3 ms·
Reasonably measured take on the story from the FT: https://www.ft.com/content/8a8a2396-6e97-4cfd-9f80-c5aaa2de304f https://www.ft.com/content/8a8a2396-6e97-4cf
by samizdis 6y ago
Reasonably measured take on the story from the FT:
https://www.ft.com/content/8a8a2396-6e97-4cfd-9f80-c5aaa2de304f https://www.ft.com/content/8a8a2396-6e97-4cfd-9f80-c5aaa2de3...
Sadly, I've not been able to find a non-paywalled version syndicated anywhere else. (Although it can be retrieved at archive.is)
Some interesting quotes from the article:
In this relentless barrage of hype, delivered in a disarmingly low-key manner, it is easy to forget the reality. Nikola has yet to put any vehicles into production. And, as its regulatory filings make clear, it has no orders at all for its fuel cell trucks, only non-binding reservations.
As for all the technological brilliance ... there is precious little to be seen. Nikola boasts a grand total of only 11 patents in the US, with another 55 applications pending.
And later:
Nikola faked a video of one of its trucks by making it look like the vehicle was driving under its own power when it was really only rolling downhill, according to Hindenburg’s report — a claim backed up by FT reporting this week.
“It was built to be a working prototype,” Mr Russell insists of the truck.
But did it actually work? His answer, after a long pause: “I wouldn’t comment on that.”
In its pay-off, the FT draws pointed comparisons with Theranos.
A good read, wherever the truth lies.
- imglorp 6y agoI'm a little curious about the (allegedly?) rigged demos. There's dozens of youtube garage tinkers who could slam some off the shelf parts into a random salvage chassis in under a week. Maybe they won't meet many performance targets but they'll at least be able to show something moving under its own power. The point is, making one electric or H2 vehicle is a very low bar now. Making one manufacturable, and a production line to do it, is the hard problem. So why show a nonworking sham?
- jboog 6y agoYeah you're right, it's all so bizarre. This dude IPOd a unicorn startup and is (for now) a billionaire by selling a vision of a manufacturing company with a non-working prototype that literally almost anyone with modest engineering skills could pull off. The Founder has no engineering background (in fact no college degree), no experience in the vehicle industry, no brilliant engineers or killer patent on technology. It smelled super fishy when they first IPO'd but I figured since all these VCs and vehicle manufacturers were partnering with them there must be something under the hood. Now it seems like such a transparent fraud. How did so many people that should have known better get conned into this?
- samizdis 6y agoSee electrek article Nikola admits to faking video of driving prototype [1] And also Nikola press release [2], which states: "As Nikola pivoted to the next generation of trucks, it ultimately decided not to invest additional resources into completing the process to make the Nikola One drive on its own propulsion." [1] https://electrek.co/2020/09/14/nikola-nkla-admits-faking-video-driving-prototype-weak-response/ https://electrek.co/2020/09/14/nikola-nkla-admits-faking-vid... [2] https://nikolamotor.com/press_releases/nikola-sets-the-record-straight-on-false-and-misleading-short-seller-report-96 https://nikolamotor.com/press_releases/nikola-sets-the-recor...
- alokrai 6y agounpaywalled FT article: https://archive.is/jMLkh https://archive.is/jMLkh