11 ms·
"What did the researchers find? Simply put, a gas that shouldn’t be there, and on Earth is considered a conclusive biosignature: phosphine, a very stinky gas.
by hutzlibu 6y ago
"What did the researchers find?
Simply put, a gas that shouldn’t be there, and on Earth is considered a conclusive biosignature: phosphine, a very stinky gas. As far as scientists know, there are only two ways to produce it, either artificially in a lab, or by certain kinds of microbes that live in oxygen-free environments. Since it is rather unlikely there any alien labs on Venus, that leaves microbes."
Or it reveals, that we still don't really know what is going on on venus, which chaotic atmosphere and vulcanic activity might very well result in the specific "lab conditions" to create phosphine.
So, it is a very interesting find, worth investigating, but I just for the existence of a gas, I would not shout "proof of alien life", yet.
- avmich 6y agoInteresting. > As far as scientists know, there are only two ways to produce it, either artificially in a lab, or by certain kinds of microbes that live in oxygen-free environments. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphine Philippe Gengembre (1764–1838), a student of Lavoisier, first obtained phosphine in 1783 by heating phosphorus in an aqueous solution of potash (potassium carbonate).[4][5]
- heavenlyblue 6y agoSo you can obtain it without microbes?
- saberdancer 6y agoYes, the article was clear on that. There are methods to produce it "naturally" or in a lab, but no explanation fits the amount of gas they have detected. So either they do not understand conditions on Venus, there is a new method to produce it or there is a microbe producing it.
- throwaway316943 6y agoAnd how do you propose to obtain elemental phosphorus in the atmosphere of Venus? As a side note, phosphorus is actually named after Venus the morning star, light bearer, etc because it is highly reactive and glows slightly in the presence of oxygen.
- gus_massa 6y ago> And how do you propose to obtain elemental phosphorus in the atmosphere of Venus? The second preparation method in Wikipedia looks more plausible https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphine#Laboratory_routes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphine#Laboratory_routes > 4 H3PO3 → PH3 + 3 H3PO4 > Phosphine evolution occurs around 200 °C (400°F). But I only have a Chemistry specialization in my secondary school and I am not an astrogeologer.
- perl4ever 6y agoIs it possible a previous space probe seeded the atmosphere though? For example, did the Soviets sterilize all the Venera probes perfectly?
- felipemnoa 6y ago>>Is it possible a previous space probe seeded the atmosphere though? Even if this were the case, it would still be quite amazing.
- hutzlibu 6y agoHell yeah, a microbe released on Venus atmosphere decades ago and has not only survived, but produces already a measurable atmospheric effect? That would be a amazing sensation. Terraforming would then be much, much easier, than expected. But I doubt it.
- bsder 6y agoAn Earth microbe evolving to be suddenly Venus-adjusted would possibly be more stunning than just "life evolved on Venus".
- gremlinsinc 6y agoI disagree, close in proximity to 'stunning', however, finding true unique life that originated on a planet by itself organically goes a long way towards proving/disproving the fermi paradox. I think it was maybe Carl Sagan who said (something like): if we find life in our solar system it's probably game over for us, as it means the great filter is likely ahead of us, not behind us. Though, you can take one look at the world right now, and not see how easy it would be to just destroy it if we aren't careful (and we're not being careful).
- thechao 6y agoI agree with Nick Lane: the great filter is likely to be the Eukaryotic event.