4 ms·
> Provide a rooted phone by default. Librem 5 is rooted. It's basically just a Desktop computer in the form-factor of a phone. > Add tools that let me see wh
by fsflover 6y ago
> Provide a rooted phone by default.
Librem 5 is rooted. It's basically just a Desktop computer in the form-factor of a phone.
> Add tools that let me see what my phone is doing behind the scenes.
Everything is open source. You have all the power to study what your phone is doing. Standard GNU/Linux tools should work.
> Give me option to turn-off some of the things I don't like
Everything is free software, you can change it as you like. Also, there is no analytics by default: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHcHi0TBFv4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yHcHi0TBFv4
> Help with planned obsolence by providing updates
Lifetime updates are promised. Even if the company dies, the community can support the phone, since it's FLOSS: https://wp.puri.sm/posts/librem-5-longevity-solving-the-problem-of-disposable-technology/ https://wp.puri.sm/posts/librem-5-longevity-solving-the-prob...
> Edit: one more thing, please add NFC. Going back to carrying boatload of cards again is not an option
Unfortunately, not in the first version. One step at a time.
- tpxl 6y ago>> Add tools that let me see what my phone is doing behind the scenes. >Everything is open source. You have all the power to study what your phone is doing. Standard GNU/Linux tools should work. Yes, for the base system, however for third-party stuff, it would still be nice to prevent the apps from phoning home and stuff.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fsflover 6y agoBut how do you already do it on GNU/Linux? You can do the same.
- tpxl 6y agoOf course you can, but is it obvious and user friendly?
- entropicdrifter 6y agoLinux phones are never going to be especially obvious or user friendly. To get those types of features you need a boatload of investment that the open source community can't hope to muster in any sort of reasonable timeframe. For now the choice is privacy vs user friendliness. Currently rooted/de-Googled Android provides one of the best compromises for the average privacy-minded power user, but maybe in a few more years these Linux phones will be mature enough to give Android more of a run for their money.
- zozbot234 6y ago> To get those types of features you need a boatload of investment that the open source community can't hope to muster in any sort of reasonable timeframe. The Linux desktop is an obvious counterexample. If the open source community can develop user-friendly desktop environments (GNOME, KDE Plasma, Xfce) they can surely develop user-friendly mobile stacks.
- brnt 6y ago> Everything is open source. You have all the power to study what your phone is doing. Standard GNU/Linux tools should work. The vastness of the just the changelogs makes that untenable. Understanding the changes to such a nontrivial stack is something experts will even struggle with. Certainly, open source code is a prerequisite to any trust, but just that isn't enough.
- fsflover 6y agoEveryone needs to check just one small thing of their choice. It would be enough for a good coverage.
- dathinab 6y ago> [..] It's basically just a Desktop computer in the form-factor of a phone. Which is what has me worried the most. The (common) security model of GNU/Linux is for today/2020 in my opinion pretty bad for desktops and totally unacceptable for phones. When I first heard about snap and flatpack I thought things are slowly heading in a better direction but it turns out that was a misconception. I haven't looked into how the libre phone does sandboxing but I don't have to much hopes to be honest.
- lelele 6y ago> The (common) security model of GNU/Linux is for today/2020 in my opinion pretty bad for desktops and totally unacceptable for phones. Would you please expand on this for desktops? or reference any kind of document? Thank you.
- Zak 6y agoI'm not the one you asked, but I think the underlying issue is that the Unix security model is built around the assumption that software shares the user's intent, and is treated as exactly as trusted as the user. Computers at the time tended to be multi-user, so the focus was on protecting users from other users. While there was a risk of overtly malicious software, preventing remote code execution attacks and teaching users not to run trojan horses was mostly sufficient (for Unix users; the broader population using Windows often installed malicious adware in the early 2000s). In a modern environment, software should not necessarily be trusted to act in accordance with the user's wishes or best interests, and there's often a financial incentive for software creators to do things users wouldn't want them to. In the early 2000s, the most visible issue was Windows software that displayed advertisements outside of the software, often not obviously connected to the software. It would often monitor the user's browsing habits and such, leading to the name "spyware". Spyware of that sort was universally considered malicious, but modern smartphone apps often send far more sensitive information, such as location and address books to their creators. Those provide a simple example of a situation the classic Unix security model doesn't address very well. I am the only user of my phone, and I obviously want to be able to read my address book and get my location from the GPS. I do not want the latest and greatest app for sharing pictures of my lunch to track my location to show me restaurant ads, and I only want it to know about people I have explicitly connected to within the app, not my whole address book. Android's security model addresses that to a degree, restricting some capabilities until the user explicitly allows them. Some of these, like filesystem access aren't handled very gracefully, and it's possible for an app to refuse to work until granted permissions it doesn't really need (this is against policy for inclusion in the Play store, but enforcement is imperfect, and software can be installed from other sources). One workaround seen in XPrivacy is to feed fake data to apps.