8 ms·
XOR patent ended CD32, and Commodore-Amiga
- Sodaware 16y agoHere's the patent in question: http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT4197590 http://www.google.com/patents?vid=USPAT4197590
- al_james 16y agoAlthough I used to be a huge Amiga fan, I think that Amigas of the time lagged behind other systems for gaming. PC's having chunky display formats (as opposed to plainer (planer?) on the Amiga) meant that PC's could do far more 3D graphics than a equivalently powered Amiga, and Amigas were often underpowered anyway. The Amiga kicked ass at 2D games, but could not hack it in 3D. At the end of the day, had the Amiga been a viable business, $10M in patent fines would not have killed them off.
- brudgers 16y agoIn 1988 there was nothing like Calagari on the PC side for 3d graphics - at least not at an accessible price running on accessible hardware (1meg A500/M68000) from floppy disk - e.g. Autdesk's AutoShade was $1000 without a modeler and views could not be updated interactively as they could with Calagari. In other words, Autoshade was in the same price range as the entire Calagari system (sans monitor) and required several thousand dollars in additional software resources. Considering the the cost of the 80287 math coprocessors required by the modeler (ACAD) and the costs of VGA adapters in 1987, the cost of doing 3D graphics on a PC was substantially more than the Amiga.
- al_james 16y agoSorry, I was talking more about 3D games, in particular those that became popular around the time Doom came out (1993) which is the same year the CD32 was released. The Amiga was great for 3D production graphics. Software such as Lightwave and Imagine 3D punched way above its weight (and cost) for a while.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- psykotic 16y ago> plainer (planer?) Planar. Bitplaned graphics was definitely an impediment to efficient rasterization. But when you look at what demo sceners have done with 3D on the Amiga, it's hard to argue that was its main downfall. What killed the Amiga was stagnation in both technology and marketing. It also never had much of a foothold as a non-gaming machine in the home. The IBM-compatible PC was the focus of innovation from many different companies. It wasn't a one-vendor platform like the Amiga. That is the ultimate cause of its demise. If the fate of the PC had stayed tied to IBM, it would have suffered the same end. Apple had a similar problem with the Macintosh in the 1990s and it almost killed them. If Apple's stewardship ever wavers, that is sure to happen again. It will take a lot more before it can become an immortal (undead?) platform like the PC.
- al_james 16y ago> Planar Thanks.
- eftpotrm 16y agoThe planar mode graphics had been a benefit in the more memory restricted days before; it was starting to become a problem but still, at that point Amigas tended to play the games of the day better than PCs costing 3x as much until Doom pushed 3D to the forefront. There were enough 3D games on Amigas, but Doom was a level beyond them for a while. Still, I did enjoy Acid Software's Gloom which wasn't that far behind. As a hardware platform, it was more closely tied to the individual chips but that was rapidly fading, with OS abstraction APIs for sound and graphics coming in around then. As a software platform, while it lacked MMU-dependent features, in other ways it had major benefits. Small, fast, pretty tidy, modular, customisable. Quite frankly I'd still like something to replace the Amiga's Datatypes concept, 20 years later. A sad loss to computing. To this day I'm baffled how Commodore managed to lose the not-PC slot to Apple in spite of having cheaper harder with more features and a vastly more capable operating system. I've said before here; if Commodore had done their job properly, we'd be saying Steve Who?
- psykotic 16y agoI loved the C64 and the Amiga. They were my first and second computer. But it's painfully clear in retrospect that Commodore never stood a chance. Jack Tramiel ran the show like a cigar-puffing industrialist straight out of a Dickens novel. There was none of Gates's vision of computing or Jobs's sense of quality from the top of the company. The Amiga line was developed almost entirely outside Commodore and then bought up and brought in house.
- rbanffy 16y agoI wouldn't blame Tramiel for Commodore's demise either. The Amiga was a very fine platform and Tramiel is also behind the ST line (called, at that time, "Jackintosh") after departing to Atari. The ST line was truer to the Commodore of the VIC and 64 era in that it was simple (much simpler than the Amiga), powerful (somewhat less than the Amiga) and inexpensive. At that time, nobody was predicting the collapse of the PC market around the IBM PCs (which were much more expensive than the home computers of the mid-to-late 80's and much clunkier).
- jerf 16y ago
- kenjackson 16y agoRealistically the Amiga and CD32 were dead by the time 3D PC gaming came out (although it was still my main machine at the time, but I knew I was on a dead platform).
- neild 16y agoThe Amiga kicked ass at 2D games, but could not hack it in 3D. The Amiga was effectively dead before 3D games became notable.
- brlewis 16y agoIt's easy for HN to see that the XOR patent is obvious, and not just in hindsight. Convincing a court is not so easy. The solution is not to get rid of quote-unquote bad software patents, but to adhere to the Supreme Court precedents that make software per se non-statutory. Any patent whose novelty and non-obviousness is claimed only in software should rightly be invalid.
- monochromatic 16y ago> Supreme Court precedents that make software per se non-statutory Got a citation for that? I didn't think so.
- brlewis 16y agoI agree with the citations from the 1970s here: http://www.bitlaw.com/software-patent/history.html http://www.bitlaw.com/software-patent/history.html I disagree with their description of the 1981 Diehr opinion as saying "the only new feature of this invention was the timing process controlled by the computer". The dissent said this, not the majority. The dissent was based on the facts of the case, not law. Diehr was not a departure from earlier precedent. EDIT: Not only did the Court majority not say what bitlaw says in the Diehr opnion, they contradict it: "According to the respondents, the continuous measuring of the temperature inside the mold cavity, the feeding of this information to a digital computer which constantly recalculates the cure time, and the signaling by the computer to open the press, are all new in the art." http://brlewis.com/y/2004/diehr.htm http://brlewis.com/y/2004/diehr.htm
- monochromatic 16y agoTo the extent those old cases are in conflict with Bilski, they are not binding precedent.
- brlewis 16y agoWhat does Bilski say that conflicts with them?
- jefffoster 16y agoPrevious discussion here (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1545178 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1545178)
- EdwardMSmith 16y agoHmm, I wonder about the accuracy of this, specifically about CD32s not being imported. I worked, at that time, for the largest Amiga dealer in the US, and we built a couple hundred multimedia display kiosks using CD32s and Paravision SX-1s. We had no trouble getting them (well, other then the usual Commodore supply issues of the time). Oh, wow, found an old email about this: http://www.howtomakeanimations.info/cd32sx1mm300-problems http://www.howtomakeanimations.info/cd32sx1mm300-problems freaky.
- epmos 16y agoI remember reading about it at the time. As I recall, some units had gotten in before the majority were seized. I have a CD32 ( complete with an SX-1 ) in my garage that likely was one of your display kiosks at one time. I have never been quite as excited over a machine as when I got my Amiga 500. I had owned a Commodore Plus/4 and a 128 since middle school and high school, and bought the 500 to start college. It was quite an amazing little machine for it's day. Then again, I haven't ever been 17 again either, so that might explain it.
- EdwardMSmith 16y agoWow, I have a few cd32 discs in the basement somewhere - want them? We would distribute burned CDs containing graphic, sound, and video/animation assets to the customers. This was '94, and if I remember correctly blank cds were something like $8-10 each (and the burner must have been close to $1000), and the burning process was so fragile that I'd burn discs at night just to try to prevent any possible issues due to vibration, or power fluctuations, or whatever other gremlins caused burn failures. I think we still had only like an 75%-ish success rate. Fun time, though.
- StudyAnimal 16y agoI remember when I had a C64, and my friend wanted a computer for xmas, and we were pestering his had to get the 128, which was the best computer we knew of at the time. Then on xmas day, he got an Amiga 500! We didn't even know about those. He was pretty happy. I was pretty bummed I only had a C64.
- rbanffy 16y agoErm... I see XOR for blinking cursors is obvious and should never be patented, but to blame only that for Amiga's demise is... a bit of an exaggeration. Management deserves most - in fact, almost all - of the credit for driving Commodore into the ground. It's such a shame. Commodore made great computers. The Amiga had sort of an identity problem. It was born a videogame console and NTSC timing was pervasive throughout the system and that made the design more complex as the machines evolved. They should have gotten rid of that as soon as they launched their second-generation machines.
- rsbrown 16y agoTo be fair, the author does not claim that the XOR patent was to blame for Commodore's demise. Rather, the claim is that: 1) Management "bet the farm" on CD32. 2) XOR patent infringement claims killed CD32. 3) The failure of the CD32 product was the last nail in the coffin. Tragic. I loved my Amiga 500 dearly. It makes one wonder what might have happened if Commodore could have held on for a few more years and (perhaps under new management) ridden the wave of internet-driven hardware sales to new heights.
- Maci 16y agoTechnically the Amiga Platform has always been rather agnostic about it's timing & video output. It spits out PAL / NTSC / RGBS in various funky resolutions, all you have to do is ask or set a jumper depending on the model. Secondly if it wasn't for this spot on NTSC carrier frequency that the Amiga could output we would never have seen products such as the Video Toaster. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Toaster http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Video_Toaster Or this oddity, the A2024 with a 10hz-15hz refresh rate: http://www.amiga-hardware.com/showhardware.cgi?HARDID=863 http://www.amiga-hardware.com/showhardware.cgi?HARDID=863
- zandorg 16y agoVaguely related, is that I once hooked up a monochrome VGA monitor to my Amiga 1200 by soldering the monitor's cable to a suitable Amiga video connector, and setting it up to be 640x480 VGA in the OS settings. Worked a treat!
- 16y ago
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- joeycfan 16y agoThe fact that someone can patent a fundamental of set theory is wrong. And history will look back on it as witch burnings.
- nekoZonbi 16y agoSomehow, when I was a kid, and I got my first computer, it was an Amiga 3000. The amiga was already dying, but as a kid I was not able to at first realize that. What personally killed the Amiga for me, was the graphics power. The Amiga 3000 "enhanced chipset", best graphic mode was 320x200 with 64 colors (extra half brigth). Meanwhile, PC VGA displays 800x600 and 1024x768 256 colors were starting to become popular on the PC side. The Amiga was clearly behind. The Amiga was also capable of 640x400, but only with 16 colors. And the "HAM" mode, 4096 simultaneos colors on low res 320x200, suffered from "color fringing" and was mostly unusable. What would have made me happy back then, was a 736 x 482 overscan mode with 4096 real simultaneous colors. I wish I could restore all the game demos that I made back then with Amos Basic. lots of simple games, a basic doom clone, musical apps, etc. I would love to give a look at that code again.