4 ms·
To those of you who haven't made a CPU before: CPU technology is more like a javascript framework than a natural resource. When someone says "block China from U
by phendrenad2 6y ago
To those of you who haven't made a CPU before: CPU technology is more like a javascript framework than a natural resource. When someone says "block China from US CPU ISAs" think "block China from US javascript frameworks". Then you'll have the appropriate sense of how silly it is.
- polymorph1sm 6y agoIf javascript frameworks is patented then yes, you can. For reference ARM big little scheduler is patented[1], you need to license from ARM if you use any of their big little design. RISC-V under BSD license might change this. [1] https://patents.google.com/patent/US9710309 https://patents.google.com/patent/US9710309
- dash2 6y agoIf push comes to shove, why would you expect China to respect a set of patents that strangle its economic growth?
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoBecause that would result in a more devastating response from the side that holds patents. If china stops respecting international trade laws and agreements, other nations will hurt china's interests in return. Given the scale of the things, the weak spots will be found inevitably.
- michaelt 6y agoJudging from China's policies towards Uighur Muslims and Hong Kong, I think China isn't very worried about foreign censure.
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoThere is a difference. Nobody in the first world really cares about Uighurs or Hong Kong. However, there are quite a handful of parties who do care about patents (and resulting profits).
- sangnoir 6y agoChina has been pilfering intellectual property from labs & private companies via APTs for the last couple of years: what are the handful of parties who care about patents going to do - write a strongly worded letter? If China decides it wants to get the latest ARM design and/or ISA in the future, do you doubt they can acquire them? Sure, they won't be able to call it "ARM" but you can bet it will be compatible[1]. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Wall_Peri#Fiat_Panda_copy_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Wall_Peri#Fiat_Panda_cop...
- Andrew_nenakhov 6y agoThey wouldn't be able to sell products with this 'acquired' architecture to anyone. Just ask how Huawey sales are doing in US and Europe.
- inglor_cz 6y agoFor internal market, no, but they will have problems selling the pirate copies to the rest of the world. Most rich states do respect intellectual property.
- phendrenad2 6y ago(1) What you linked does not appear to be an ARM patent. (2) Even if it were, lack of big/little scheduling is hardly going to bring China's homegrown chip market to it's knees. And that's assuming the patent is ironclad and can't be worked around.
- saberience 6y agoThe bigger question is more, what use is a homegrown chip market if no countries in the world are buying your chips?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- phendrenad2 6y agoTrue, if US companies are disallowed from giving licenses to Chinese companies, then likely the US would also block import of competing Chinese CPUs.
- _nedR 6y agoI haven't made CPUs before ( I am guessing you have?), so I am not sure of what you are implying. Are you saying that CPU technology is as easy or copy-able like a javascript framework? I can see that ISA would be copy-able. But what about a modern implementation?
- phendrenad2 6y agoCPU design is a mature field that has been studied extensively. I've thrown together a few toy CPUs, and studied some F/OSS RISC-V designs. New tricks are still being developed for modern software workloads and modern constraints (low-power is key now, whereas before other things might have been priority), but architecture things really haven't changed much since the 90s. My comparison with JS frameworks comes from my perception that CPU designs are all, kinda, the same. There are also a million ways to do things, but the core principles are obvious to people who study CPU design.