3 ms·
There is an even simpler explanation: some moral principles push people towards a game-theoretic optimum, so evolution selects for it. Eg, a society that allow
by roenxi 6y ago
There is an even simpler explanation: some moral principles push people towards a game-theoretic optimum, so evolution selects for it.
Eg, a society that allows random murders will be at a staggering disadvantage. By magic, most (all?) societies have strong moral arguments against murder. Ditto honesty - honest societies have structural advantages.
Any cooperative species will have something that looks like morality. Even ants practice first aid.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI feel those explanations are complementary. Being a product of evolution, the brain has some game-theoretic principles encoded in it. And with capability of conscious thought, communication, and later language and writing, we learn to recognize and apply game-theoretic principles more abstractly. Culture is, in part, game theory in form of heuristics. On the other hand, where game theory says some choice is arbitrary, the brain can have a default encoded - and that default will be universal across humans.
- bobthechef 6y ago"Optimum" is a moral notion. You're begging the question.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoNot in game-theoretic sense, and not in evolutionary sense.
- mannykannot 6y agoI don't think so. In this view, the concepts of what constitutes ethical behavior have arisen from individuals coming to understand what sort of society is most likely to give the best outcome according to their own long-term self interest. This is no more begging the question than the concept of survival of the fittest in theories of evolution, the point being that there is a coherent concept of fitness in that case, and self-interest in this one. In both cases, the question being addressed is "how did we arrive at the current state of affairs, when other outcomes are at least logically possible?"
- karmakaze 6y agoThis is quite hand-wavy and not solidly founded. Some things that fall out from evolution align with advantages some do not. An example might be that 'allowing' a low rate of random murders may not have any practical difference in outcomes but humans are concerned with personal safety an a random event may apply to anyone so everyone (over) reacting would be the norm but not optimal in a game-theoretic sense. Negative bias leading to inaccurate judgements is such an example. > cooperative species will have something that looks like morality For the argument of the post to be valid, it has to apply to 'species' rather than a correlated subset.