint comes from heavy industry that is creating the materials so google can actually operate and if I would be sarcastic - they actually create a greater need for materials where its production produce large amount of emissions. I would even claim, that they would do far more if they would stop showing ads. The electricity footprint on world wide scale must be enormous. I can claim 0 emission for myself except from (sorry, I just had to say it :D), farting and breathing. But once I start to count in how my food was produced, how the goods I am using were produced etc. this is just not true. Anyway as a decades long vegetarian and strictly driven on public transport or bicycle I do my best here. This is just publicity stunt from google and it doesn't really mean anything. But looks like it worked. BBC cached it and is doing an article about it.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 6y ago> How do we feed people cheaply without fossil fuels (both as fertiliser & for crop transport)? Agriculture (even without fossil fuels) has a far greater impact on the environment than all fossil fuel use combined. Why the focus on fossil fuels for all your points?
- xdavidliu 6y ago> Agriculture (even without fossil fuels) has a far greater impact on the environment than all fossil fuel use combined Can I get a source for that claim? A quick Google gives me the following: > Globally, fossil fuel-based energy is responsible for about 60% of human greenhouse gas emissions, with deforestation at about 18%, and animal agriculture between 14% and 18% (estimates from the World Resources Institute, UN Food and Agriculture Organization, and Pitesky et al. 2009 https://www.skepticalscience.com/how-much-meat-contribute-to-gw.html https://www.skepticalscience.com/how-much-meat-contribute-to...
- SparkyMcUnicorn 6y agoHere's a full infographic with sources [0]. I did watch this documentary, and while I don't agree with some of the conclusions or outlook, it does serve up some facts I wouldn't have looked into had I not seen it. [0] https://www.cowspiracy.com/infographic https://www.cowspiracy.com/infographic
- philipkglass 6y agoCowspiracy's numbers on global warming are bull shit. That infographic attributes 51% of global greenhouse gas emissions to animal agriculture. The US EPA says that 24% of global emissions are attributable to all agriculture and land use changes as of 2010: https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emissions-data https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/global-greenhouse-gas-emiss... The IPCC's more recent accounting says 23% of global emissions are attributable to all agriculture and land use changes: https://www.ipcc.ch/2019/08/08/land-is-a-critical-resource_srccl/ https://www.ipcc.ch/2019/08/08/land-is-a-critical-resource_s... Here's a detailed critical review of Cowspiracy from the Union of Concerned Scientists: https://blog.ucsusa.org/doug-boucher/cowspiracy-movie-review https://blog.ucsusa.org/doug-boucher/cowspiracy-movie-review According to Cowspiracy, the major source of global warming pollution isn’t fossil fuels like coal, oil, and natural gas, as the world’s scientists are telling us. No, it’s animal agriculture—not just eating cows, but all other kinds of meat, and eggs and milk and fish too. So the principal solution to global warming isn’t renewable energy. It’s for everyone to become a vegan. Central to Cowspiracy’s conspiracy theory is the supposed “fact” that a 2009 study found that 51% of all greenhouse gases are produced by animal agriculture. A good deal of the movie is taken up with interviews with people from environmental organizations, such as the Rainforest Action Network, Oceana, and the Natural Resources Defense Council, who don’t seem to accept this “fact,” and therefore must be part of the conspiracy to cover it up. Greenpeace politely declined, twice, to be interviewed, proving that they’re part of the cowspiracy too. ...
- zaptheimpaler 6y agoGlobally, data centers account for 1-2% of the worlds total energy consumption. Any efficiency improvement in such a big piece of total energy consumption is very significant.