6 ms·
> The Hoover Foundation isn’t exactly unbiased. What does that mean? They’re a non-partisan think tank. They certainly have a free market point of view, but ev
by rayiner 6y ago
> The Hoover Foundation isn’t exactly unbiased.
What does that mean? They’re a non-partisan think tank. They certainly have a free market point of view, but every source has a point of view.
- pmoriarty 6y agoCondoleeza Rice its director, John Yoo is a Visiting Fellow, Donald Rumsfeld, Ed Meese, and Henry Kissinger are Distinguished Visiting Fellows. Non-partisan? Come on.
- rayiner 6y agoAnd what percentage of the New York Times editorial board is Democrats? I would still call the Times a non-partisan paper (albeit one with liberal leanings). A somewhat old (2000) Hoover Institution article notes that 1/4 of its Fellows are Democrats. I would be shocked if 1/4 of the Times editorial Board was Republicans. Or really if even one person on the Times editorial Board was a Republican.
- jacobolus 6y agoNot a single member of the NY Times editorial board ever worked in the White House (except as a reporter), worked as a full-time political operative, or the like. They’re all career journalists and scholars. It’s not remotely comparable to the Hoover Institution. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/opinion/editorialboard.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/opinion/editorialbo...
- rayiner 6y agoSure, because the Times is a newspaper and the Hoover Institute is a think tank. Part of the mission of a think tank requires having people with real world experience in government. I don’t think that’s a good proxy of whether the work is politically biased (rather than ideologically biased). Arguably, the Times is more overtly politically biased with its new “moral clarity” angle.
- jjeaff 6y agoI think if they didn't have an agenda, at least with this specific topic, they would have included data on other states to compare to.
- stagehn 6y agoYou're missing the point. Their bias doesn't come from whether they've literally worked in the White House, it comes from their political beliefs and how strongly those beliefs are held. How many in the NYT vocally support the Republican Party vs vocally support the Democratic Party?
- verylittlemeat 6y agoThe parent did say editorial board but I would suggest that a criticism of the NYTimes in the same spirit that actually warrants attention is its board of directors. Many if not all of them are wealthy lifelong democrats. I'm not trying to move the goal posts on you, just pointing out what I think was the original intent of the comment that - that left or right you should always follow the money.
- jacobolus 6y agoNot a single member of the NYT board of directors ever worked in the White House or worked as a full-time political operative either. They’re a mix of people from the journalism industry and people who had senior management roles in other kinds of businesses: some lawyers, some finance people, etc. https://www.nytco.com/board-of-directors/ https://www.nytco.com/board-of-directors/ I certainly have problems with the NYT. It is generally pro-corporate and pro-establishment. It is under strong pressure to accept bullshit at face value, and often succumbs (e.g. in the run up to the Iraq War). It tends far too strongly towards nonsensical “bothsidesism” There are also a lot of excellent journalists working there, and they do a lot of important work. So it’s a mixed bag.
- areyousure 6y agoJohn W. Rogers, Jr. "was a leading campaigner for ... Bill Bradley's 2000 United States presidential campaign" and "served as a fundraising leader in Project Vote efforts led by former United States President Barack Obama". "He was part of the inner circle of the Barack Obama presidential campaign. He is a long-time Obama associate who serves as the co-chair of Obama's Illinois finance committee and who has been a major fundraiser for Democratic Party candidates. He served along with Bill Daley, Pat Ryan, Penny Pritzker and Julianna Smoot on Barack Obama 2009 presidential inauguration committee." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_W._Rogers_Jr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_W._Rogers_Jr.
- jacobolus 6y agoHe’s a rich finance guy who is a major campaign contributor and fundraiser. That’s not the same as being a political operative, working in the White House, or the like. For example, Brian McAndrews (also on the NYT board of directors) maxed out his campaign contributions to the RNC, Mitt Romney, GOP PACs, etc. But he also isn’t a political operative.
- refurb 6y ago7% of reporters identify as Republicans versus 28% identify as Democrats.[1] If we're going to play the "this source is biased" with every article published on HN, then we're going to see a lot of "people should know this paper has a Democratic bias". [1]https://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2014/05/survey-7-percent-of-reporters-identify-as-republican-188053 https://www.politico.com/blogs/media/2014/05/survey-7-percen...
- pmoriarty 6y agoIt's media owners who decide the direction of their holdings, not the lowly reporter on the beat.
- refurb 6y agoI don't think that true, but if it was, that would be even worse since every single reporter for the NYTimes would have to tow the Democratic line. Thank god it's not that bad (they still will have a right-leaning opinion column once a month or so).
- davidivadavid 6y agoFrom what I remember from the Gentzkow/Shapiro work on media bias, media owners isn't really the source of bias. Paraphrasing, it turns out the bias comes from... the readers, who want a paper where they can read what pleases them.
- rayiner 6y agoOne amazing fact is that the Democrat:Republican skew among reporters is higher than almost every group traditionally perceived to skew Democratic. Gay people, for example, skew Democrat versus Republican closer to 3:1. But circling back, this is a theme. Conservative organizations and think tanks (Federalist Society is another example) have more Democrats than putatively objective professions (journalism, academia) have Republicans. That’s bad.
- taurath 6y agoGay people are not 3:1. You’re making up statistics to further your argument, but it’s not helping. Any source I’ve seen in terms of voting record and polling it’s 5:1 or higher. https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/record-lgbt-support-democrats-midterms-nbc-news-exit-poll-shows-n934211 https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/record-lgbt-support-...
- messick 6y agoGuessing the NYTimes has less than 3 people on its board that would be put on trial for war crimes at the ICC if the US didn’t forbid it, which isn’t something an org with Yoo, Kissinger, and Rumsfeld can say.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 6y agoThe Hoover Institution is aligned with the Republican Party. It has been since it was named after Herbert Hoover, a Republican president. Like the Nixon library, it exists primarily to redeem the reputation of its namesake. (For those who need a refresher, Hoover's policies nearly destroyed America during the Great Depression and he spent the rest of his life trying to convince the world that unrestrained free markets and supply side economics was the cure all for everything.
- rayiner 6y agoYou sound like you need a refresher on both Hoover and the Institution.
- gamblor956 6y agoMy source was the Hoover Institution's website... Perhaps you should do some research before defending an ideological propaganda organization that has spent decades promoting economic theories that have been shown not to work. For this particular opinion piece, they're including data from two economic downturns while excluding the growth period between them.
- rayiner 6y agoI don’t know what planet you live in, but we are entering the fifth decade of the Hoover Institution’s ideas being so widely recognized as effective that countries in Western Europe have been undoing their previous approaches at top-down governance to implement decentralized free market ones. Sweden has partially privatized its social security and has cut corporate tax rates to 21%. Denmark has gotten rid of its communications regulator. Macron is preaching Hoover-Institution style reform to a sclerotic France. (Heck it’s been so popular in Europe that the US is falling behind in deregulation and privatization, such as with the Post Office.) Meanwhile, we are entering the fourth decade of the “New Democrat” party in the United States, which had to wholesale adopt small government ideas from Republicans in order to remain electorally relevant. It’s traditionally left wing economic ideas that have been soundly repudiated over the last five decades. A return to left-wing economics was just soundly rejected again in the US (Sanders) and the U.K. (Corbyn).
- dragonwriter 6y agoIt's a right-wing ideological propaganda mill; it's “non-partisan” in the trivial sense that, like most “think tanks”, it has no formal control by a political party, and in the slightly more substantive (but also directly opposed to what most people try to communicate by “non-partisan” in terms of political bias) sense that, also like most ideological propaganda mills, it is devoted to an ideology much narrower than the big-tent views of either of the US’s major parties, which are both somewhat opportunistically shifting coalitions.
- rayiner 6y agoBy your metric, nearly every newspaper is a “left-wing ideological propaganda mill.” (My litmus test for that is whether the publication will credulously print the demonstrable untruth that “schools are underfunded” or “teachers are underpaid”).
- dragonwriter 6y ago>>By your metric, nearly every newspaper is a “left-wing ideological propaganda mill.” No, my metric is whether pushing an ideology is the overt mission, which it is for ideological “think tanks”, including Hoover.
- matchbok 6y agoThe fact that I know many teachers who still have to buy pencils for their students proves how wrong you are.
- JamesBarney 6y agoThis isn't necessarily due to underfunding. Parents are supposed to provide their children school supplies. And many teachers are reimbursed for that. Probably a better metric is dollars spent per student.