5 ms·
I work for a government software development team (At least for the next week). I have other friends in other governments on other teams. I can’t see a governm
by MattGaiser 6y ago
I work for a government software development team (At least for the next week). I have other friends in other governments on other teams.
I can’t see a government being able to build generalized software or contribute effectively to it. Governments don’t tend to have people who say no to feature requests. The end result is not a generalized good solution, but extremely specific solutions built on a generalized platform of if statements and endless configuration setups with special cases weaved through.
Governments are used to getting to decree everything from the button shade to the location of the buttons (different departments might ask for different button placements and get it) to the database type used (for the same piece of software) to the cloud vendor to all manner of additional features that require threading them through the core software. They want piles of exceptions and special cases. They want every possible scenario from the paper based days to be included in the software or it is not sufficient for their purposes. They want to specify date formats. They want to have very custom reports.
To use OSS, you basically need a generalized thing many people can use. But each government department will rapidly make it far from generalized.
- salimancer 6y ago100% agree. I do R&D in the defense industry and scope creep is an absolute nightmare. The only times I get to say no are when the laws of physics dictate so.
- oska 6y agoYou're assuming the government controls the development process. That's not the objective (and frankly, FOSS licences works against control, as any party can fork the code). Rather, the suggestion is for governments to support FOSS developers, just as they do the arts community, without directly dictating what work they do. If they want a project extended in a certain way they can pay directly for that development, but they should do it on the back of an existing product that serves the general community and feed useful development of the software from their extension back into the general development tree.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoStandards may help commoditize the more fundamental parts. It was the government that created ASCII and SQL after all. At least back when they cared about competition.
- boxed 6y agoThere are much more constructive ways government can help. They can for example fund the core devs of programming languages, databases and similar foundational systems. A lot of this work is now done part time on their free time.
- de_watcher 6y agoA typical FOSS has already a lot of customizability. Yes, they want to have a lot of specific stuff, but it isn't that dramatic.