6 ms·
Yeah, doesn't make sense. I prefer a simpler argument for why there is a subset of morality that's universal for (vast majority of) humans: argument from share
by TeMPOraL 6y ago
Yeah, doesn't make sense.
I prefer a simpler argument for why there is a subset of morality that's universal for (vast majority of) humans: argument from shared brain architecture.
We're essentially running the same wetware under the hood, at least on the time scales of human civilization. So while the universe doesn't necessarily privilege a set of values, human brains are. And that's all that really matters (until we meet aliens or start building conscious AIs) - conscious experience is a feature of brains, not laws of physics in general.
- Iv 6y agoI like the idea that morality is something that is built by mankind and that needs to be extracted by studies. For instance, economists have found the value at which US society estimates an American's life by seeing at which point risks balances costs in some hazardous investments.
- ukj 6y agoThis conception is highly susceptible to Goodhart's law. It favours the quantitative over the qualitative which is a good way to trip over the McNamara fallacy.
- Iv 6y agoI don't think so, if it is done properly. For instance you want a human life to be worth more but the only way for that to happen is to actually spend more to save human lives, which makes the value of life increase.
- ukj 6y agoWhat is your standard for "properness" ?
- Iv 6y agoIn this context, "that can't be tricked the way you propose". If you accurately measure the value human society puts on life (that is, avoiding the bias of, e.g. considering only a part of the population that may be privileged) then your only way to trick the metric is by actually increasing the value of human lives.
- ukj 6y agoWhat is your standard for "accuracy" ?
- Iv 6y agoWhy do every "philosophical" debate ends up with "let's play semantic and never address the question being actually debated?" Philosophy is about answering real, deep questions, not about trying to find smart ways to pretend your interlocutor is confusing when defining a field that is characterized by the vagueness of the concepts it explores. Either make an effort to understand what your interlocutor mean or explicit why the ambiguity your perceive is relevant. I am arguing that morality is something subjective, created by human society, but that can therefore be measured with the tools of human sciences, like economics. You are arguing that an improper way to measure it would lead to bad outcomes, which I agree with but I fail to see how it addresses the question. Do you think a proper way to measure it is impossible (and the meaning for "proper" here, is, OBVIOUSLY, "that does not lead to the outcomes you outline")? If so can you explain why you think so?
- ukj 6y agoOn the one hand you dislike semantics, on the other hand you want me to understand your meaning. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ I am arguing that the social aspect of morality isn't about measurement, but about whose yardstick we should be using. Said differently: How do we calibrate our measurement instruments? Man is the measure of all things. --Protagoras.
- 6y ago
- mannykannot 6y agoMaybe, but a measure of the phenomenon is not an explanation of how human societies came to have an ethical aspect. It is also possible that the metric is considering only one aspect of a society's ethical position, especially given that things like trolley problems, and some of the things that are done in the name of nominally ethical religions, suggest that people are not consistently rational in their ethical thinking and behavior. One might, for example, value another's life purely on the economic value it is to oneself - would that be an ethical position or the absense of one? I don't doubt that one could make some sort of argument for the former, but ethics are really only interesting when they are at odds with perceived self-interest.
- Iv 6y agoThe idea is to not look at individual choices but at the aggregate of choices made and measure what mankind considers good.
- mannykannot 6y agoThe aggregate of choices is a consequence of what individuals choose, and to try to ignore that is to avoid the issues that determine the outcome.
- Iv 6y agoI am not sure how? Quite the contrary, stating that "good is what the society decides" is a way to solve contradictions in individual choices. That's not my stance, btw, but that's a morality framework that is coherent.
- mannykannot 6y ago> I am not sure how? Quite the contrary, stating that "good is what the society decides" is a way to solve contradictions in individual choices. It seems to me a way to avoid considering the contradictions in individual choices, which is where many of the interesting issues of ethics lie. This stance may be coherent in its own terms (and quantifiable, 'objective' and so forth), but I am skeptical that it yields much insight, and I think it is wise of you to not adopt it. Does this stance offer any specific counter-arguments to the specific points I raised in my original post in this thread? Does it, for example, refute my claim that "a measure of the phenomenon is not an explanation of how human societies came to have an ethical aspect?"
- roenxi 6y agoThere is an even simpler explanation: some moral principles push people towards a game-theoretic optimum, so evolution selects for it. Eg, a society that allows random murders will be at a staggering disadvantage. By magic, most (all?) societies have strong moral arguments against murder. Ditto honesty - honest societies have structural advantages. Any cooperative species will have something that looks like morality. Even ants practice first aid.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoI feel those explanations are complementary. Being a product of evolution, the brain has some game-theoretic principles encoded in it. And with capability of conscious thought, communication, and later language and writing, we learn to recognize and apply game-theoretic principles more abstractly. Culture is, in part, game theory in form of heuristics. On the other hand, where game theory says some choice is arbitrary, the brain can have a default encoded - and that default will be universal across humans.
- bobthechef 6y ago"Optimum" is a moral notion. You're begging the question.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoNot in game-theoretic sense, and not in evolutionary sense.
- mannykannot 6y agoI don't think so. In this view, the concepts of what constitutes ethical behavior have arisen from individuals coming to understand what sort of society is most likely to give the best outcome according to their own long-term self interest. This is no more begging the question than the concept of survival of the fittest in theories of evolution, the point being that there is a coherent concept of fitness in that case, and self-interest in this one. In both cases, the question being addressed is "how did we arrive at the current state of affairs, when other outcomes are at least logically possible?"
- 6y ago